FTG Securities Limited v Crown Asset Management Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2018-404-1710

[2020] NZHC 2007

BETWEEN

FTG SECURITIES LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

CROWN ASSET MANAGEMENT LIMITED

First Defendant

AND

BANK OF NEW ZEALAND

Second Defendant

Hearing: 8–10 June 2020

Counsel:

A J Forbes QC and H M Weston for Plaintiff R P Coltman and K Rowe for First Defendant

K M Paterson and A E Cao for Second Defendant

Judgment:

10 August 2020

Reissued:

21 August 2020


JUDGMENT OF OSBORNE J


This judgment was delivered by me on 10 August 2020 at 4.00 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:

FTG SECURITIES LIMITED v CROWN ASSET MANAGEMENT LIMITED [2020] NZHC 2007 [10 August 2020]

TABLE OF CONTENTS

What this case is about[1]

The sequence of events

The securities “assigned” to FTG[10]

Tuam’s receivership and liquidation[17]

Contractual dealings between FTG and BNZ – June 2012 to November 2015[29] Contractual dealings between FTG and CAML – March 2015 to June 2015[34] FTG commences the -659 proceeding against BNZ and the receivers[46] FTG commences a new (this -1710) proceeding[59]

FTG’s pleading of its claim[65]

The context[73]

BNZ’s pleading of its defence[77]

CAML’s pleading of its defence[85]

Legal principles – interpretation of the Priority Deed[87]

The reason for non-compliance with cl 15[90]

Equitable assignment of contractual rights

The law[98]

Contractual prohibitions on assignment – impact on transfer of contractual rights [103] The available constructions of a prohibition clause[110] Contractual prohibitions on assignment – impact on transfer of equitable interests [112] The Chester Legal Aid case[134]

Discussion of the legal principles[143]

Application of the principles to the prohibition in cl 15[152]

Procedural relief sought by FTG[164]

FTG’s enforcement of rights against CAML

The declaration sought by FTG in relation to equitable assignment[169]

The declaration sought by FTG in relation to proceeds received by CAML[172]

FTG’s enforcement of rights against BNZ[183]

Interpretation of the Priority Deed[184]

The application of equitable and other defences generally[187]

The clean hands defence

Equitable principles[190]

The transaction[201]

FTG’s conduct [205]

Costs

[213]

Result

[214]

What this case is about

[1]    This case concerns the debts incurred and securities given by a property development company, Tuam Ventures Ltd (Tuam), now both in receivership and in liquidation.

[2]    By 2007, Tuam had two secured creditors, namely Bank of New Zealand (BNZ), the second defendant in this proceeding, and Canterbury Finance Ltd (CFL). BNZ has continued to hold its interests through to today. The interests of CFL passed to the first defendant, Crown Asset Management Ltd (CAML).

[3]    The plaintiff – FTG Securities Ltd (FTG) – in 2015 sought to acquire from CAML its bundle of debt and second-ranking security interests. For that purpose, FTG entered into a Deed of Transfer of Debt and Securities (the Transfer Deed) dated 15 June 2015 with CAML.

[4]    As between BNZ and CAML, subordination and rights of priority were the subject of a Deed of Subordination and Priority (the Priority Deed) which Tuam, BNZ and CFL…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FTG Securities Limited v Crown Asset Management Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 2007
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

FTG Securities Limited, the plaintiff, sought a declaration that it had a valid equitable assignment of certain debt and securities from Crown Asset Management Limited, the first defendant, as well as an order that the first defendant account to the plaintiff for any proceeds received from the realisation of the debt and securities. The second defendant, Bank of New Zealand, defended the proceeding on the basis that the plaintiff did not have a valid equitable assignment of the debt and securities and that the plaintiff's claims were barred by the doctrine of clean hands. The court found that the plaintiff did not have a valid equitable assignment of the debt and securities as the assignment was made in breach of a contractual prohibition on assignment. The court also found that the plaintiff's claims were barred by the doctrine of clean hands as the plaintiff had deliberately participated in the breach of the contractual prohibition on assignment. The court ordered that the first defendant account to the plaintiff for any proceeds received from the realisation of the debt and securities and dismissed the plaintiff's claims against the second defendant. The court also awarded costs to the defendants.