Fluoride Action Network (NZ) Incorporated v Hastings District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA AHURIRI ROHE

CIV-2024-441-000027

[2024] NZHC 1781

UNDER the Judicial Review Procedure Act 2016; the NZ Bill of Rights Act 1990; and the
Declaratory Judgments Act 1908

IN THE MATTER

of an application for Judicial Review of a decision of the Hastings District Council to commence fluoridating Hastings water supply

BETWEEN

FLUORIDE ACTION NETWORK (NZ) INCORPORATED

First Applicant

NZDSOS INC
Second Applicant

AND

HASTINGS DISTRICT COUNCIL

First Respondent

DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF HEALTH
Second Respondent

ATTORNEY-GENERAL

Third Respondent

Hearing: (On the papers)

Counsel:

S J Grey for Applicants

H P Harwood and S B Hart for First Respondent
J N E Varuhas and R E R Gavey for Second and Third Respondents

Judgment:

2 July 2024


JUDGMENT OF LA HOOD J

(Costs)


FLUORIDE ACTION NETWORK (NZ) INC v HASTINGS DISTRICT COUNCIL [2024] NZHC 1781 [2 July 2024]

[1]    On 24 May 2024, I dismissed the applicants’ judicial review proceedings seeking to prevent the re-fluoridation of Hastings’ urban water supply.1

[2]    I indicated a preliminary view that the respondents are entitled to costs on a 2B basis with certification for second counsel. However, I made directions about the filing of memoranda if costs could not be agreed. As agreement has not been reached, I am required to determine costs.

Parties’ positions

[3]    The applicants submit that the general rule that costs should follow the event should not be applied. They rely on r 14.7(e) of the High Court Rules 2016, which provides that the Court has the discretion to refuse to make an order for costs if the “proceeding concerned a matter of public interest, and the party opposing costs acted reasonably in the conduct of the proceeding”. The applicants submit this rule applies because:

(a)there is considerable public importance in access to drinking water free from contamination through fluoridation;

(b)the right to decline medical treatment is a fundamental right provided for in the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (the Bill of Rights);

(c)the applicants have no private interest in the outcome as they are incorporated societies with a public interest purpose;

(d)access by the public to the court to determine the legality of the actions of central and local government is a constitutional right; and

(e)the issue of whether the Crown pressured a local authority to comply with an unlawful directive before the required Bill of Rights assessment was completed were novel.


1      Fluoride Action Network (NZ) Inc v Hastings District Council [2024] NZHC 1313 [Substantive decision].

[4]    The respondents’ position is that this is not an appropriate case for the application of r 14.7(e) and costs should follow the event, for the reasons I refer to below.

Decision

[5]    I accept the second and third respondents’ submission that, while the applicants clearly consider they are acting in a public interest, in reality the case reflected the special interests of their members. The proceeding was effectively another vehicle for groups that oppose fluoridation to challenge the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fluoride Action Network (NZ) Incorporated v Hastings Distric... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 1781
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Fluoride Action Network (NZ) Incorporated and NZDSOS Inc sought to prevent the Hastings District Council from re-fluoridating the Hastings urban water supply. The applicants argued that the proceeding concerned a matter of public interest and that the Court should refuse to order costs to follow the event. The respondents, including the Hastings District Council, the Director-General of Health, and the Attorney-General, submitted that the proceeding did not meet the criteria for refusing to award costs and that costs should follow the event.

The Court found that while the applicants considered their actions to be in the public interest, the proceeding was effectively another vehicle for groups opposing fluoridation to challenge the Director-General’s directions to local authorities to fluoridate their water supplies. The Court noted that water fluoridation is already subject to ongoing legal challenge and that Parliament has explicitly endorsed water fluoridation as a public health measure. The applicants' failure to succeed on any of their claims, coupled with the unsatisfactory framing of their case, further supported the conclusion that costs should follow the event.

The Court ordered that the applicants pay the respondents' costs on a 2B basis, with certification for second counsel. The Court found that the respondents' conduct in defending the application and cooperating to have it heard urgently was reasonable and responsible. The Court also found that the wide-ranging nature of the applicants' claim and the urgency with which it was brought to hearing justified allowing for second counsel. The applicants were ordered to pay the first respondent's costs in the sum of $20,470.40 and the second and third respondents' costs in the sum of $20,566.05.