IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CRI-2016-404-000324 [2016] NZHC 2676
BETWEEN ALLAN TREVOR GIBBS
Appellant
AND
MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT Respondent
Hearing: 7 November 2016 Counsel:
S D Withers for Appellant
G A Campbell for RespondentJudgment:
7 November 2016
ORAL JUDGMENT OF DOWNS J
Solicitors/Counsel:
S D Withers, Auckland.
Meredith Connell, Auckland.
GIBBS v MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT [2016] NZHC 2676 [7 November 2016]
The case
[1] This is a sentence appeal in relation to benefit fraud. On 8 September 2016
Judge Ronayne sentenced the appellant to a term of two years and three months’
imprisonment.1 The Judge also imposed reparation of almost $60,000.
[2] The background is simple. On 27 November 2007, the appellant applied for and was granted a sickness benefit, accommodation supplement, disability allowance, and an additional allowance for temporary support. All of the benefits were granted on the condition the appellant advise the Ministry of Social Development if his circumstances materially changed.
[3] Between January 2008 and April 2013 the appellant had a variety of jobs, but he did not tell the Ministry of them. Consequently, he received overpayments of
$97,002.82. The appellant was caught when the Inland Revenue Department shared information with the Ministry of Social Development.
[4] The appellant was interviewed on 3 October 2013. He said that he had told the Ministry about one of his jobs, but not the balance because he was too far into debt.
[5] The appellant was charged on 15 April 2014. He entered guilty pleas on
2 May 2016. The sequence in between was examined at some length by the Judge below. I need not do so. It is sufficient to observe on any analysis, the pleas of guilty were not entered promptly.
[6] The appellant is 65 years old. He has a history of fraud. In 1992 he was convicted of 29 charges of using a document for pecuniary advantage. In 2000 he was convicted of like-offending and also altering a document with intent to defraud. That too was benefit fraud. In 2005 the appellant was convicted of offences of making a false statement and misleading a Social Welfare officer. The appellant also has historical convictions for theft as a servant and using a document for a pecuniary
advantage.
1 Ministry of Social Development v Gibbs [2016] NZDC 17447.
[7] The Judge adopted a starting point of two years and three months’ imprisonment, which he uplifted by six months in light of the appellant’s recidivism. The Judge then applied discounts totalling six months: two months for what the Judge described as the appellant’s “mental health issues”; two months to reflect the appellant’s repayment of $37,160 to the Ministry; and two months in recognition of the appellant’s guilty pleas. As observed, the Judge also ordered reparation of
$59,842.82.
The arguments
[8] The appellant contends his sentence is manifestly excessive. He invites attention to allegedly inadequate discounts for mental health, guilty pleas and his voluntary repayments. That said; the appellant devoted most of his…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gibbs v Ministry of Social Development and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] NZHC 2676
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined whether the Judge erred in imposing the sentence, including the discounts for mental health issues, late guilty pleas, and voluntary repayments. The court found that the discounts were appropriate and that the overall sentence was within range. However, the court found that the reparation order would give rise to undue hardship and was unrealistic given Gibbs' circumstances. The court noted that at 65 years old, Gibbs would have little if any savings upon release from prison, and the debt of $60,000 would be crushing.
The appeal was allowed to the extent of quashing the reparation order, but the court dismissed the appeal otherwise. The court emphasised that Gibbs was still serving a significant term of imprisonment and had already repaid approximately 38% of the monies he stole. The quashing of the reparation order did not affect the Ministry of Social Development's ability to recover the monies by other means under the Social Security Act.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi