Fabian v New Zealand Government

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-4576 [2013] NZHC 1891

BETWEEN  TYRONE MAUNGA URAUTUNI FABIAN

Plaintiff

ANDNEW ZEALAND GOVERNMENT First Defendant

ATTORNEY GENERAL Second Defendant

Hearing:                   On the papers

Appearances:

Judgment:                29 July 2013

COST JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SARGISSON

This judgment was delivered by me on 29 July 2013 at 4 pm pursuant to

Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date ..........................

FABIAN v NEW ZEALAND GOVERNMENT [2013] NZHC 1891 [29 July 2013]

[1]      I  issued  a  judgment  on  28  June  2013  striking  out  the  plaintiff’s  fourth amended statement of claim and making an order dismissing the proceeding.   I reserved the issue of costs in respect of which I made the following observations:

[27]     On the matter of costs I make these observations: ordinarily, under the statutory costs regime, costs will follow the event.   This may be a case where costs are not pursued or if they are pursued, costs would be warranted on a Category 1 Band A basis given that the issues are so clear cut.  If costs are pursued, counsel for the Attorney is to file and serve a memorandum within 5 working days and Mr Fabian is to have a further 5 working days in which to respond should he wish to do so.

[2]      Counsel for Attorney has filed a memorandum seeking costs on a Category 1

Band basis for costs of $3,498 and disbursements of $1,408.16, making a total of

$4,906.16.

[3]      The plaintiff in his memorandum filed in response seeks that no order for costs be made.  Essentially, his submission is twofold.  He says he tried his best to rectify the deficiencies in his statement of claim in circumstances where he was unable to secure legal representation.  Secondly, he says he receives a pension which is his only income.

[4]      I accept that there may be a certain pointlessness in making an order for costs given the plaintiff’s limited income.  I also accept that he has struggled without legal representation to comply with the Court’s direction that the claim be pleaded in conformity  with  the  basic  requirements  in  the  High  Court  Rules  regulating pleadings.   However, during the process of case management the Associate Judge who was case managing the file gave clear indications that the plaintiff’s pleading was seriously deficient and did not comply with those basic requirements.   Such requirements apply to all litigants including those who lack representation, and are designed to ensure that all parties (represented or unrepresented) have fair notice of the opposing party’s case.  Unfortunately for the plaintiff it is incumbent on him to comply with those requirements as it is on other litigants.  He has had the benefit of considerable time to get his pleading in order without putting the defendant to the unnecessary time and cost of being put to the trouble of making a formal application.

[5]      Additionally, the plaintiff can now be in no doubt that his claim was doomed to fail given that it was based on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fabian v New Zealand Government and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 1891
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Fabian v New Zealand Government, the plaintiff, Tyrone Maunga Urau Tuni Fabian, brought a claim against the New Zealand Government and the Attorney General. The plaintiff sought to assert claims related to Maori sovereignty, which the defendants sought to have dismissed as untenable. The High Court of New Zealand struck out the plaintiff's fourth amended statement of claim and dismissed the proceeding. The court reserved the issue of costs, which the Attorney General subsequently sought to have awarded on a Category 1 Band A basis. The plaintiff opposed the application, citing his limited income and lack of legal representation. The court found that, while there were circumstances warranting some discount, the statutory presumption that costs follow the event should not be departed from. However, the court allowed a discount for the straightforward nature of the case, the plaintiff's lack of representation, and his limited income. The court ordered that the Attorney General was entitled to costs in the amount of $3,322.16.

The court was required to determine the appropriate amount of costs to be awarded to the Attorney General in light of the plaintiff's opposition to the application. The court considered the plaintiff's submissions and the statutory costs regime, which ordinarily provides that costs follow the event. The court found that there were circumstances warranting some discount, including the straightforward nature of the case, the plaintiff's lack of representation, and his limited income. The court also noted that the plaintiff had been given clear indications that his pleading was seriously deficient and had the opportunity to discontinue the proceeding at a point when it was clear that the claim was doomed to fail. The court balanced these factors against the statutory presumption and ordered that the Attorney General was entitled to costs in the amount of $3,322.16.

The court found that the statutory presumption that costs follow the event should not be departed from in this case. However, the court allowed a discount for the straightforward nature of the case, the plaintiff's lack of representation, and his limited income. The court noted that the plaintiff had been given clear indications that his pleading was seriously deficient and had the opportunity to discontinue the proceeding at a point when it was clear that the claim was doomed to fail. The court ordered that the Attorney General was entitled to costs in the amount of $3,322.16. The court also made no order for costs on the steps taken in respect of the case management conferences and related memoranda and appearances.

The court ordered that the Attorney General is entitled to costs in the amount of $3,322.16 and that the plaintiff is not to pay any costs on the steps taken in respect of the case management conferences and related memoranda and appearances. The court also ordered that the Attorney General is entitled to the disbursements claimed of $1,408.16.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established