Galvanising (HB) Limited v John Howard Ross Fisk

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
SC 132/2015
[2016] NZSC 49
BETWEEN

GALVANISING (HB) LIMITED
First Applicant

STUART DAVID EASTON AND ROBERT ELVIDGE AS TRUSTEES OF THE EASTON PROPERTY TRUST
Second Applicants

HOOKED ON TRANSPORT LIMITED
Third Applicant

STUART DAVID EASTON AND VIVIENNE JANE EASTON
Fourth Applicants

AND

JOHN HOWARD ROSS FISK AND TONY WAYNE PATTISON AS LIQUIDATORS OF EAST QUIP LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
Respondents

Court:

Elias CJ, William Young and O'Regan JJ

Counsel:

C R Carruthers QC and G J Harley for Applicants
D Chan for Respondent

Judgment:

3 May 2016

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The application for leave to appeal is dismissed.

B        The applicants must pay costs of $2,500 to the respondents.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

  1. This is an application for leave to appeal against a decision by the Court of Appeal[1] upholding orders made in the High Court[2] setting aside certain transactions between each of the applicants and a company now in liquidation, East Quip Limited (East Quip), on the basis that they were voidable transactions[3] and ordering each applicant to pay sums relating to the transactions to the respondents, who are the liquidators of East Quip (the liquidators).[4]  For convenience we will refer to these orders by the colloquial name, claw back orders.  The present application focuses on s 292(4B) of the Companies Act 1993, which treats all transactions entered into as part of a continuing business relationship as if they were a single transaction for the purposes of determining whether a transaction is voidable.

    [1]Galvanising (HB) Ltd v Fisk [2015] NZCA 529, (2015) 14 TCLR 204 (Cooper, Venning and Williams JJ) [Fisk (CA)].

    [2]Fisk v Galvanising (HB) Ltd [2013] NZHC 3543 (Associate Judge Osborne) [Fisk (HC)].

    [3]Companies Act 1993, ss 292 and 294.

    [4]Companies Act, s 295.

  2. East Quip and the applicants, Galvanising (HB) Limited (Galvanising) and Hooked on Transport Limited, the Easton Property Trust and Mr and Mrs Easton comprised a corporate trading group.  Mr and Mrs Easton owned and controlled the group of companies.  The liquidators succeeded in obtaining claw back orders in relation to payments and set offs made by East Quip to or in favour of all of the applicants.  The most significant claw back order related to Galvanising, which was ordered to pay over $700,000 to the liquidators.

  3. The applicants wish to argue that the “continuing business relationship” for the purposes of s 292(4B) was not the individual relationships between East Quip and each of the applicants other than Mr and Mrs Easton but a tripartite relationship involving East Quip, the payee and Mr and Mrs Easton, who acted as bankers for the whole group.  The applicants illustrate this by an example of a notional payment from East Quip to Galvanising.[5]  The argument is that any payment by East Quip to Galvanising would be matched by a credit entry in the shareholder current account of Mr and Mrs Easton with East Quip and a matching debit entry in the current account of Mr and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Galvanising (HB) Limited v John Howard Ross Fisk and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZSC 49
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Galvanising (HB) Limited v John Howard Ross Fisk, the applicants sought leave to appeal against a decision by the Court of Appeal upholding orders made in the High Court. These orders set aside certain transactions between the applicants and East Quip Limited, a company now in liquidation, on the basis that they were voidable transactions under the Companies Act 1993. The Court of Appeal had ordered each applicant to pay sums relating to the transactions to the liquidators of East Quip. The applicants argued that the transactions should be considered as part of a tripartite relationship involving East Quip, the payee, and Mr and Mrs Easton, who acted as bankers for the group of companies. They contended that the transactions should be treated as a single transaction, which would negate the claw back orders.

The legal issues before the Supreme Court of New Zealand were whether the Court of Appeal's interpretation of s 292(4B) of the Companies Act 1993 was correct and whether the factual findings of the High Court and Court of Appeal precluded the applicants' argument. Specifically, the Court had to determine if the continuing business relationship for the purposes of s 292(4B) was the individual relationships between East Quip and each of the applicants or a tripartite relationship involving East Quip, the payee, and Mr and Mrs Easton. The applicants argued that the Court of Appeal's rejection of their interpretation of the continuing business relationship was incorrect and that their argument raised issues of general or public importance.

