Fee v Rennell HC Auckland CIV 2010-404-005853

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2010-404-005853

BETWEEN  JONES FEE Appellant

ANDJOHN ALFRED RENNELL AND PENELOPE JANE RENNELL Respondents

Hearing:         24 February and 2 March 2011

Counsel:         M Muir for Appellant

K F Gould for Respondents

Judgment:      22 March 2011 at 12:00 PM

JUDGMENT OF FOGARTY J

[1]      At an undefended hearing on 11 May 2010 in the District Court (Judge Sharp) judgment was entered based on admission in the sum of $136,872.30 together with interest and costs against the appellant.

[2]      The appellant then successfully applied to have the judgment set aside.  This was done by Judge Wilson QC on 11 August.  It was on the grounds that there had been no notice to the address of service of the hearing date, 11 May.

[3]      The reason why the Judge found this is contained in paragraph [28] of his judgment which reads:

[28]     Mr  Gould  submitted  that  the  judgment  had  not  been  regularly obtained by the plaintiffs because notice of the hearing was not served on Mr and Mrs Rennells at their specified address for service.   Notice of the hearing was sent correctly to the solicitors acting but not to the nominated address for service.  Accordingly Mr and Mrs Rennells are entitled to have this judgment set aside. Judgment is set aside accordingly.

[4]      It is necessary to explain the second sentence.

JONES FEE V JOHN ALFRED RENNELL AND PENELOPE JANE RENNELL HC AK CIV 2010-404-005853

22 March 2011

[5]      The new District Court form No. 3 provides:

Section 1:  Defendant’s details

...

1C      Defendant’s address for service

...     Rennells  Jewellers  and  Engravers,  115  Main  Highway,  Ellerslie, Auckland 1051

...

1F

Name of defendant’’s lawyer

Name:  Roger D. Cann

Firm:    Wilson McKay

...

Contact details of defendant’s lawyer for serving forms

Street address:   Wilson McKay House, 1A St. Vincent Avenue, Remuera, Auckland

[6]      The solicitors for the applicants for the judgment had sent notice of the date of hearing to Rennells Jewellers, 15 Main Highway, Ellerslie, instead of 115 Main Highway. They had also sent notice of the date of hearing to Wilson McKay House.

[7]      Essentially Judge Wilson ignored that notice to Wilson McKay and accepted the argument that there had not been notice of hearing because of a misaddress to Rennells Jewellers and Engravers.

[8]      Mr Muir’s clients, Jones Fee, have appealed the judgment of Judge Wilson. Mr Muir put up a sophisticated argument seeking to draw a distinction between the function of cl 1C and the function of cl 1F.     I do not think they have separate functions.     Both  provide  a  mechanism  whereby  the  defendants  can  receive documents relating to the claim and including notices of hearing.

[9]      There is a problem with this form in that it does not address the fact that a defendant  can  effectively  provide  two  addresses  for  service.    It  is  a  source  of

confusion.  The problem has been identified by the Rules Committee.  I anticipate that in due course the form will be amended.  In the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fee v Rennell HC Auckland CIV 2010-404-005853 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 234
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Fee v Rennell involved an appeal against a judgment set aside by Judge Wilson QC, which had previously been granted in the sum of $136,872.30 plus interest and costs. The appellant, Jones Fee, sought to reinstate the original judgment on appeal. The legal issues in this case were whether the original judgment was obtained irregularly due to a misaddress of the hearing notice and whether the respondents had a serious argument against the merits of the original judgment. The court found that the original judgment was obtained regularly, as the respondents' lawyers had received notice of the hearing, and thus the misaddress to the respondents' business address did not affect the regularity of the judgment. The court further held that the respondents had no basis to argue against the merits of the original judgment, as the admission of liability had been signed by one of the respondents on behalf of both parties. The appeal was allowed and the original judgment was reinstated.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established