IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CIV-2014-404-001709 [2014] NZHC 2640
BETWEEN PETER RONALD FINLAY
Appellant
AND
WESTPAC NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Respondent
Hearing: 23 October 2014 Appearances:
Appellant in Person
B J Upton and D J Tillett for RespondentJudgment:
28 October 2014
JUDGMENT OF VENNING J
This judgment was delivered by me on 28 October 2014 at 1.00 pm, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High
Court Rules.
Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Date……………
Solicitors: Simpson Grierson, Auckland
Copy to: Appellant
FINLAY v WESTPAC NZ LTD [2014] NZHC 2640 [28 October 2014]
Introduction
[1] Mr Finlay appeals against a decision of the District Court at North Shore. On
12 June 2014 Judge Hinton entered summary judgment in favour of Westpac New Zealand Limited (Westpac) against Mr Finlay in the sum of $212,675.04 (including costs and disbursements).
[2] The judgment related to a shortfall owed by Mr Finlay to Westpac under a
loan. Westpac’s claim followed the sale of two properties secured to it located at
41B and 43 Gordon Road, Western Heights, Rotorua.
Chronology
[3] The following brief summary of events is sufficient to set the background context:
(a) On 12 January 2012 Westpac made demand of Mr Finlay in relation to the loan he had with the Bank.
(b)On 26 January 2012 Mr Finlay was served with a Property Law Act notice.
(c) On 7 March 2012 Westpac wrote to Mr Finlay following a telephone discussion between him and Mr Hoy of the Bank.
(d)On 13 March 2012 Westpac’s solicitors wrote to Mr Finlay advising him that Westpac was obtaining registered valuations and marketing proposals for the properties from Harcourts Real Estate and Bayleys Real Estate.
(e) On 21 March 2012 Westpac obtained market valuations for the property from Reid and Reynolds Ltd, trading as Telfer Young (Rotorua) (Telfer Young).
(f) On 2 April 2012 Westpac’s solicitors wrote to Mr Finlay advising him that Westpac had instructed Bayleys to market and sell the property.
(g)The properties went to auction on 24 May 2012 but were not sold as there were no bids received for either section.
(h)On 10 October 2012 Westpac obtained updated valuations for the properties from Telfer Young.
(i)On 19 October 2012 Westpac received an offer for 43 Gordon Road for $25,000. After negotiations it accepted the offer. Settlement occurred on 30 October 2012.
(j) On 1 November 2012 Westpac received an offer for the property at
41B Gordon Road for $25,000. After negotiations it accepted that offer. Settlement occurred on 9 November 2012.
The appeal
[4] Mr Finlay appeals on the grounds that:
(a) the Judge was wrong to take a robust approach to the summary judgment application;
(b)the Judge was not entitled to reject the valuation evidence adduced by Mr Finlay’s valuer, Mr Davies. Westpac’s valuers were wrong to consider the properties lacked subdivision potential. The conflict between Mr Davies’ valuation evidence and Westpac’s experts required resolution at a full hearing;
(c) the Judge was wrong to consider that Mr Finlay had not co-operated…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Finlay v Westpac New Zealand Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NZHC 2640
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Regarding the valuation evidence, the Court found that Mr Finlay's valuer, Mr Davies, did not physically inspect the properties and did not suggest a valuation in a forced sale/mortgagee sale valuation. The Court preferred the evidence of Telfer Young, which had inspected the properties and noted their overgrown nature. The Court also found that Mr Davies' valuation relied on information that was not available to Telfer Young at the time of their first valuation. The Court held that the Judge was entitled to prefer the evidence of Telfer Young as to the appropriate valuation for mortgagee sale purposes.
As for Westpac's duty of care, the Court found that Westpac had taken reasonable care to obtain the best price reasonably obtainable as at the time of sale. The Court noted that the statutory obligation is not to obtain the best price reasonably obtainable but to take reasonable care to obtain the best price reasonably obtainable. The Court held that Westpac was not required to chase Mr Finlay up and seek to obtain further information from him, as Mr Finlay had failed to respond to Westpac's request for information relating to the proposed subdivision of the properties.
Finally, regarding the sale price, the Court held that while the sale prices of the sections were low, they were consistent with the more recent valuations the Bank obtained, or had available to it at the time of sale. The Court found that a sale price of $25,000 in each case, while no doubt disappointing to Mr Finlay, was not so out of the range of the recent valuations to suggest Westpac was in breach of the obligation it owed Mr Finlay in selling at those prices.
The Court dismissed the appeal with costs on a 2B basis together with disbursement as fixed by the Registrar to Westpac.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi