Exuberant Limited v Quinovic Property Management Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2019-485-595

[2021] NZHC 3533

BETWEEN

EXUBERANT LIMITED

First Plaintiff

AKSHAYA KHERA
Second Plaintiff

AND

QUINOVIC PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LIMITED

First Defendant

TE ARO PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LIMITED
Second Defendant

ROSS SCOTT DAVEY and LANA DOREEN DAVEY

Third Defendants

Hearing: 25 November 2021

Appearances:

P Dalkie and D Watson for plaintiffs T Gee and E Cox for defendants

Judgment:

20 December 2021


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE JOHNSTON


Introduction and background

[1]    The only aspect of this case that remains for determination is the costs payable by the  plaintiffs,  Exuberant  Ltd  and  Akshaya  Kera,  to  the  defendants,  Quinovic Property Management Ltd, Te Aro Property Management Ltd and Ross and Lana Davy, pursuant to a recent order made by Cooke J. On first blush, that sounds

EXUBERANT LIMITED v QUINOVIC PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LIMITED [2021] NZHC 3533
[20 December 2021]

straightforward. It has turned out to be anything but. The costs issue was set down for a full day’s hearing. There were preliminary skirmishes about the mode of hearing and evidence. The parties filed and served no fewer than eight affidavits, including affidavits sworn by legal practitioners offering opinion evidence. Both practitioners were cross examined. Counsel filed and served lengthy written submissions, which were supplemented by oral submissions at the hearing.

[2]For all that, the factual background is not especially complex.

[3]    Quinovic Property Management Ltd is a Wellington-based property management company. At all material times Mr and Mrs Davy were shareholders in and directors of the company, which has franchised its business throughout the country. Exuberant was  incorporated  in  anticipation  of  acquiring  a  franchise.  Ms Khera was and is the company’s sole shareholder and director.

[4]    During the first half of 2017, between late March and early May, following an involved  series  of  transactions  that  there  is  no  need  to  describe  here,  Quinovic Property Management and Exuberant entered into an agreement pursuant to which Quinovic Property Management granted to Exuberant a non-exclusive franchise to operate in Wellington. To provide some measure of the scale of the concern, I record that Exuberant paid close to $800,000 for the business, and a further $60,000 fee which was treated as consideration for training that Quinovic Property Management was to provide.

[5]    From the start, the relationship between Quinovic Property Management and Exuberant was less than harmonious. In late 2018, Quinovic Property Management commissioned a report as to the operation of Exuberant’s business from an independent party. The report which emerged was critical of the way in which the business was being managed by Ms Khera.

[6]    In early 2019, a series of reviews of Exuberant appeared on social media which were extravagantly laudatory of the company and its business.

[7]    When Mr and Mrs Davey became aware of these reviews, they were sceptical about their provenance and authenticity. Quinovic Property Management embarked upon  an  investigation.  Ultimately,  the  company  concluded  that  Exuberant  or Ms Khera were the source of these reviews.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Exuberant Limited v Quinovic Property Management Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZHC 3533
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerns the costs payable by the plaintiffs, Exuberant Ltd and Akshaya Khera, to the defendants, Quinovic Property Management Ltd, Te Aro Property Management Ltd and Ross and Lana Davey, pursuant to a recent order made by Cooke J. The central issue in the case was whether or not Exuberant and Ms Khera were the source of the reviews. This issue was the focus of the early interlocutory stages of the proceeding up until March 2021. Ultimately, the defendants sought a search order and secured documentation establishing that Exuberant and Ms Khera were indeed the source of the reviews, directly contradicting the premise of their claim. Exuberant and Ms Khera sought to abandon the claim but the defendants applied for orders refusing the plaintiffs leave to discontinue, striking out the proceeding and ordering the plaintiffs to “pay the defendants’ costs, disbursements and witness expenses occasioned by the plaintiffs’ claim, on a solicitor-client basis, including the costs of this application”. Cooke J made orders that the plaintiffs’ claim was struck out and the defendants were entitled to indemnity costs on the basis they are entitled to such solicitor and client costs under the terms of the relevant contract. The plaintiffs were to make an interim payment of costs to the defendants in the amount of $63,693.50. The plaintiffs sought to avoid paying the full amount of the costs claimed by the defendants because a proportion of their solicitor’s fee notes were addressed to a third party, and thus, the defendants did not incur these costs. The defendants filed and served a further affidavit sworn by Mr Cox who is the solicitor on the record. Mr Dalkie objected to this affidavit being received into evidence on the grounds that its receipt would prejudice the plaintiffs, who had no opportunity to reply, and that the contents of the affidavit were controversial and yet Mr Cox was the defendants’ solicitor and appearing, with Mr Gee, as counsel. Associate Judge Johnston declined to allow the affidavit to be read. The issues for determination were: the scope of the franchise agreement insofar as it confers on Quinovic Property Management a right to recover costs and disbursements; the defendants’ actual costs and disbursements; and the reasonableness or otherwise of the same. The primary term in the contract dealing with costs was cl 33. The defendants’ actual costs were $609,790.69 and disbursements were $251,071.64. In terms of reasonableness, the overriding requirement is that the costs claimed must be reasonable. It is an objective exercise and the Court must make a principled assessment of reasonableness against stated criteria. Both counsel made detailed submissions. There is no escaping that the difference between the views of the two experts is huge. Mr Wilson offers the view that, taken overall, the defendants’ costs are reasonable and is prepared to support total fees of $609,790. Ms McMahon, on the other hand, takes the view that the maximum costs that could be regarded as reasonable is $245,138.82. In the end, Associate Judge Johnston agreed with Mr Wilson’s overall approach, which emphasises an assessment of the overall reasonableness of the costs charged against the job done bearing in mind the NZLS factors and the other considerations. The view taken by Ms McMahon appears to give too much weight to time expended. The overall maximum fee that was arrived at for this work was $347,768.31, together with all claimed disbursements. Costs in relation to this interlocutory application were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.