Fox Ears Limited v Westcity NZ Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2023-404-2122

[2024] NZHC 1913

BETWEEN

FOX EARS LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

WESTCITY NZ PTY LIMITED & WESTCITY NZ NOMINEES PTY LIMITED

First Defendants

COLLIERS REAL ESTATE MANAGEMENT LIMITED

Second Defendant

Hearing: 8 July 2024

Counsel:

SLL Gallagher for the Plaintiff

M A Keil for the First Defendants I Davies for the Second Defendant

Date of Judgment:

12 July 2024


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE BRITTAIN


This judgment was delivered by me on 12 July 2024 at 10 am.

Pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

…………………..

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Righteous Law, Auckland Keil & Associates, Auckland

Robertsons Barristers & Solicitors

FOX EARS LTD v WESTCITY NZ PTY LTD [2024] NZHC 1913 [12 July 2024]

Introduction

[1]    The plaintiff, Fox Ears Ltd (Fox Ears), was formerly the tenant of a premises in a shopping mall operated by the first defendants, Westcity NZ Pty Ltd and Westcity NZ Nominees Pty Ltd (Westcity). Fox Ears operated a Health 2000 franchise from the premises.

[2]    The term of the lease was seven years commencing on 19 May 2019. Fox Ears vacated the premises on about 1 December 2019. On 2 December 2019, Westcity entered into a new lease with the franchisor, Health 2000 Retail Ltd (Health 2000).

[3]    In this proceeding, Fox Ears alleges that its lease was surrendered by operation of law on 2 December 2019. Fox Ears has sued Westcity to recover a security deposit that Fox Ears paid to Westcity at the commencement of the lease, of $23,805.90. Fox Ears also claims damages for the value of its fitout of the premises and chattels left in the premises when it vacated, alleging that Westcity has been unjustly enriched by the value of those assets.

[4]    Westcity says that the security deposit was applied to the amounts due under the lease for the period ending on 1 December 2019. Westcity says that Fox Ears remains liable for any unpaid rent until the term of the lease expires on 18 May 2026.

[5]Westcity has applied for security for costs in respect of the claim by Fox Ears.

Legal principles

[6]    The Court has a discretion to grant an application for security of costs under  r 5.45(2) of the High Court Rules 2016 if it would be just in all the circumstances to do so. That discretion is, however, only engaged if the threshold test in r 5.45(1) is met. For presents purposes, that will be if the Court is satisfied there is reason to believe that the plaintiff will be unable to pay the costs of the defendant if the proceeding is unsuccessful.1


1      Rule 5.45(1)(b).

[7]    The Court may draw a reasonable inference that a party will be unable to meet costs from credible evidence of surrounding circumstances.2

[8]    Exercise of the Court’s discretion under r 5.45(2) requires a balancing of the interests   of  plaintiff  and  defendant,   as  summarised  by  the  Court  of  Appeal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fox Ears Limited v Westcity NZ Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 1913
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fox Ears Limited, the plaintiff, was a tenant under a lease of premises in a shopping mall operated by the first defendants, Westcity NZ Pty Ltd and Westcity NZ Nominees Pty Ltd (Westcity). Fox Ears vacated the premises on about 1 December 2019 and subsequently alleged that its lease had been surrendered by operation of law. Fox Ears sued Westcity to recover a security deposit paid at the commencement of the lease and for damages for the value of its fitout of the premises and chattels left when it vacated. Westcity denied the surrender of the lease and counterclaimed for unpaid rent and damages. Westcity applied for security for costs under rule 5.45(2) of the High Court Rules 2016.

The court determined whether the threshold test for security for costs had been met, which required the court to be satisfied there was reason to believe that the plaintiff would be unable to pay the costs of the defendant if the proceeding was unsuccessful. The court found that there was reason to believe that Fox Ears had no capacity to meet an adverse costs order, based on Fox Ears’ financial difficulties and lack of current financial information. The court then considered the merits of Fox Ears’ claims, finding that there was a genuine and substantial dispute as to whether the lease had been surrendered. However, the court also found that it was arguable that Fox Ears’ early vacating amounted to a repudiation of the lease, which entitled Westcity to damages. The court concluded that Fox Ears’ prospects of success were poor.

The court balanced the interests of the parties, noting that Fox Ears’ impecuniosity was not due to Westcity’s conduct and that there had been no delay in Westcity’s application for security for costs. The court found that this was an appropriate case for security for costs and ordered Fox Ears to pay $15,000 into court as security for Westcity’s costs for all steps in the proceeding to the conclusion of discovery. The proceeding was stayed pending payment of the security into court. The court also granted leave for Westcity to seek a revision of the amount of security if there was a defended interlocutory application and to apply for further security for all steps post the close of pleadings. The court’s preliminary view was that Fox Ears should pay Westcity’s costs on the application for security on a 2B basis, together with disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established