Estate of Cleveland

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV 2016-485-183 [2016] NZHC 601

IN THE ESTATE OF ANNA MARIA CLEVELAND

MICHAEL DAVID FERRARI Applicant

On the papers

Judgment:

7 April 2016

JUDGMENT OF MALLON J

[1]      An  application  is  made  under  s  14  of  the Wills Act  2007  for  an  order declaring that a document is the valid will of Anna Maria Cleveland, a deceased person. The application is made because the will does not comply with s 11(4) of the Wills Act 2007.  The witnesses to Ms Cleveland’s signature were not together when she signed the document.  It is also not known if Ms Cleveland had already signed the document when it was witnessed or acknowledged that she had done so.

[2]      Ms Cleveland died on 14 September 2015.  A document dated 14 November

1998 was found in her papers. The document is handwritten.  It is almost in identical terms to a typewritten will dated 26 June 1987 but has the following changes:

(a)      The executor  in  the new will  is  Ms  Cleveland’s  brother,  Michael Ferrari, whereas under the earlier will it was her son, Craig Cleveland, and her son-in-law, David McElwee.

(b)The  earlier  will  permitted  Craig  Cleveland  to  remain  living  in  a property until he was the owner of his own property. That is not in the

new will.

ESTATE OF CLEVELAND [2016] NZHC 601 [7 April 2016]

(c)      The new will includes a new clause giving investment funds to her children ($25,000 to Craig and the balance equally to her daughters, Louise and Ruth).

[3]      In both the old and new wills Louise and Ruth were given their mother’s jewellery.   Under both wills the three children share equally in the balance of the estate.

[4]      An affidavit has been filed by Mr Ferrari.   He deposes to Ms Cleveland’s death and he attended her funeral.  He recalls Ms Cleveland asking him in 1998 if he would agree to being named as her executor in the will she was preparing.   He annexes consents from the beneficiaries under the new will (Craig, Louise and Ruth) to the order that is sought.

[5]      An affidavit has been filed by Gerard Hoskins.   He was one of the two witnesses to the new will.  He and his wife were friends of Ms Cleveland and her husband.  He recalls an occasion in 1998 when Ms Cleveland arrived at his house with a document.  She described it as “one of those family matters” and gave him a folded paper which she asked him to sign.  She was secretive about its contents but Mr Hoskins assumed it was her will.   He signed the document and Ms Cleveland then left.   He says the other person shown as a witness on the document, M R Sinclair, Secretary, Wellington, was not present and must have signed it on a separate occasion at another location.

[6]      Affidavits have been filed by Louise, Ruth and Craig.  They each depose that they understood from their mother that under her will she…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Estate of Cleveland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 601
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Estate of Anna Maria Cleveland case involved a dispute regarding the validity of a handwritten will dated 14 November 1998. The applicant, Michael David Ferrari, sought a declaration that this document was the valid will of Ms Cleveland, who passed away on 14 September 2015. The primary issue was whether the will complied with section 11(4) of the Wills Act 2007, which requires that the witnesses to the will must be present together when the testator signs it. In this case, the witnesses were not present together when Ms Cleveland signed the document, and it was not clear if she had signed it before the witnesses were present.

The court had to determine whether the will was a valid testamentary document despite the procedural flaw. Ferrari, the proposed executor, provided an affidavit stating that he had been asked by Ms Cleveland in 1998 to be her executor and had given his consent. Additionally, the beneficiaries under the new will—Craig, Louise, and Ruth—provided affidavits expressing their belief that the new will reflected their mother's testamentary intentions. Gerard Hoskins, one of the witnesses, also provided an affidavit stating that Ms Cleveland had given him a document to sign, which he assumed was her will, though the other witness, M R Sinclair, was not present at the time.

After considering the affidavits and the evidence presented, Mallon J concluded that the document indeed expressed Ms Cleveland's testamentary intention. The court was satisfied that the will was a valid expression of her wishes and granted the declaration that the document was the valid will of Anna Maria Cleveland. Consequently, the draft order filed by the applicant was approved for issuance.