Freshmax NZ Limited v Oak Glen Orchards Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV-2011-441-000827 [2012] NZHC 2910

BETWEEN  FRESHMAX NZ LIMITED Plaintiff

ANDOAK GLEN ORCHARDS LIMITED First Defendant

ANDFAMILY TRIO LIMITED Second Defendant

ANDMICHAEL JOHN ALCOCK Third Defendant

ANDDONALD BRUCE STEEDMAN Fourth Defendant

Hearing:         31 May 2012

with written submissions received 16 July 2012; 31 July 2012; and 14

August 2012 (Heard at Napier)

Appearances: M Keall for Plaintiff

D Kerr for Defendants

Judgment:      6 November 2012

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE [as to costs and disbursements]

[1]      My judgment on the plaintiff’s summary judgment application was delivered

on 4 July 2012.

[2]      Counsel have dealt with the issue of costs and disbursements through written submissions.

FRESHMAX NZ LIMITED V OAK GLEN ORCHARDS LIMITED HC NAP CIV-2011-441-000827 [6

November 2012]

The costs issue

[3]      The  plaintiff  was  successful  in  its  summary judgment  application.    It  is common ground that costs should follow the event.

[4]      In my judgment on the summary judgment application,1  I reserved the costs but summarised the nature of the issue which arose in this way:

The plaintiff is also entitled to costs upon the basis that they follow the event. Again,  pursuant  to  discussion  with  counsel  at  the  hearing  I  will reserve costs. Freshmax relies upon provisions in the guarantees which provide for the recovery of legal fees on a full indemnity basis. Mr Keall accepted that there was no equivalent provision in the principal contracts. Costs remain in the discretion of the Court. It would be an unusual outcome if the Court were to order solicitor/client costs against the guarantors but costs on some lesser basis against the principal obligant. My preliminary view  is  that, taking into  consideration  both  the  contractual  provision  as against the guarantors and a degree of lack of success (by $16,106.94) for the plaintiff, a costs award on a 2B basis together with disbursements as fixed by the Registrar might be appropriate. Leave will be reserved to the parties in relation to costs.

The plaintiff ’s position on costs

[5]      The plaintiff seeks indemnity costs.

[6]      The plaintiff’s actual legal costs in its attempts to recover the debt before proceedings  were issued  and  in  the period  of  the proceedings  were  $44,151.38 (including GST but excluding disbursements).   Disbursements were $3,264.72 (including GST).

[7]      To the extent that an award of indemnity costs would involve earlier costs of attempted  recovery rather  than  costs  in  preparation  of  the  litigation  (the  earlier recovery costs are not available through an application limited to the High Court Rules themselves: Paper Reclaim Ltd v Aotearoa International Ltd).2

[8]      In this case, the plaintiff pleaded and relies on a contractual provision in the guarantees allowing recovery of all legal fees incurred in enforcing the guarantees on

a full indemnity basis.3     It is the second, third and fourth defendants who were guarantors.

[9]      As against the first defendant (which entered into the principal contract which did not contain a clause as to recovery of solicitor/client fees on an indemnity basis), the plaintiff seeks costs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Freshmax NZ Limited v Oak Glen Orchards Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2910
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Freshmax NZ Limited v Oak Glen Orchards Limited was a case heard by the High Court of New Zealand Napier Registry, focusing on the issue of costs and disbursements following a successful summary judgment application by Freshmax against Oak Glen Orchards Limited and others. Freshmax sought indemnity costs from all defendants, relying on contractual provisions in the guarantees, while the defendants argued for a limitation of costs to a 2B scale basis. The court examined the reasonableness of the plaintiff's costs, considering the complexity of the case and the contractual agreement for indemnity costs. The court held that the contractual agreement for indemnity costs should be enforced unless there were public policy grounds or objective unreasonableness to prevent it. It rejected the defendants' argument that the costs should be harmonized and instead allowed Freshmax to recover its full indemnity costs, including those incurred before the litigation commenced, as agreed in the contract. The court also found that the use of out-of-town counsel was reasonable under the circumstances. The final orders mandated the first defendant to pay $17,500 in costs and $3,264.72 in disbursements, while the second, third, and fourth defendants were jointly and severally liable for $44,151.38 in costs and $3,264.72 in disbursements, with these costs not being cumulative. Additionally, the court ordered the defendants to pay $796 in costs for the submissions on the costs issue.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.