Gapes v Dempsey Wood Civil Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA605/2021
 [2023] NZCA 435

BETWEEN

ANTHONY JOHN GAPES
Appellant

AND

DEMPSEY WOOD CIVIL LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

18 October 2022

Court:

Miller, Brown and Gilbert JJ

Counsel:

J W A Johnson and S T Dymond for Appellant
E St John for Respondent

Judgment:

12 September 2023 at 2 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed save that the orders made under the Companies Act 1993 and reflected in orders (a), (b) and (c) in the sealed judgment of the High Court are set aside.

BThe appellant must pay costs to the respondent for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Gilbert J)

  1. Mr Gapes was the sole director of Panama Road Development Ltd (Panama), a company formed for the purpose of carrying out a substantial residential property development in Auckland known as the Springpark development.  Panama contracted Dempsey Wood, one of New Zealand’s largest civil works contracting companies, to carry out the civil works.  Panama was placed in receivership on 3 December 2015 by its secured creditor, Koi Structured Credit Pty Ltd (Koi), a Singapore-based lender that provided Panama with a $30 million development facility personally guaranteed by Mr Gapes.  The receivers sold the development in March 2016 for around $25 million.  This left a shortfall of approximately $2.57 million outstanding to Koi.  Liquidators were appointed by special resolution of Panama’s shareholder (Mr Gapes’ interests) on 6 April 2016. Unsecured creditors, including Dempsey Wood, with combined debts totalling some $1.4 million, received nothing.

  2. Dempsey Wood brought proceedings against Mr Gapes in the High Court alleging a breach of s 9 of the Fair Trading Act 1986 (the FTA) and breaches of ss 131, 135, 136 and 137 of the Companies Act 1993.[1]  Dempsey Wood sought relief pursuant to s 301 of the Companies Act in respect of the alleged breaches of that Act.

High Court judgment

[1]The claim under s 137 of the Companies Act 1993 was not pursued.

  1. In a careful and comprehensive judgment delivered on 10 September 2021, Fitzgerald J found that Mr Gapes breached his duties as a director under ss 135 and 136 of the Companies Act from 13 November 2015.[2]  The Judge rejected the claim that Mr Gapes breached his duty under s 131.[3]  The Judge made an award of $100,000 pursuant to s 301 of the Companies Act in respect of the ss 135 and 136 breaches.[4] 

    [2]Dempsey Wood Civil Ltd v Gapes [2021] NZHC 2362 [High Court judgment] at [181], [203] and [263(a)–(b)].

    [3]At [215].

    [4]At [233].

  2. The Judge also found that an email Mr Gapes sent to Mr Dempsey on 12 November 2015 (the email) was misleading and deceptive and was reasonably relied on by Dempsey Wood in continuing to carry out works from that date until receivers were appointed 15 working days later.[5]  The Judge ordered Mr Gapes to pay Dempsey Wood the sum…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gapes v Dempsey Wood Civil Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZCA 435
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns a substantial residential property development in Auckland known as the Springpark development. Mr Anthony Gapes was the sole director of Panama Road Development Ltd (Panama), the company responsible for the development. Panama contracted Dempsey Wood Civil Ltd (Dempsey Wood), one of New Zealand's largest civil works contracting companies, to carry out the civil works. Dempsey Wood sued Mr Gapes, alleging breaches of the Fair Trading Act 1986 (FTA) and the Companies Act 1993 (Companies Act) and sought relief pursuant to s 301 of the Companies Act. In a judgment delivered on 10 September 2021, the High Court found that Mr Gapes breached his duties under ss 135 and 136 of the Companies Act from 13 November 2015. The Judge made an award of $100,000 pursuant to s 301 of the Companies Act in respect of the ss 135 and 136 breaches. The Judge also found that an email Mr Gapes sent to Mr Dempsey on 12 November 2015 was misleading and deceptive and was reasonably relied on by Dempsey Wood in continuing to carry out works from that date until receivers were appointed 15 working days later. The Judge ordered Mr Gapes to pay Dempsey Wood the sum of $286,295 pursuant to s 43 of the FTA. This sum was calculated as the cost to Dempsey Wood of carrying out this work after deducting its profit margin. The Judge also made orders that the FTA award be reduced by any amount received by Dempsey Wood as a result of Mr Gapes’ payment to Panama of the award made under s 301 of the Companies Act. Mr Gapes appeals against the judgment granting relief under s 43 of the FTA, contending the Judge erred in finding: (a) the email was misleading and deceptive; (b) Mr Dempsey relied on the email; and (c) the email caused Dempsey Wood’s loss. Mr Gapes also appeals the judgment granting relief under s 301 of the Companies Act, contending the Judge erred in finding: (a) Mr Gapes created a substantial risk of serious loss to creditors by allowing Panama to continue trading from 13 November 2015 and therefore breached s 135; (b) the obligation to Dempsey Wood was incurred for the purposes of s 136 from 13 November 2015, rather than when the contract was entered into on 5 September 2014, as contended by Mr Gapes; (c) Mr Gapes did not have a reasonable basis for believing that Panama could meet its obligations to Dempsey Wood; and (d) in applying the “new debt” approach when assessing Mr Gapes’ liability for the purposes of the award under s 301. Because of the coincidence in the Judge’s findings as to the timing of the various breaches of obligation, any losses recoverable by Dempsey Wood under the Companies Act (for the period 13 November to 3 December 2015) are subsumed in the damages awarded under the FTA caused by reliance on the 12 November 2015 email in continuing to carry out work under the contract for the same period. This overlap was recognised in the order made by the Judge and reflected in order (f) of the sealed judgment. For this reason, Mr St John, for Dempsey Wood, advised at the hearing that the appeal in respect of the Companies Act claims leading to orders (a) to (c) of the sealed judgment is not resisted. This sensible and practical concession means that we do not need to engage with the appeal against the judgment in respect of the Companies Act claims. This part of the appeal can be allowed without opposition given Dempsey Wood is the only creditor found to have suffered loss as a result of Mr Gapes’ breaches of duty under the Companies Act. Our attention can therefore be focused on the appeal against the judgment given under the FTA, the only part of the judgment Dempsey Wood actively seeks to defend. The Court found that Mr Gapes breached his duties under ss 135 and 136 of the Companies Act from 13 November 2015. The Judge made an award of $100,000 pursuant to s 301 of the Companies Act in respect of the ss 135 and 136 breaches. The appeal against these findings was not resisted. The appeal against the judgment in respect of the FTA claim must be dismissed. The appeal against the judgment in respect of the Companies Act claims can be allowed without opposition. The appeal is dismissed save that the orders made under the Companies Act 1993 and reflected in orders (a), (b) and (c) of the sealed judgment of the High Court are set aside. The appellant must pay costs to the respondent for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established