IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND INVERCARGILL REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA WAIHŌPAI ROHE
CIV-2023-425-21
[2025] NZHC 191
UNDER the Judicial Review Procedure Act 2016 IN THE MATTER
of an application for review
BETWEEN
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW INITIATIVE
Applicant
AND
ENVIRONMENT SOUTHLAND
Respondent
Hearing: 30 September, 1-2 October 2024 Appearances:
D A C Bullock and K L Calder for the Applicant
P A C Maw and M A Mehlhopt for the Respondent
Judgment:
18 February 2025
JUDGMENT OF HARLAND J
INTRODUCTION
[1] This application for judicial review by the Environmental Law Initiative (ELI) concerns the legality of the Southland Regional Council’s1 approach to its obligations to monitor, report and act on monitoring under the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA).
[2] ELI's concerns arise in the context of the need to preserve and protect Southland’s wetlands. Under s 6(a) of the RMA, the preservation of wetlands and the protection of them from inappropriate subdivision, use and development is a matter of
1 The Southland Regional Council trades as “Environment Southland” but will be referred to here as “the Council”.
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW INITIATIVE v ENVIRONMENT SOUTHLAND [2025] NZHC 191 [18 February 2025]
national importance. It is not contested that Southland's wetlands have been significantly degraded in recent decades. Several of ELI's concerns also involve more general issues about the legality of the approach of the Council under the RMA.
[3]The application is opposed by the Council.
THE PLEADINGS—AN OVERVIEW
[4] ELI is an incorporated charitable trust board and a registered charity. Its main objective is to support the protection of natural resources and the environment in Aotearoa New Zealand. Its specific charitable purposes include the preservation, conservation, protection and enhancement of natural and cultural resources, to prevent their harm, misuse, depletion, unsustainable use and destruction.
[5] One way ELI achieves these objectives is by researching technical, legal and scientific environmental issues. One issue ELI is concerned about is the rapid and ongoing loss of wetlands, the ineffectiveness of local authorities to prevent wetland loss and the wider consequences for the environment arising from that loss.
[6] The Council has various functions, powers and duties in relation to the environment. Specifically, under s 30(1) of the RMA and most relevant to this case, its functions to:
(a) control the use of land for the purpose of maintaining and enhancing the quality of water in water bodies and ecosystems in water bodies, as well as maintaining the quantity of water in water bodies;2
(b) establish rules in its regional plan to allocate the taking or use of water (other than coastal water);3 and
(c) establish, implement and review objectives, policies and methods for maintaining indigenous biological diversity.4
2 Resource Management Act 1991 [RMA], s 30(1)(c)(ii), (iii), (iii)(a).
3 Section 30(1)(fa)(i).
4 Section 30(1)(ga).
[7] The first cause of action alleges that the Council has failed to comply with its statutory duties under the RMA, specifically s 35(2)(b) (to monitor the effectiveness and efficiency of the policies, rules or other methods in its…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Environmental Law Initiative v Environment Southland and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] NZHC 191
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The High Court found that the Council's interpretation of "its plan" in s 35(2)(b) was incorrect. The Court held that the term "plan" included rules in the proposed plan that had become operative under s 86F of the RMA. The Court rejected the Council's argument that its obligations under s 35(2)(b) only applied to the operative plan, noting that this interpretation was inconsistent with the legislative history and the purpose of the RMA.
Consequently, the Court found that the Council had failed to comply with its obligations under s 35(2)(b) by not monitoring and reporting on the efficiency and effectiveness of rules in both the operative and proposed plans. The Court also found that the Council had failed to comply with its obligations under s 35(2A) by not compiling and making available to the public a review of the results of its monitoring under s 35(2)(b).
The Court issued declarations that the Council had failed to comply with its statutory obligations under ss 35(2)(a), (b) and 35(2A) of the RMA. However, the Court declined to issue orders directing the Council to comply with its obligations, finding that declarations were a sufficiently effective form of relief. The Court emphasised that the declarations would provide guidance to the Council and other councils on the execution of their s 35 duties. The applicant was awarded costs.