ETWEEN LAI JANICE TOY Appellant AND THE KING Respondent

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA472/2023
 [2024] NZCA 446

BETWEEN

LAI JANICE TOY
Appellant

AND

THE KING
Respondent

Hearing:

26 June 2024

Court:

Ellis, van Bohemen and Hinton JJ

Counsel:

A J Hamblett for the Appellant
B J Thompson and B So for the Respondent

Judgment:

16 September 2024 at 10.00 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The application to adduce fresh evidence is declined.

B        The appeal against conviction and sentence is dismissed.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Hinton J)

  1. This is an appeal against conviction and sentence for contravening orders made under the Animal Welfare Act 1999 (the Act).

Background

  1. On 1 November 2017, Ms Toy was found guilty of five animal welfare offences following a judge-alone trial before Judge Mabey KC.[1]  The convictions related to Ms Toy’s ill-treatment and neglect of cats and a goat.  For that offending, Ms Toy was made subject to a five-year disqualification order under s 169 of the Act.[2]  The order disqualified Ms Toy from owning, exercising authority over, or being in charge of animals and was effective from 1 November 2017. 

    [1]Waikato SPCA v Toy [2017] NZDC 13795.

    [2]Waikato SPCA v Toy [2017] NZDC 24951 [2017 Sentencing notes].

  2. Between November 2017 and March 2020, the Society for the Protection of Cruelty to Animals (the SPCA) received information that Ms Toy was breaching the disqualification order.  SPCA animal welfare inspectors observed animals on Ms Toy’s property on several occasions and, on 29 May 2020, the SPCA executed a search warrant at that property.  Ms Toy was the only person present.  The inspectors located over 100 animals on the property.  Most were seized and removed.

  3. Ms Toy was charged with one representative charge under s 169B(1) of the Act which provides that it is an offence to contravene a disqualification order.

  4. On 6 April 2023, following a trial before Judge S Clark and a jury in the District Court at Hamilton, Ms Toy was found guilty of contravening the disqualification order.

  5. On 21 July 2023, the Judge sentenced Ms Toy to two years’ intensive supervision and ordered her to pay $3,000 in reparation to the SPCA.[3]  It was a special condition of this order that Ms Toy not be in a position of care, ownership or exercise authority over any animals at any time.

    [3]R v Toy [2023] NZDC 25148 [judgment under appeal].

  6. The Judge also made a further five-year disqualification order under s 169 of the Act.[4]  That order took effect from the date of sentencing and again prohibited Ms Toy from being the owner of, or exercising authority over, or being the person in charge of, animals for a five-year period.

Grounds of appeal

[4]The 2017 order had, by then, expired.

  1. Ms Toy’s appeal against conviction is on the basis that a miscarriage of justice occurred for three reasons:

    (a)the Judge misdirected the jury on mens rea;

    (b)the Judge erroneously assumed animals are not taonga protected by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ETWEEN LAI JANICE TOY Appellant AND THE KING Respondent and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZCA 446
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lai Janice Toy appeals her conviction and sentence for contravening a disqualification order under the Animal Welfare Act 1999. The appeal was heard by Ellis, van Bohemen, and Hinton JJ in the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. Lai Janice Toy was previously found guilty of animal welfare offences and was subject to a five-year disqualification order, prohibiting her from owning, exercising authority over, or being in charge of animals. Despite this, she continued to care for numerous animals on her property, leading to her charge and subsequent conviction for breaching the disqualification order. The Crown opposed both the conviction and sentence appeals. Lai Janice Toy's grounds for appeal against conviction include claims that the trial judge misdirected the jury on mens rea, erroneously assumed animals are not taonga protected by the Treaty of Waitangi, and wrongly excluded evidence of tikanga in relation to animal welfare. The Court found no merit in these arguments, confirming that the judge's directions on mens rea were correct and that there was no miscarriage of justice. Regarding the sentence appeal, Lai Janice Toy argued that her sentence was manifestly excessive, but the Court found the sentence appropriate and consistent with sentencing principles. The five-year disqualification order was deemed justified by the nature of her previous offences and her continued disregard of court orders. The reparation order of $3,000 was also considered fair, taking into account Lai Janice Toy's limited financial means. Consequently, the appeal against both conviction and sentence was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established