Energy Beverages LLC v Prolife Foods Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2019-485-263

[2019] NZHC 1691

BETWEEN

ENERGY BEVERAGES LLC

Appellant

AND

PROLIFE FOODS LIMITED

Respondent

Hearing: 15 August 2019

Appearances:

K McHaffie and P Moodley for the Appellant S Aymeric and J A Hazel for the Respondent

Judgment:

26 September 2019


JUDGMENT OF CULL J


TABLE OF CONTENTS

Background  4

The Assistant Commissioner’s decision  10

Approach to appeal  14

Legal framework  20

Grounds of appeal  25

Issues  26

Issue One: section 17(1)(a)  27

The reputational threshold - the awareness of Energy Beverages' marks  28

Likelihood of deception or confusion  44

(a)The similarity of the goods  48

(b)The similarity of the marks  62

(c)Any other circumstances relevant to the likelihood of deception or confusion                   75

Conclusion under s 17(1)(a) of the Act  79

Issue Two: section 25(1)(b  80

Findings  87

Results  89

ENERGY BEVERAGES LLC v PROLIFE FOODS LIMITED [2019] NZHC 1691 [26 September 2019]

[1]                 Energy Beverages LLC (Energy Beverages) appeals against the decision of the Assistant Commissioner of Trade Marks (the Commissioner) to direct that two trade mark applications of Prolife Foods Ltd (Prolife Foods) proceed to registration.1

[2]Energy Beverages opposed the applications to register the marks

and  (Prolife Foods’ marks), and now appeals her decision.2 Energy Beverages says the Commissioner erred in fact and in law in finding that Energy

Beverages failed in their grounds of opposition under s 17(1)(a) and s 25(1)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 2002 (the Act). Energy Beverages’ marks are set out in Appendix I to this judgment.

[3]                 Energy Beverages seeks orders reversing the Commissioner’s decision, that both Prolife Foods’ marks should not be registered, and costs, including a reversal of the costs awarded by the Commissioner.

Background

[4]                 On 12 August 2015 and 3 February 2016 respectively, Prolife Foods lodged applications to register the Prolife Foods’ marks. The marks are both ‘combined’ marks.

[5]The August 2015 application was for the mark      with the mark name

“MOTHER EARTH NATURE AT ITS MOST DELICIOUS FRUIT BITES”.

[6]The February 2016  application was  for the  mark      with the

mark name “MOTHER EARTH NATURE AT ITS MOST DELICIOUS ON-THE- GO!”

[7]                 The applications for Prolife Foods’ marks are both in relation to class 29 and 30 goods. Class 29 goods are described as preserved, dried and cooked fruits and vegetables, jellies, jams, preserves, nuts, edible nuts, food products made from nuts, prepared nuts, nut blends, spreads in the class of peanut butter, dried fruit, and dried


1      Prolife Foods Ltd v Energy Beverages LLC [2019] NZIPOTM 12.

2      Enlarged copies of the marks are displayed in Appendix II of this judgment.

fruit blends. Class 30 goods are described as essentially any and all types of baking product, chocolates, snack foods including muesli bars, cereals, dried fruit and nuts, and importantly in this case, beverages including coffee, tea, cocoa, chocolate-based beverages, cocoa-based beverages and drinking powders including chocolate and cocoa drinking powders.3

[8]                 Energy Beverages filed notices…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Energy Beverages LLC v Prolife Foods Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 1691
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Energy Beverages LLC appeals against the decision of the Assistant Commissioner of Trade Marks to direct that two trade mark applications of Prolife Foods Limited proceed to registration. The Commissioner had dismissed Energy Beverages’ opposition to Prolife Foods’ proposed marks. Energy Beverages contends that the Commissioner erred in fact and in law in finding that Energy Beverages failed in their grounds of opposition under s 17(1)(a) and s 25(1)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 2002. The court dismissed the appeal and upheld the Commissioner’s decision. The court found that Energy Beverages had failed to establish the necessary level of awareness of its mark in the New Zealand market under s 17(1)(a) of the Act. The evidence provided by Energy Beverages was not sufficiently robust or reliable to justify an alternative finding. Although the threshold requirement for market awareness is low, the evidence adduced by Energy Beverages at the relevant dates was not sufficiently robust or reliable, in the court’s view, to justify an alternative finding. The court also found that Energy Beverages had failed to show that the marks were sufficiently similar under s 25(1)(b) of the Act. The marks were not visually, aurally, or conceptually similar. The minor degree of similarity in the marks, namely the use of the word “MOTHER”, the lack of visual, aural, and conceptual similarity between the two respective sets of marks, and the limited similarity of goods in respect of the specification of beverages only, satisfied the court that there was no likelihood of deception or confusion if Prolife Foods’ proposed trade marks were registered. The court concluded that in these circumstances, the relevant consumers would not likely be deceived or confused.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established