Forest Holdings Ltd v Mangatu Blocks Incorporation

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

CIV 2016-470-158 [2017] NZHC 448

UNDER the Arbitration Act 1996

BETWEEN

FOREST HOLDINGS LTD Appellant

AND

MANGATU BLOCKS INCORPORATION Respondent

Hearing: 13 December 2016

Counsel:

M D Branch and K Bond for Appellant
Z G Kennedy and M D Toulmin for Respondent

Judgment:

15 March 2017

JUDGMENT (NO. 2) OF HEATH J

This judgment was delivered by me on 15 March 2017 at 3.00pm pursuant to Rule

11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:
Harkness Henry, Hamilton

Minter Ellison, Auckland

FOREST HOLDINGS LTD v MANGATU BLOCKS INCORPORATION [2017] NZHC 448 [15 March 2017]

CONTENTS

The appeal  [1] The Forestry Right  [5] Repudiation and cancellation of the Forestry Right  [11] The arbitration

(a)      The claims  [16]

(b)      The Liability Award  [18] (c)      The Damages Award  [20] Analysis

(a)      The “first principles” approach  [25]

(b)      Do the authorities demand a different result?  [42] Result                  [52]

The appeal

[1]      Forest Holdings Ltd (Forest Holdings) and Mangatu Blocks Incorporation (Mangatu)  were  in  dispute  about  Mangatu’s  alleged  wrongful  termination  of  a forestry right (the Forestry Right) which it had granted in favour of Forest Holdings.1

They submitted their dispute to arbitration.  Hon B J Paterson QC was appointed as arbitral tribunal (the arbitrator).

[2]      In  an  award  made  on  8  June  2016  (the  Liability Award),  the  arbitrator determined that Mangatu’s purported termination of the Forestry Right with immediate effect from 10 July 2013, and its subsequent eviction of Forest Holdings from the forest land, constituted a repudiation of the contract.2    The arbitrator held that Mangatu ought to have served a notice requiring alleged breaches of the forestry right to be remedied within 120 days.

[3]      As a result of the Liability Award, it was necessary for the arbitrator to assess damages  payable  to  Forest  Holdings.    A preliminary  question  arose  about  the methodology to be employed in assessing damages.  In a second award, made on 29

July 2016 (the Damages Award), the arbitrator found that, having regard to the principles that he considered should be applied, “the prospects of [Forest Holdings] obtaining other than a normal damages award on its capital loss claim appear to be

minimal”.3

1      See paras [5]–[9] below.

2      See paras 15 and 16 of the termination letter of 10 July 2013, set out at para [14] below.

3      Damages Award, para 41(f), set out at para [23] below.

[4]      Forest Holdings sought leave to appeal to this Court against the Damages Award.  An appeal may only be brought on a question of law, by leave of the High Court.4   In a judgment given on 14 November 2016, I granted leave, identifying the point of law as follows:5

(a)       …

Having regard to binding findings of fact set out in the [Liability Award] of 8 June 2016, did the arbitral tribunal correctly determine the legal basis on which Forest Holdings Ltd was entitled to seek damages   resulting   from   Mangatu   Block[s]   [Incorporation’s] unlawful termination of the forestry right?

The Forestry Right

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Forest Holdings Ltd v Mangatu Blocks Incorporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 448
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Forest Holdings Ltd v Mangatu Blocks Incorporation involved a dispute over the termination of a forestry right agreement between Forest Holdings and Mangatu. The High Court of New Zealand was asked to review the arbitrator's decision on the assessment of damages awarded to Forest Holdings following the wrongful termination of the forestry right. The primary issue was whether the damages should be assessed as at the date of the repudiation or the date of the contract's cancellation. The court found that the assessment should be based on the value of the asset at the time of the repudiation, taking into account any future events that had a real possibility of occurring at that time. The court held that the arbitrator's decision to limit damages to a nominal amount was not supported by the authorities, and the appeal was allowed. The case was remitted to the arbitrator for reassessment of damages in line with the court's judgment. Costs were reserved for later determination.