Foote v Keltern Stud Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV-2012-441-497 [2012] NZHC 3407

BETWEEN  SUSANNE JANE FOOTE AND STUART DAVID FOOTE AS TRUSTEES OF THE FOOTE FAMILY TRUST

Plaintiffs

ANDKELTERN STUD LIMITED Defendant

Hearing:         13 December 2012 (Heard at Napier)

Counsel:         J. Bates - Counsel for Plaintiff

N. Russell - Counsel for Defendant

Judgment:      13 December 2012

ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE D.I. GENDALL

Solicitors: Gresson Grayson, Solicitors, PO Box 1045, Hastings

Chen Palmer Public and Employment Law Specialists, PO Box 2160, Wellington 6140

SJ FOOTE AND SD FOOTE AS TRUSTEES OF THE FOOTE FAMILY TRUST V KELTERN STUD LIMITED HC NAP CIV-2012-441-497 [13 December 2012]

Introduction

[1]      This proceeding involves a company known as Keltern Stud Limited (the defendant company).

[2]      The defendant company was formed many years ago (certainly at some time prior to 2000) by members of the Kelt family.

[3]      Prior to his death in 2000, as I understand the position, a 50% shareholding in the defendant company was owned by Mr G.R. Kelt senior (Mr Kelt senior) who is the father of the first-named plaintiff Suzanne Jane Foote (Ms Foote) and her brother David Andrew James Kelt (Mr Sam Kelt).  Prior to 2000, Mr Sam Kelt owned the remaining 50% shareholding in the defendant company.

[4]      Following the death of the late Mr Kelt senior, Ms Foote acquired effectively by inheritance his 50% shareholding in the defendant company.   In addition, as I understand the position, about that time the late Mr Kelt senior and Mr Sam Kelt as shareholders in the defendant company had made advances to the company each totalling  $313,213.00.    I  believe  these  amounts  at  the  time  were  shown  in  the accounts of the defendant company as shareholders’ loans.

[5]      Following  her  acquisition  of  the  shares  and  shareholders’  loan  in  the defendant  company, in  about 2000 Ms  Foote became a director along with her brother Mr Sam Kelt.   They continued as directors until Ms Foote resigned I understand in about 2010.

[6]      Ms Foote’s 50% shareholding in the capital of the defendant company is now held by the plaintiffs as trustees of the Foote Family Trust.

[7]      From all accounts, in the recent past Ms Foote and her brother Mr Sam Kelt have fallen out in a major way.   Certainly, so far as the defendant company is concerned, as family member shareholders they have become estranged from each other.  Both counsel who appeared before me today have acknowledged that this is the case.

[8]      Perhaps as a result of this, the current proceeding is before this Court.  This represents an application by Ms Foote and her husband as trustees of the plaintiff family trust to place the defendant company into liquidation.   The application is brought upon the basis of an unsatisfied statutory demand issued by the plaintiffs on

17 July 2012 requiring repayment of the $313,213.00 shareholders’ loan advance by

the defendant company.

[9]      The defendant company did not respond to this statutory demand when it was served with it on 17 July…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Foote v Keltern Stud Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 3407
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Foote v Keltern Stud Limited, the plaintiffs, Susanne Jane Foote and Stuart David Foote as trustees of the Foote Family Trust, sought to liquidate the defendant company, Keltern Stud Limited. The plaintiffs argued that the company was unable to repay a debt of $313,213.00, which was owed to them as a shareholder loan. The defendant company sought leave to file a statement of defence out of time, asserting that the debt was not a loan but shareholder funds, that it was solvent, and that it had a reasonable excuse for the delay in filing the defence. The court had to decide whether to grant the defendant leave to file its statement of defence out of time and whether the company was liable for the debt, solvent, and if the application was just and equitable.

The court found that the defendant had an arguable defence to the claim, as the nature of the $313,213.00 contribution was unclear. While the previous financial accounts showed these amounts as shareholder loans, the draft accounts for 2011 and 2012 claimed that they represented shareholder equity. The court could not make a definitive ruling on the matter based on the available material. The court also found that the defendant company was likely solvent, as the defendant had contributed additional funds to the company. However, the plaintiffs disputed this claim. In terms of justice, the court considered the family situation and the attempts to negotiate a resolution between the estranged family members. The court found that the defendant company had not provided a reasonable excuse for the delay but that the application should not be disqualified based on this alone.

The court concluded that it was in the interests of justice to grant the defendant leave to file its statement of defence out of time. The liquidation application involved family member shareholders who were estranged from each other, and the court needed to consider all available evidence before making a decision. The court also noted a public interest in the defendant company being liquidated due to the alleged mismanagement by one of the shareholders. The court made an order granting the defendant leave to file its statement of defence out of time and directed the parties to file additional evidence and set a hearing date for the liquidation application. Costs with respect to the present application were reserved, and leave was granted to the plaintiffs to file an amended statement of claim to plead just and equitable grounds for a liquidation order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established