Fisk v Nicholls

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2010-485-002242 [2012] NZHC 2507

UNDER  section 292 of the Companies Act 1993

IN THE MATTER OF     Gravitas Limited (In Receivership and In

Liquidation)

BETWEEN  JOHN HOWARD ROSS FISK AND CRAIG ALEXANDER SANSON Plaintiffs

ANDMARTYN BRUCE NICHOLLS Defendant

Hearing:         25 September 2012

Appearances: R Gordon and P Roy for Plaintiffs

S McAnally and B Hojabri for Defendant

Judgment:      1 October 2012

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS

[1]      The plaintiffs are the liquidators of Gravitas Limited which was placed in liquidation on 25 January 2011.  The defendant is a former director and shareholder in the company.  On 22 and 24 April 2009 Mr Nicholls made two payments from the company bank account to himself totalling $310,300.   In this proceeding the liquidators seek orders setting aside these payments and directing the defendant to repay them, under ss 292 and 294(5) of the Companies Act 1993.

[2]      The liquidators filed their application on 7 June 2012 accompanied by an affidavit from Mr J H Fisk.  On 12 July Mr Nicholls filed a notice of opposition and affidavits sworn by himself and by Susheel Dutt.  These affidavits were sworn a few

days outside timetable directions made on 16 July.   By the same directions the

JOHN HOWARD ROSS FISK AND CRAIG ALEXANDER SANSON V MARTYN BRUCE NICHOLLS HC WN CIV-2010-485-002242 [1 October 2012]

plaintiff was given until 31 August to file and serve any reply affidavits and the application was set down for a half day fixture before me on 25 September 2012.

[3]      On 18 September the plaintiffs filed affidavits from Mr Fisk and Mr A C Willdig  totalling,  with  exhibits,  some  469  pages.     These  were  met  with  an application by Mr Nicholls for an order under r 9.76 of the High Court Rules that these affidavits not be read.  He says the affidavits are not in reply, as they introduce new material.

[4]      Consequently the fixture on 25 September was allocated to argument on this application. The issues before me are:

a)  Are the affidavits of Mr Fisk and Mr Willdig entirely, or in part, in reply to the evidence filed by Mr Nicholls?

b) If the affidavits are not in reply, either entirely or in part, should those parts of the affidavits be struck out, or admitted with an opportunity given to Mr Nicholls to reply to those parts of the affidavits which I find to be new evidence.

[5]      Rule 9.76(1)(d) provides that an affidavit must be confined, if in reply, to matters strictly in reply.  Rule 9.76(2) provides that the Court may refuse to read an affidavit that, being in reply, introduces new matter.

[6]      First, therefore, it is necessary to determine whether the affidavits filed are in reply to Mr Nicholls’ evidence.

[7]      Mr McAnally took me through the affidavits with some care and precision, identifying by reference to groups of paragraphs in each, factual material which he said does not reply to evidence which had been given by either…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fisk v Nicholls and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2507
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Fisk v Nicholls, the plaintiffs, who are the liquidators of Gravitas Limited, sought to set aside two payments made by the defendant, a former director and shareholder of the company, totalling $310,300. The payments were made on 22 and 24 April 2009, and the company was placed in liquidation on 25 January 2011. The plaintiffs sought the orders under sections 292 and 294(5) of the Companies Act 1993. The defendant opposed the application and filed affidavits in response.

The issues before the court were whether the affidavits filed by the plaintiffs were in reply to the evidence filed by the defendant and, if not, whether those parts of the affidavits should be struck out or admitted with an opportunity given to the defendant to reply to those parts of the affidavits which were found to be new evidence. The court found that all the evidence given by the plaintiffs was evidence in reply to the defendant's evidence and dismissed the application. The plaintiffs were awarded 50% of costs on a 2B basis plus full disbursements fixed by the Registrar.

The court's reasoning was based on the objective of the High Court Rules to secure the just, speedy and inexpensive determination of any proceeding or interlocutory application. The court emphasised the need to ensure that each party is treated fairly and justly in the presentation of its case and the need to balance the need to exclude irrelevant evidence inviting equally unproductive counterattack against the need to discourage detailed technical attacks on admissibility in advance of trial. The court also noted that evidence in reply is not confined merely to acceptance or rejection of evidence given in opposition but can include new evidence that is relevant to the issues. The court found that the plaintiffs' evidence was properly classified as evidence in reply and that the defendant had sufficient time to assimilate the evidentiary material and respond appropriately.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.