IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE
CIV-2024-485-603645
[2024] NZHC 2502
IN THE MATTER of an Order calling upon Executor to show cause why probate should not be granted to the Other Executor alone date 24 May and the Consent memorandum dated 24 June 2024 IN THE ESTATE
of RAELYN EDNA PETERS-EGGERS
Hearing: On the Papers Counsel:
M L Harkness for Ms Shaw
C R Osborne for Interested Party K C Eggers
Judgment:
3 September 2024
JUDGMENT OF McQUEEN J
[Costs]
[1] This is an application for costs in respect of an interlocutory application for an order nisi. The applicant, Ms Shaw, seeks increased or indemnity costs, or 1B scale costs. The respondent (to the costs application), Mr Eggers, submits that costs should lie where they fall, and disputes that Ms Shaw’s third set of costs submissions should be considered by the Court. However, if the Court makes a costs order, Mr Eggers says 1A would be the appropriate scale, subject to disputing the recoverability of specific steps.
Background and procedural history
[2]The will-maker, Raelyn Edna Peters-Eggers, died on 28 August 2023.
ESTATE OF PETERS-EGGERS [2024] NZHC 2502 [3 September 2024]
[3] The executors named in the deceased’s will are Ms Shaw (the deceased’s sister), Mr Eggers (the deceased’s husband) and Mr Gilbot-Ducray (the solicitor who held the will).
[4] After a breakdown in relationship with Mr Eggers, Mr Gilbot-Ducray renounced his appointment as one of the executors of the will and accepted that the estate should be administered through the grant of probate.
[5] In February 2024, Ms Shaw filed an ex parte application for an order nisi calling on Mr Eggers to show cause why probate of the will should not be granted to Ms Shaw or some other person. This was supported by an affidavit from Ms Shaw which says Mr Eggers would not sign the documents required for grant of probate and raised concerns about dissipation of assets by Mr Eggers because of a difficult relationship between him and other beneficiaries. Ms Shaw is not a beneficiary of the estate.
[6] On 14 May 2024, the Deputy Registrar granted the application. The matter was listed for call in the Judge’s Chambers List on 10 June 2024.
[7] On 29 May 2024, counsel for Ms Shaw, Ms Harkness, filed a memorandum in the Court recording that it was understood that service had been effected on Mr Eggers and that Ms Shaw sought that probate be granted to her solely.
[8] Counsel for Mr Eggers, Mr Ballantyne, filed a memorandum dated 5 June 2024 recording Mr Eggers’ position, which was that he did not accept that he has refused to prove the will or renounce his right and title to probate and execution of the will. Mr Eggers said that he had made all reasonable efforts to contact Ms Shaw in relation to the grant of probate but she was overseas and was he unable to advance…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Estate of Peters-Eggers and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NZHC 2502
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court began by examining the principles governing the determination of costs. Costs generally follow the event, but the court has discretion to make orders if the parties cannot agree. The court considered the submissions and affidavits from both parties, noting the factual dispute over who was obstructing or delaying the application for probate. The court found that it could not resolve these factual disputes on affidavit evidence and shared concerns about allowing a costs hearing to become a mini-trial on substantive issues that had been resolved by consent. The court concluded that neither party could be considered the unsuccessful party in the proceeding, as both agreed to appoint an independent executor early in the proceeding.
Taking all the circumstances into account, the court determined that an award of costs to Ms Shaw against Mr Eggers was not appropriate. However, the court found that the filing of the application for the order nisi was a straightforward proceeding, appropriately classified as category 1 under the High Court Rules. A comparatively small amount of time was reasonable for such a step, making band A under the Rules appropriate. The court directed that the executor of the estate, Mr Smith, consider paying Ms Shaw the costs and disbursements relating to the filing of that application on a category 1A basis, being $1,590, plus a filing fee of $200 and the cost of sealing the order $50, as an expense of administration.
Ultimately, the court dismissed the applications for costs and directed that costs, including costs on the costs applications, should lie where they fall. The court provided a copy of the judgment to Mr Smith, the executor of the estate of Ms Peters-Eggers.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi