Frost v Carr HC Dun CIV 2007-412-507

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV 2007-412-507

BETWEEN  MURRAY NEIL FROST AND MICHAEL CRAIG HORNE

Applicants

ANDEWAN ROBERT CARR First Respondent

ANDBROOKSIDE FARM TRUST LIMITED Second Respondent

ANDJARCEL INVESTMENTS LIMITED AND AWATAIERI HOLDINGS LIMITED

Third Respondent

ANDANESYDS LIMITED (IN RECEIVERSHIP)

Fourth Respondent

ANDRODNEY JOHN HUMPHRIES Fifth Respondent

CIV 2007-412-510

AND BETWEEN            EWAN CARR First Plaintiff

ANDBROOKSIDE FARM TRUST LIMITED Second Plaintiff

ANDRODNEY JOHN HUMPHRIES First Defendant

ANDBIG SKY DAIRY FARMS LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)

Second Defendant

FROST AND HORNE V CARR AND ORS HC DUN CIV 2007-412-507 30 May 2008

ANDCASCADE CAPITAL LIMITED Third Defendant

ANDMAIN FARM LIMITED Fourth Defendant

ANDCONSULTANT MANAGEMENT SERVICES LIMITED (IN RECEIVERSHIP)

Fifth Defendant

ANDANESYDS LIMITED (IN RECEIVERSHIP)

Sixth Defendant

ANDAWATAIERI HOLDINGS LIMITED Seventh Defendant

ANDJARCEL INVESTMENTS LIMITED Eighth Defendant

Hearing:         8 April 2008

Appearances: S P Rennie for the Carr Interests

J G J Toebes for the Receivers of the Big Sky Group of Companies
A R Gilchrist and L M Nicholson for the Humphries Interests

A J L Wedekind for Anesyds Limited (In Receivership) N F Flanagan for South Canterbury Finance Limited

Judgment:      30 May 2008 at 2.00 pm

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF RANDERSON J On Application for Stay

This judgment was delivered by me on 30 May 2008 at 2 pm, pursuant to r 540(4) of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:           Rhodes & Co, PO Box 13444 Armagh Street, Christchurch

Buddle Findlay, PO Box 2694, Wellington
Dyer Whitechurch, PO Box 6444, Wellesley Street, Auckland
Morgan Coakle, PO Box 114, Auckland

Meredith Connell, PO Box 2213, Auckland

Raymond Sullivan McGlashan, PO Box 557, Timaru

Counsel:            A R Gilchrist, PO Box 5444, Wellesley Street, Auckland

2

Introduction

[1]      The Carr interests seek a stay of proceedings or execution of my judgment issued on 29 February 2008 pending an appeal to the Court of Appeal scheduled for hearing on 27 and 28 August 2008.

[2]      The  application  is  opposed  by  the  receivers  of  the  Big  Sky  Group  of companies, the Humphries interests and the receiver of Anesyds Limited.

[3]      The  substantive  proceeding  arose  from  the  failed  settlement  of  sale  and purchase agreements relating to three substantial dairy farms in the Maniatoto Basin. Also included in the sale were two separate properties known as the Danseys Pass Coach Inn and the historic Styx Hotel.

[4]      The most substantial assets are the three dairy farms which, collectively, are said to be one of the largest dairy operations in the South Island.  The Big Sky Group of companies owns the dairy farms.  The Carr interests own one-third of the shares in the companies and the Humphries interests two-thirds.  The major creditors are the Bank of New Zealand (who appointed Messrs Frost and Horne as receivers) and Edgewater Motel Limited, a company owned by the Humphries interests.

[5]      The Carr interests were granted an option to purchase the various assets under a document known as the Amended Settlement Agreement executed in May

2007.   The option was exercised and the sales were to be completed by 4pm…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Frost v Carr HC Dun CIV 2007-412-507 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NZHC 2366
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Frost v Carr [2008] NZHC 1052 involves an application for a stay of proceedings or execution of judgment pending an appeal. The applicants, Murray Neil Frost and Michael Craig Horne, seek to stay the proceedings initiated by Ewan Robert Carr and others against the applicants, Brookside Farm Trust Limited, Jarcel Investments Limited, Anesyds Limited (in receivership), Rodney John Humphries, and others. The substantive proceeding concerns the failed settlement of sale and purchase agreements relating to three dairy farms and two other properties. The Carr interests sought an option to purchase the assets under the Amended Settlement Agreement, which was not exercised by the deadline, leading to its cancellation. The court found the agreement validly cancelled, and there was no basis for an order for specific performance.

The court was required to balance the rights of the successful party to the fruits of the judgment with the need to preserve the appellant's position pending the appeal. The relevant considerations included the likelihood of the appeal being rendered nugatory, the potential injury to the successful party by the stay, the bona fides of the appellant, the effect on third parties, the novelty and importance of the questions, the public interest, and the overall balance of convenience and the status quo.

The court found that the value of the farms was likely to increase over the next six to twelve months, and the farms would not have been sold until around the same time even without the appeal. The court also considered Mr Carr's historic interests in the land and the potential for specific performance if his appeal was successful. The court decided to grant a stay on the following terms: none of the assets would be sold pending the final disposition of the appeal; Mr Carr would provide an assignment of all the shareholding of the Carr interests in the Big Sky Group as security for any losses sustained by the respondents from June 1, 2008, until the final disposal of the appeal by the Carr interests; and the caveats in favour of the Carr interests would be removed. The court reserved the costs of the application for stay and leave for any party to apply further in relation to the stay order or the orders relating to Danseys Pass.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.