Estate of O'Carroll

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TIMARU REGISTRY

CIV-2017-476-000005 [2017] NZHC 1797

UNDER Sections 14 and 31 Wills Act 2007

IN THE MATTER

of the Will of WINIFRED ISABELLA O'CARROLL

BETWEEN

ALISTAIR KENNETH MCCUTCHEON Applicant

Hearing: 24 July 2017

Appearances:

G M Brodie for Applicant and the children and grandchildren of the late William Ross McCutcheon and the late

Kenneth Leith McCutcheon
P A Bradford for the children and grandchildren of the late
Lena Mary Rae

Judgment:

1 August 2017

JUDGMENT OF DUNNINGHAM J

Introduction

[1]      The late Winifred O’Carroll died in Auckland on 28 April 2011, aged 101. She   was   survived   by   various   nieces   and   nephews   and   grand-nieces   and grand-nephews.  She made a will on 22 September 2009.  However, shortly before her death, she instructed her solicitor to prepare a new will.  Before it was finalised and executed, Mrs O’Carroll died.

[2]      In the circumstances, these proceedings deal with the following issues:

(a)       whether the document prepared in April 2011 (altered to reflect her

solicitor’s file note of 20 April 2011), (“the unsigned 2011 will”),

ESTATE OF WINIFRED ISABELLA O’CARROLL [2017] NZHC 1797 [1 August 2017]

should be validated under the Wills Act 2007 and admitted to probate, or whether the will of the deceased dated 22 September 2009 (the

2009 will) should be admitted to probate? and

(b)regardless  of whether the 2009  will  or the unsigned  2011  will  is admitted to probate, whether an alleged mistake in those documents should be rectified under s 31 of the Wills Act 2007?

Background

[3]      While the late Mrs O’Carroll had been married, she never had children.  She did, however, have two sisters and three brothers, three of whom had children.  All her siblings predeceased her.

[4]      Mrs  O’Carroll’s  sister,  Lena  Mary  Rae,  had  three  children.    She  had  a daughter, Sara (but known as Sadie), who had seven children who all survived Mrs O’Carroll.   Lena also had two sons, one of whom died without issue, and another son, William Kelvin Rae, who had eight children, seven of whom survived Mrs O’Carroll.  William is a specific legatee in the 2009 will, but not the unsigned

2011 will.

[5]      One of Mrs O’Carroll’s brothers, William Ross McCutcheon, had a daughter

and two grandchildren.

[6]      Another brother, Kenneth Leith McCutcheon, had five children. They are: (a)         Patricia Marlene McCutcheon, who is adopted;

(b)      Shona Winifred Stoddart; (c)    Keith Ross McCutcheon;

(d)      Glynis Lynette Sullivan; and

(e)       Alistair Kenneth James McCutcheon.

He also had 12 surviving grandchildren.

[7]      The applicant, Alistair McCutcheon, is a surviving nephew, and is named as one of the executors and trustees in both the 2009 will and the unsigned 2011 will.

[8]      The assets of Mrs O’Carroll’s estate primarily comprise cash deposits in the

bank,  and  loans  to  various  family  members,  although  one  of  these,  a  loan  of

$180,000 to Katrina Glass, is contested.

The 2009 Will

[9]      The  last  will  executed  by  the  late  Mrs  O’Carroll  is  her  will  dated

22 September   2009.      It   was   prepared   by   her…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Estate of O'Carroll and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 1797
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand was asked to decide whether a will prepared shortly before Winifred O'Carroll's death should be admitted to probate. The court was also asked to determine if a mistake in the will should be rectified under section 31 of the Wills Act 2007. The applicant, Alistair McCutcheon, was a surviving nephew and named as one of the executors and trustees in both the 2009 will and the unsigned 2011 will. The court found that the unsigned will reflected Mrs O'Carroll's settled testamentary intentions, except for the record of the funds advanced to the nieces and nephews. The court also found that the mistake in the will could be cured through section 31 of the Wills Act 2007. The court ordered that the unsigned will be declared the valid last will and testament of the deceased and that it be amended to reflect the deceased's clear intentions.

The court's decision was based on the evidence presented by the solicitor who had been acting for Mrs O'Carroll since 1999. The court was satisfied that the unsigned will represented the concluded testamentary intentions of Mrs O'Carroll, except for the record of the funds advanced to the nieces and nephews. The court found that the mistake in the will could be cured through section 31 of the Wills Act 2007 by directing the deletion of the relevant clause and substituting a new clause that reflected the deceased's instructions. The court also found that the costs of involving counsel to represent the children and grandchildren of Lena Mary Rae should be awarded from the estate rather than from public funds.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.