Fenton Projects Limited v Carlton Gore Holdings Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2013-404-3604 [2013] NZHC 2872

BETWEEN  FENTON PROJECTS LIMITED Applicant

ANDCARLTON GORE HOLDINGS LIMITED

Respondent

Hearing:                   22 October 2013

Counsel:                  M Lenihan for Applicant

GJ Luen for Respondent

Judgment:                31 October 2013

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SARGISSON

This judgment was delivered by me on 31 October 2013 at 2.00 p.m., pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date: ………………………….

Solicitors:           Burton & Co, Auckland

Hesketh Henry, Auckland

FENTON PROJECTS LTD v CARLTON GORE HOLDINGS LTD [2013] NZHC 2872 [31 October 2013]

[1]      The  applicant,  Fenton  Projects  Limited,  seeks  an  order  setting  aside  a statutory demand.   The respondent, Carlton Gore Holdings Limited, served the demand,  which  is  dated  17  July  2013,  on  the  applicant  seeking  payment  of

$63,579.62 for outstanding rent and other sums due under a lease.

[2]      The application is in reliance on s 290(4)(a) of the Companies Act 1993 which relevantly states:

(4)      The Court may grant an application to set aside a statutory demand if it is satisfied that –

(a)      there is a substantial dispute whether or not the debt is owing or is due; or

[3]      There is no dispute that the application has been made and served in the time allowed under s 290.  At issue is whether there is a substantial dispute as to whether or not the debt is due and owing by Fenton to the Carlton.

[4]      Carlton opposes the application.

Background

[5]      Fenton  leases  premises  at  77  Carlton  Gore  Road  from  the  lessor,  the Melanesian Mission Trust Board, pursuant to an assignment of lease.  Fenton took the assignment from Carlton in August 2007 and became liable to pay the rent and observe the covenants of the lease.

[6]      Notwithstanding the assignment of the lease, Carlton also remains liable to the Trust Board for sums due under the lease and pursuant to s 98 of the Land Transfer Act 1952 and s 367(5) of the Property Law Act 2007, it has the benefit of implied covenants in the assignment of lease that Fenton will pay the rent and pay all of the lessee’s covenants in the lease expressed or implied.   Under the same provisions, Carlton has the benefit of Fenton’s implied covenant to indemnify it in respect of unpaid rent or breach of the covenants of the lease and to keep Fenton

harmless against all associated actions and expenses.1

1      It is common ground that Carlton is entitled to claim against Fenton in respect of its liability to the landlord pursuant to s 98 Land Transfer Act 1952 (which continues to apply to this lease

[7]      Under the lease rent is payable quarterly on the first day of the months of March, June, September and December in each year during the term.  Each quarterly payment is $63,250 inclusive of GST.

[8]      During the period 1 September 2011 to 31 May 2013, Carlton says there was a shortfall between the amount Fenton paid to the Trust Board and the amount…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fenton Projects Limited v Carlton Gore Holdings Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 2872
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fenton Projects Limited applied to the High Court of New Zealand to set aside a statutory demand served by Carlton Gore Holdings Limited, which sought payment of $63,579.62 for outstanding rent and other sums due under a lease. The dispute centres on whether there is a substantial dispute as to whether the debt is owing or due, as required by s 290(4)(a) of the Companies Act 1993. The primary issue before the court was whether Fenton had a substantial dispute over its liability to pay the debt claimed by Carlton.

The court found that there was no substantial dispute that Fenton had failed to make the full payments required under the lease, as the evidence showed that Fenton had indeed made payments totalling $387,733.82 against the required total of $451,313.44. The court also noted that Fenton did not provide any evidence to challenge the accuracy of the schedule detailing the shortfall. Moreover, the court held that Carlton was entitled to seek payment of the shortfall from Fenton under the assignment of lease, which included an implied covenant for indemnity.

Carlton had the benefit of implied covenants from Fenton to indemnify it for any shortfall and had paid the Trust Board to cover Fenton's defaults. The evidence from Carlton's accountant and director confirmed these facts, and Fenton did not provide any counter-evidence to challenge these claims. The court concluded that there was no substantial dispute over the existence of the debt, as Fenton had failed to pay the full amount due under the lease and Carlton had indeed paid the shortfall to the Trust Board.

The court dismissed Fenton's application to set aside the statutory demand and ordered Fenton to pay the debt of $63,578.95 within ten working days of the judgment. The court also declined to order interest on the debt, stating that any entitlement to interest under the contractual arrangements between the parties should be pursued separately. Costs were reserved, with Carlton having the option to seek indemnity costs under the assignment of lease.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established