Gary Owen Burgess v Susan Natalie Bevan

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

NOTE:  PURSUANT TO S 35A OF THE PROPERTY (RELATIONSHIPS) ACT 1976, ANY REPORT OF THIS PROCEEDING MUST COMPLY WITH SS 11B TO 11D OF THE FAMILY COURTS ACT 1980

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
SC 9/2011
[2011] NZSC 114

BETWEEN  GARY OWEN BURGESS
Applicant

AND  SUSAN NATALIE BEAVEN
Respondent

Court:             Elias CJ, Blanchard and William Young JJ

Counsel:         Applicant in person
S J Shamy for Respondent

Judgment:      22 September 2011

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

1We grant leave to appeal and cross-appeal (and an extension of time in relation to the cross-appeal).

2The approved grounds of appeal and cross-appeal proceed on the basis that the Court of Appeal’s assessment under s 14(2)(c) of the Property (Relationships) Act 1976 in favour of equal sharing was correct and are as follows:

(a)was the Court of Appeal in error in adopting separation date values;

(b)was there any logical or arithmetical error in the Court of Appeal’s identification and valuation of the relationship property and its allowances for post-separation contributions;

(c)should the Court of Appeal have made consequential orders in respect of the costs ordered in relation to earlier judgments and money paid by Mr Burgess to Ms Beaven; and

(d)what, if any, additional or other orders are required.

REASONS

  1. Mr Burgess seeks leave to appeal and Ms Beaven leave to cross-appeal (in her case out of time) against a judgment delivered on 20 December 2010 in which the Court of Appeal allowed an appeal by Mr Burgess in litigation between the parties as to their relationship property.[1]  The dispute between Mr Burgess and Ms Beaven has been long drawn out (a factor which itself has caused difficulty) and has also been much litigated in the Family Court, High Court and Court of Appeal; this despite the sums of money actually in issue being comparatively modest.

    [1]      Burgess v Beaven [2010] NZCA 625, [2011] NZFLR 609.

  2. Mr Burgess and Ms Beaven each owned a house when they married.  His house was sold to acquire a rural property and Ms Beaven’s house was retained until separation.  In quantifying the respective contributions of the parties, Judge Strettell valued (a) Mr Burgess’s contribution via his house at the net price for which it was sold early in the marriage, but (b) Ms Beaven’s contribution via her house by reference to the sale price later received (which included inflationary gains).[2]  And in carrying out this exercise, he did not allow anything to Mr Burgess for the increase in value of the rural property as at the date of separation over its acquisition cost.[3]  The associated conclusions provided the foundation for a finding by the Judge that Ms Beaven’s contribution to the marriage partnership had clearly been disproportionately greater than that of Mr Burgess and he directed a division of the relationship property on a 65:35 basis in her favour.[4]  Mr Burgess’s appeal to John Hansen J against Judge Strettell’s decision was successful on other points but not in relation to this issue.[5]  Mr Burgess later applied…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gary Owen Burgess v Susan Natalie Bevan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZSC 114
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Gary Owen Burgess v Susan Natalie Bevan involves a long-standing dispute between the parties regarding the division of their relationship property. This dispute has been subject to extensive litigation across various courts in New Zealand, including the Family Court, High Court, and Court of Appeal, despite the relatively modest sums involved. The Supreme Court of New Zealand granted leave for both appeal and cross-appeal, extending time for the latter, and addressing the appeal on the basis that the Court of Appeal's assessment in favour of equal sharing under s 14(2)(c) of the Property (Relationships) Act 1976 was correct.

The legal issues the Court had to decide primarily revolved around the valuation of the contributions made by each party to the marriage. Specifically, the Court had to determine whether the Court of Appeal correctly assessed the separation date values and if there were any logical or arithmetical errors in the identification and valuation of the relationship property and allowances for post-separation contributions. Additionally, the Court examined whether the Court of Appeal should have made consequential orders regarding the costs ordered in earlier judgments and money paid by Mr. Burgess to Ms. Beaven.

The Court's reasoning focused on whether the Court of Appeal correctly adopted the separation date values and if there were any errors in the valuation process. The Court found that Mr. Burgess's argument that the value of the houses should be assessed at the time they became relationship property was valid. However, it dismissed the appeal on the point of timing of valuation, as Ms. Beaven had adequately presented all relevant financial details to the Court. Consequently, the Court decided to grant an extension of time for the cross-appeal to allow for a comprehensive review of the Court of Appeal's judgment. The Court emphasized the importance of the parties preparing calculations for the division of relationship property based on both separation date and hearing date values, encouraging them to reach agreements where possible.

The final orders of the Court include granting leave to appeal and cross-appeal, extending time for the cross-appeal, and directing the parties to prepare detailed calculations for the division of relationship property, with an expectation that they may settle the case despite the protracted litigation history.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.