Estate of Howie

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2013-485-5314 [2014] NZHC 346

IN THE MATTER             of the estate of Ruth Annie Howie

BETWEEN  ANTHONY CLIVE SANDLANT, ROBERT DUDLEY BERRY and MICHAEL MCLEAN TOEPFER Plaintiffs

Hearing:                   On the papers

Counsel:                  NL Penman-Chambers for plaintiffs

NA Farrands for Sashabel Pty Ltd, Annabel Rose Hutchinson and Sasha Daisy Hutchinson

JS Caen for Elaine Margaret Mary Hutchinson

Judgment:                3 March 2014

JUDGMENT OF FAIRE J

Solicitors:           Hesketh Henry, Auckland 1142

Morrison Kent, Auckland

Simpson Grierson, Auckland

Estate of RA Howie [2014] NZHC 346 [3 March 2014]

[1]      The plaintiffs apply for alternative orders granting probate in solemn form of the will of the late Ruth Annie Howie, dated 14 June 2011, or alternatively an order granting probate in solemn form of the will of the late Ruth Annie Howie, dated

14 April 2008.

[2]      The reason for the application is that an issue arises as to the testatrix’s testamentary capacity in respect of the will dated 14 June 2011.  The parties directly affected by this issue are the daughters of the deceased’s nephew, Ben Hutchinson, namely Annabel and Sasha Hutchinson who are the subject of specific requests in the will of 14 June 2011, and Elaine Hutchinson who is the surviving spouse of Owen Hutchinson, who is the son of the deceased’s cousin and who is granted a one- seventh interest in residue in the will of 14 June 2011.

[3]      Counsel for Annabel and Sasha Hutchinson confirm that they support the grant of probate in respect of the will dated 14 April 2008.   That is significant because it is in fact against their interests.

[4]      Elaine Hutchinson’s counsel confirms that she abides the decision of the

court.

[5]      Counsel confirm that there is no further evidence other than that so far filed in affidavit form that could assist the court in determining the testamentary capacity of the deceased as at 14 June 2011.

The relevant legal principles

[6]      The law in relation to testamentary capacity is well settled.  Before a Will is admitted to Probate it must be established that that Will was the product of a sound mind.  In short, the testatrix must, at the time the Will is made, be of sound mind, memory and understanding.1

The issue of testamentary capacity is one of fact.  It must be established in the light of  those  well-established  principles.    Unless  the  court,  on  a  review  of  all  the

1      Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549 at 567.

evidence, is able to affirmatively declare itself satisfied of a testatrix’s competence

when she executed the Will the court must declare against its validity.2

[7]      Once a doubt is raised as to the existence of testamentary capacity, an onus rests  on  the  person  propounding  the  Will  to  satisfy  the  court  that  the  testatrix retained her mental powers to the requisite extent.3

[8]      What I am required to do is to ascertain:

a)       If the testatrix understood the nature of the act of making a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Estate of Howie and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 346
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the High Court of New Zealand concerns the estate of Ruth Annie Howie, with the plaintiffs, Anthony Clive Sandlant, Robert Dudley Berry, and Michael McLean Toepfer, seeking orders for the granting of probate of two wills dated 14 April 2008 and 14 June 2011. The dispute revolves around the testamentary capacity of Ruth Annie Howie at the time she executed the will dated 14 June 2011. The daughters of Ben Hutchinson, Annabel and Sasha Hutchinson, along with Elaine Hutchinson, the surviving spouse of Owen Hutchinson, are directly affected by this issue.

The court had to determine whether Ruth Annie Howie had the necessary testamentary capacity when she executed the will dated 14 June 2011. The court's reasoning involved assessing the testatrix's understanding of the nature of making a will, the extent and character of the property she was disposing of, and her comprehension of the claims upon her by the beneficiaries and those excluded from her will. The court found that there was a clear doubt regarding the deceased's testamentary capacity on 14 June 2011, primarily due to the low scores she obtained on mental status tests administered by Dr Budelmann and Dr Paul Owen. Consequently, the court declared the will of 14 June 2011 invalid. However, no such doubt existed regarding the will dated 14 April 2008, which was found to be valid based on the presumption of competency in the absence of contrary evidence.

In light of the findings, the court granted probate in solemn form for the will dated 14 April 2008, subject to the executors providing an affidavit confirming their willingness to act and complete the administration of the estate. The court reserved leave for any further orders that may be required and noted that no order for costs was necessary unless special circumstances warranted otherwise.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.