The Supreme Court dismissed the application for leave to appeal, holding that the applicants' argument was based on a version of the facts contrary to the concurrent findings of the High Court and Court of Appeal. The Court found that the transactions in issue were not part of a pre-planned and agreed arrangement under which all transactions would be netted off in the shareholder current accounts of Mr and Mrs Easton. The Court saw no proper basis to revisit these factual findings, which precluded the applicants' argument. Consequently, the Supreme Court concluded that it was not in the interests of justice to grant leave to appeal and dismissed the application, awarding costs of $2,500 to the respondents.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Galvanising (HB) Limited, Stuart David Easton and Robert Elvidge as trustees of the Easton Property Trust, Hooked on Transport Limited, Stuart David Easton and Vivienne Jane Easton as applicants, and John Howard Ross Fisk and Tony Wayne Pattison as liquidators of East Quip Limited (in liquidation) as respondents. The applicants are seeking to appeal against a decision by the Court of Appeal upholding orders made in the High Court that set aside certain transactions between each of the applicants and East Quip Limited, on the basis that they were voidable transactions and ordering each applicant to pay sums relating to the transactions to the respondents, the liquidators of East Quip. The most significant order related to Galvanising, which was ordered to pay over $700,000 to the liquidators. The applicants wish to argue that the "continuing business relationship" for the purposes of s 292(4B) of the Companies Act 1993 was not the individual relationships between East Quip and each of the applicants other than Mr and Mrs Easton but a tripartite relationship involving East Quip, the payee and Mr and Mrs Easton, who acted as bankers for the whole group. The applicants illustrate this by an example of a notional payment from East Quip to Galvanising. The process described in the example is said to have applied to all payments to and from group entities. On this basis, it is argued that it was necessary that the banking role played by Mr and Mrs Easton be recognised as part of the continuing business relationship. If the tripartite relationships were regarded as a continuing business relationship and transactions within the tripartite structure were treated as a single transaction as s 292(4B) requires, there would be no basis for the claw back orders. This argument was rejected by both the High Court and the Court of Appeal.

The matter originated in the High Court where the Associate Judge found that the transactions in issue were not part of a pre-planned and agreed arrangement under which all transactions would be netted off in the shareholder current accounts of Mr and Mrs Easton. This decision was appealed to the Court of Appeal which upheld the findings of the High Court. The applicants then sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of New Zealand. The Supreme Court dismissed the application for leave to appeal and ordered the applicants to pay costs of $2,500 to the respondents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the "continuing business relationship" for the purposes of s 292(4B) of the Companies Act 1993 was the individual relationships between East Quip and each of the applicants other than Mr and Mrs Easton or a tripartite relationship involving East Quip, the payee and Mr and Mrs Easton, who acted as bankers for the whole group.
2. If the tripartite relationships were regarded as a continuing business relationship and transactions within the tripartite structure were treated as a single transaction as s 292(4B) requires, whether there would be no basis for the claw back orders.

Held
1. The application for leave to appeal against the Court of Appeal's decision was dismissed.
2. The applicants were ordered to pay $2,500 in costs to the respondents.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court dismissed the application for leave to appeal, finding that the applicants' proposed argument relied on a version of facts contrary to the concurrent findings of the High Court and the Court of Appeal. The applicants argued that the "continuing business relationship" for the purposes of s 292(4B) of the Companies Act 1993 was a tripartite relationship involving East Quip, the payee, and Mr and Mrs Easton, who acted as bankers for the group. The Court of Appeal had previously found that the transactions in issue were not part of a pre-planned and agreed arrangement under which all transactions would be netted off in the shareholder current accounts of Mr and Mrs Easton. The Supreme Court held that there was no proper basis to revisit these factual findings, which precluded the applicants' argument. Consequently, the Supreme Court found that granting leave to appeal would not be in the interests of justice. The Court also awarded costs of $2,500 to the respondents.