IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA745/2009
[2010] NZCA 158BETWEENBRENT DAVID GILBERT
Appellant
ANDTHE QUEEN
Respondent
Hearing:13 April 2010
Court:Hammond, Chisholm and Priestley JJ
Counsel:P F Gorringe for Appellant
K Raftery for Respondent
Judgment:30 April 2010 at 2.30 pm
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
A An extension of time to file the appeal is granted.
B The appeal is dismissed.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Priestley J)
The appeal
[1] The appellant stood trial in May 2009 in the Tauranga District Court. He faced a total of 12 counts laid variously under ss 219, 220, 228, and 229A of the Crimes Act 1961 involving dishonesty. The jury found him guilty on all 12 counts.
[2] Judge Rollo, who had presided over the trial, sentenced the appellant to concurrent terms of imprisonment. The lead sentence, imposed on nine of the 12 counts, was four years imprisonment.
[3] The appellant challenges that sentence contending it is manifestly excessive.
Background
[4] The offending took place over a period of approximately 22 months between May 2003 and March 2005. The victim, at the time of sentencing, was an 88 year old woman. She was a friend of the appellant’s grandmother. The appellant had known her for most of his life.
[5] In early 2003 the appellant and his partner moved in to live with the victim and her then seriously ill husband. At the time the appellant was an undischarged bankrupt.
[6] The appellant befriended the elderly couple to the extent that they were both persuaded to sign enduring powers of attorney in his favour. The victim’s dying husband took that step in May 2008 shortly before his death. The next month, shortly after her husband’s death, the victim did likewise. As a bankrupt the appellant did not qualify to be a donee under a power of attorney.
[7] It is unnecessary to describe the offending in any detail. Monies were transferred from the accounts of the victim’s husband into the victim’s account with another bank. The appellant then arranged for the victim to open bank accounts with other banks in respect of which he was a signatory.
[8] After various inter-account transfers, a bank cheque, drawn on one of the victim’s accounts for $64,996, was paid to the appellant’s father. A few days later two further bank cheques for $87,000 each were withdrawn and deposited by the appellant into a solicitor’s trust account. The $174,000 involved in those two transactions was used to purchase a residential property in Tauranga, initially in the name of a company controlled by the appellant, and subsequently in the name of the appellant’s partner.
[9] The appellant transferred a further $5,000 from his victim’s account to his company in March 2005. That transaction, however, was detected by the victim and her bankers. The sum was repaid.
[10] Some time before sentencing the Tauranga property was sold. From its sale proceeds the victim was reimbursed $140,000. However, to achieve that result she had to embark…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gilbert v The Queen and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] NZCA 158
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that the court had to decide were whether the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive and whether the mitigating factors were adequately considered. The court had to examine the appellant's culpability, the aggravating circumstances, and the mitigating factors before determining if the sentence was appropriate. The appellant argued that the start point was too high by a margin of three to six months, and that a fifteen-month reduction for mitigating factors was appropriate. The Crown, on the other hand, argued that the start point was well within range and that a discount for remorse was inappropriate.
The court considered the appellant's culpability and the aggravating circumstances, such as the premeditation, breach of trust, the vulnerability of the victim, the duration of the offending, and the flouting of restrictions placed on him by the Insolvency Act. The court also considered the mitigating factors, such as the appellant's co-operation at trial and a late expression of remorse. The court held that the Judge was correct to factor into his culpability assessment the total $244,000 loss rather than the net loss. The court concluded that any adjustments to the components of the end sentence on their part would be mere tinkering, which they declined to do. Therefore, the appeal against sentence was dismissed.
The final orders of the court were that an extension of time to file the appeal is granted, but the appeal is dismissed. The Court of Appeal of New Zealand upheld the sentence imposed on the appellant, Brent David Gilbert, and rejected his appeal against the sentence.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi