ETB Realty Ltd v Eastlight Asset Trading No 3 Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2015-485-000682 [2016] NZHC 609

UNDER the Companies Act 1993

BETWEEN

ETB REALTY LIMITED Applicant

AND

EASTLIGHT ASSET TRADING NO 3

LIMITED Respondent

Appearances:

S M Hunter and O de Pont for Applicant

B R Young for Respondent

Judgment:

8 April 2016

(Determined on the papers)

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE

on costs

Introduction

[1]      On 18 August 2015, the respondent (Eastlight) served a statutory demand on the applicant (ETB).  The demand stated that ETB was indebted to Eastlight in the sum of $142,000 “in respect of refunds due for deposits … in respect of the unit titles properties at … Fenton Street”.

[2]      ETB applied within the required 10 working days for an order setting aside the demand.  It supported its application with an affidavit of its sole director, Glenn Austin, who exhibited the voluminous historical documents (comprising three bound volumes) pertaining to the Fenton Street transactions.

[3]      The Registrar allocated 6 October 2015 as the first call date.

ETB REALTY LIMITED v EASTLIGHT ASSET TRADING NO 3 LIMITED [2016] NZHC 609 [8 April 2016]

[4]      The statutory demand had been prepared and executed on behalf of Eastlight by its director, Mr Kooiman.   Upon receipt of the setting aside application, Mr Kooiman took legal advice from Mr Young.  Mr Young has advised the Court that Mr Kooiman, upon receipt of that advice, immediately instructed him to withdraw the statutory demand.

[5]      Mr  Young  confirmed  the  withdrawal  of  the  statutory  demand  to  ETB’s

solicitors some days in advance of the first call.

[6]      The Court then vacated the hearing and made directions for the filing of submissions as to costs, ETB having signalled its intention to seek indemnity costs.

[7]      The application itself was not formally dismissed, a matter which  I will attend to in the order to be made below.

ETB’s application for costs

[8]      ETB applies for orders as to costs against both Eastlight and Mr Kooiman. [9]           Submissions have been filed both for and against the costs application.

[10]     Although Mr Young’s costs memorandum is entitled as a memorandum of counsel for “the respondent”, it is clear that his memorandum was filed not only on behalf of Eastlight but also on behalf of Mr Kooiman.   Mr Young concluded his frank memorandum with the following plea:

As previously stated, Mr Kooiman accepts that there will be a cost to what he now knows to be his ill-advised actions but asks that the Court considers his plea in mitigation in the assessment of the sum.

ETB’s precise claim

[11]     Despite its earlier anticipation of an application for indemnity costs, ETB has elected to pursue increased costs.  ETB seeks increased costs through a 50 per cent

uplift on a 2B1  calculation.  Counsel for ETB confirms that the increased costs, if awarded, will be less than ETB’s actual costs as between solicitor and client.

[12]     ETB also seeks an order for costs against Mr Kooiman as a non-party.

Application for increased costs

[13]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ETB Realty Ltd v Eastlight Asset Trading No 3 Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 609
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, ETB Realty Limited sought to set aside a statutory demand issued by Eastlight Asset Trading No 3 Limited, claiming it was based on an unmeritorious argument. The statutory demand was for $142,000, representing refunds due for deposits related to unit title properties at Fenton Street. ETB applied for the demand to be set aside, arguing that Eastlight's demand was ill-advised and based on a flawed argument that ignored previous court judgments and the doctrine of issue estoppel.

The court had to determine whether ETB was entitled to increased costs due to the unmeritorious nature of the statutory demand. The legal issue involved whether the statutory demand was ill-advised and whether increased costs were warranted under the High Court Rules. ETB argued for a 50% uplift on a 2B1 cost calculation, which the court found to be justified given the circumstances. Additionally, ETB sought costs against Mr Kooiman, the sole director of Eastlight, arguing he should be held liable for the costs due to his active role in the litigation.

The court found that the statutory demand was indeed ill-advised and that Mr Kooiman's actions were improper. The court awarded ETB increased costs, totaling $8,028 plus disbursements of $2,264.77. Additionally, the court ruled that Mr Kooiman should be jointly liable for these costs, as he had an active role in the litigation and a substantial financial interest in the outcome. The court dismissed the application to set aside the statutory demand, but made directions for the filing of submissions as to costs.

In conclusion, the court ordered Eastlight Asset Trading No 3 Ltd and Michael Edwin Kooiman to pay ETB Realty Ltd its costs and disbursements, totaling $8,028 and $2,264.77 respectively, as well as the costs of submissions in relation to this costs application, which the court fixed at $1,115.00.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established