George v Sell Smart.biz Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2014-404-2139

[2020] NZHC 993

BETWEEN

ARIANA CAILEEN GEORGE

First Plaintiff

RODNEY LEE TE WAKA TOTO HOLLAND
Second Plaintiff

AND

SELL SMART.BIZ LIMITED

First Defendant (Discontinued)

DAVID CHARLES PADFIELD
Second Defendant (Discontinued)

PAUL DILKS

Third Defendant

Continued ….

Hearing: On the papers

Judgment:

14 May 2020


JUDGMENT OF KATZ J

[Costs]


This judgment was delivered by me on 14 May 2020 at 1:00pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:      Integritas Law Firm, Auckland Counsel: R S Pidgeon, Barrister, Auckland

Copy to:       Third Defendant

GEORGE & HOLLAND v DILKS [2020] NZHC 993 [14 May 2020]

TEA CUSTODIANS (BLUESTONE) LIMITED

Fourth Defendant (Discontinued)

PRENDOS NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Fifth Defendant (Discontinued)

Introduction

[1]    In  February  2007,  Ariana  George  entered  into  an  agreement  with   David Padfield to purchase a franchise and associated licence. Ms George and her then de facto partner, Rodney Holland, borrowed money from TEA Custodians (Bluestone) Ltd (“Bluestone”) to complete the purchase, secured by a mortgage over their family home. They defaulted on their repayments, following which the house was sold at mortgagee sale. The relationship between Ms George and Mr Holland ended not long afterwards.

[2]    In August 2014, Ms George and Mr Holland brought this proceeding against five defendants including Bluestone, Mr Padfield, and Paul Dilks, the mortgage broker who had helped arrange the Bluestone loan. They subsequently settled and/or discontinued against all defendants except Mr Dilks.

[3]    In 2016, Ms George assigned her litigation rights to Mr Holland. Ms George did not wish to continue with the proceeding in her own right, and acknowledged that any proceeds should go to Mr Holland, as the asset that had been lost was his family home (which his mother had significant equity in). Ms George appears to have had little or no equity in the home. The assignment was formally documented. The only relevant plaintiff from 2016 onwards, therefore, was Mr Holland. He has been legally aided at all material times.

[4]    At trial I found all four causes of action against Mr Dilks were time barred.1 I noted, however, that even if they had not been time barred the claims would likely have failed due to causation issues.

[5]As the successful party, Mr Dilks now seeks an award of costs.


1      George v Sell Smart.Biz Ltd [2019] NZHC 37. The first three causes of action were time barred under the Limitation Act 1950, s 28, and the fourth cause of action was time barred by analogy pursuant to the Limitation Act 1950, s 4(9).

Relevant legal principles

[6]    The successful party in litigation is normally entitled to an award of costs in their favour, together with reasonable disbursements.2 A litigant is only entitled, however, to recover costs incurred when they were legally represented, together with reasonable disbursements. They are not entitled to recompense for the time they have spent personally in bringing or defending proceedings.3

[7]    Pursuant to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read George v Sell Smart.biz Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 993
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In George v Sell Smart.biz Limited, Rodney Lee Te Waka Toto Holland brought proceedings against Paul Dilks, the mortgage broker who had assisted in arranging a loan for the purchase of a franchise. The proceedings were commenced in August 2014, but subsequently settled or discontinued against all defendants except Mr Dilks. The proceedings were assigned to Mr Holland in 2016, and at trial all causes of action against Mr Dilks were found to be time barred. The court was required to consider what costs and disbursements Mr Dilks was entitled to recover from Mr Holland, who was legally aided. The court found that no order for costs and disbursements could be made against Mr Holland, as he was legally aided. However, the court certified that it would have awarded disbursements of NZD 568.91 to Mr Dilks if he had not been legally aided.

The court considered whether it could make an order for costs against Mr Holland, who was legally aided. The court noted that a litigant is only entitled to recover costs incurred when they were legally represented, together with reasonable disbursements. It is not entitled to recompense for the time they have spent personally in bringing or defending proceedings. The court also noted that pursuant to the Legal Services Act 2011, no order for costs can be made against a legally aided party unless the court is satisfied that exceptional circumstances exist. Mr Dilks did not submit that exceptional circumstances exist here and there did not appear to be any. If the exceptional circumstances exception is not engaged, then the court may make an order specifying what order for costs would have been made against the legally aided party, if they had not received a grant of legal aid. The successful party is entitled to apply to the Legal Services Commissioner for payment of that sum. The Commissioner has a discretion as to whether or not to make any such payment, with reference to the conduct of the parties to the proceedings, the court’s finding of any exceptional circumstances or lack thereof, and the hardship caused to the applicant were the sums not to be paid.

The court then considered what order for costs would have been made against Mr Holland if he was not legally aided. Mr Dilks claimed costs and disbursements under four heads: (a) AUD 16,000 paid in Australia to lawyers who acted for Mr Dilks in related proceedings in Queensland; (b) AUD 24,255.87, paid by Mr Dilks to the New Zealand lawyers who represented him at an earlier stage of this proceeding, when he successfully applied to Associate Judge Bell to have a default judgment that had been entered against him set aside; (c) AUD 10,000 as a contribution towards interest payments on a AUD 50,000 loan taken out by Mr Dilks; and (d) AUD 550 incurred in respect of flights and a hotel room for the hearing before Katz J (Mr Dilks travelled from Australia for the trial). The Australian legal fees related to a proceeding outside the jurisdiction of the New Zealand courts, and so were not recoverable in these proceedings. Legal costs incurred in respect of the application to set aside the default judgment had already been determined by Associate Judge Bell, and so were not recoverable in these proceedings. Interest on the loan taken out by Mr Dilks was not properly claimable as disbursements in the context of the New Zealand proceeding. The travel and accommodation costs were conventional disbursements and unobjectionable. The quantum was clearly reasonable, indeed they appeared to be modest. If Holland had not been legally aided, therefore, Katz J would have awarded AUD 550 under this head. This equated to NZD 568.91 on 29 January 2020, the date of judgment.

Katz J certified that he would have awarded disbursements of NZD 568.91 to Mr Dilks if Mr Holland had not been legally aided. No order for costs and disbursements may be made against Mr Holland, as he is legally aided.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.