Geary v Accident Compensation Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TIMARU REGISTRY

CIV-2013-476-000299 [2014] NZHC 96

BETWEEN  IAN RUSSELL GEARY Applicant

ANDACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION

Respondent

Hearing:                   5 February 2014

Appearances:           A C Beck for Applicant

I G Hunt for Respondent

Judgment:                5 February 2014

JUDGMENT OF PANCKHURST J

Introduction

[1]      The  present  interlocutory  application  requires  the  determination  of  two questions.    The  proceeding  concerns  a  substantive  judgment  delivered  in  the District Court at Timaru on 23 July 2013.

[2]      The appellant, Mr Geary, had 20 working days in which to lodge an appeal against that judgment. The issues for determination are:

(a)       whether an appeal was brought within time; and

(b)      if not, whether an extension of time to appeal is appropriate.

GEARY v ACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION [2014] NZHC 96 [5 February 2014]

The substantive proceeding

[3]      Until 5 December 2002 Mr Geary was registered as an ACC recognised counsellor.  He is a psychologist by training and experience. A substantial part of his practice comprised affording treatment to ACC claimants.

[4]      On 7 July 2005 he issued the proceeding in the District Court alleging that he had not been paid in relation to 54 treatment claims, nor in relation to 534 travel allowance claims.  He sought payment of the sum of $63,173 plus interest and costs. Mr Geary represented himself throughout the long history of the proceeding. Eventually the case was heard in mid-2013 over six hearing days before Judge Maze. She released  a written judgment on  23 July 2013.   In  it she upheld  26 of the treatment claims, either in whole or in part.  By contrast, she rejected all of the 534 travel allowance claims.

[5]      In essence, the Judge found that there was no proof that services had been provided, that travel expenses were not claimable, or, alternatively, that there was no proof of non-payment of those claims which were not otherwise in dispute.

[6]      In the end result, Mr Geary won an award of $8,493 plus interest of $3,416. In percentage terms he recovered about 13 percent of the amount he had originally claimed.

[7]      The Accident  Compensation  Corporation  (the  Corporation)  sought  costs. Written submissions were called for and on 10 September, Judge Maze delivered a costs decision.  The Corporation succeeded in obtaining increased costs.  The sum awarded was $70,000 plus disbursements.

[8]      Mr Geary appealed against this decision, but in that instance there is no dispute that he filed and served the notice of appeal within time.

The substantive appeal

[9]      On  12  August  2013  Mr  Geary  filed  what  was  termed  an  interlocutory application  seeking  leave  to  appeal  and  an  “affidavit”  in  support.    In  fact,  the

affidavit was unsworn, although signed by Mr Geary.  It contained a series of factual assertions and then 17 grounds of appeal directed to the substantive judgment.

[10]   Despite the deficiencies of these documents, they did at least provide confirmation of Mr Geary’s intention to bring an appeal against the judgment. At the same time on 12 August Mr Geary filed his submissions in relation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Geary v Accident Compensation Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 96
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Geary v Accident Compensation Corporation, the High Court of New Zealand was called upon to decide whether an extension of time should be granted to the appellant, Mr Ian Russell Geary, to lodge an appeal against a substantive judgment delivered in the District Court. The substantive judgment, delivered by Judge Maze on 23 July 2013, upheld 26 of Mr Geary's treatment claims but rejected all 534 travel allowance claims, resulting in a recovery of approximately 13 percent of the amount claimed. Mr Geary had 20 working days to lodge an appeal against this judgment but failed to serve the appeal documents on the respondent, the Accident Compensation Corporation, within the required time. The issues before the court were whether an appeal was brought within time and, if not, whether an extension of time to appeal was appropriate.

The court found that there was insufficient evidence to confirm that Mr Geary had effectively served the appeal documents either by post or by email, as he had claimed. While Mr Geary maintained that he had sent hard copies by post and an email on 14 August 2013, neither the post office nor the email recipient confirmed receipt. The court considered the deeming provisions under the High Court Rules but found the evidence of non-receipt more compelling. Despite this, the court decided not to make final findings on the service issue and moved to consider whether an extension of time should be granted.

In assessing whether an extension of time should be granted, the court considered several factors, including the reason for the delay, the length of the delay, the conduct of the parties, and the extent of any prejudice caused by the delay. The court acknowledged that the delay was short and that no significant prejudice resulted from the failure to serve the documents on time. However, the court also noted that the appeal appeared to be without merit, but it refrained from making a final determination on this issue. Ultimately, the court found that the interests of justice favoured granting an extension of time, particularly given that Mr Geary had legal aid and had improved his grounds of appeal since the original filing. The court granted the extension of time and provided further directions for the appeal hearing.

In summary, the court granted an extension of time for Mr Geary to lodge his appeal, finding that the interests of justice favoured such an extension despite the apparent lack of merit in the appeal. The court also directed the parties to prepare for the appeal hearing and provided specific timetables and requirements for filing and serving the necessary documents.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.