Emslie v Genuine Investments Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2004-404-4803

IN THE MATTER OF

BETWEEN

Section 145 of the Land Transfer Act 1952

VALERIE JOAN EMSLIE AND GORDON WILLIAM EMSLIE

Applicant

AND

GENUINE INVESTMENTS LIMITED

First Respondent

AND

JUDITH MAY CHEYNE AND MACKY TRUSTEE COMPANY LIMITED AS TRUSTEES OF THE RS TRUST

Second Respondent

Hearing:

By memoranda

Appearances: Mr J T Burley for applicants

Mr R O Parmenter for second respondents Judgment:  24 February 2005 at 12.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE LANG

[re Costs]


[1]    In my judgment delivered on 28 January 2005 I indicated that it was my tentative view, given the particular circumstances of this case, that costs should lie where they fall. I reserved leave to the parties, however, to submit  memoranda should either of them wish to advance a different proposition.

[2]    Both counsel have now filed memoranda. The applicants seek an order for costs on a category 2B basis in their favour.

[3]    Mr Burley for the applicants emphasises that costs should usually follow the event and that in this case the second respondents actively opposed the application

EMSLIE V GENUINE INVESTMENTS LIMITED And Anor HC AK CIV-2004-404-4803 24 February 2005

and that their efforts in this regard were ultimately unsuccessful. On that basis Mr Burley submits that there is no reason to depart from the usual principle that the unsuccessful party should be required to meet the costs of the successful party.

[4]Mr Parmenter submits that costs should lie where they fall.

[5]    My tentative view that costs should lie where they fall was influenced by the fact that the underlying dispute between the parties remains unresolved. The second respondents may ultimately establish that their interest in the property has priority over that of the applicants. It might seem wrong, therefore, to award costs against  the second respondents when their assertions might ultimately be shown to be correct. Having reflected further on the matter, I am satisfied that the costs of this application fall to be determined independently of the underlying dispute between the parties. It should be determined in accordance with the principles generally applied by the Court in fixing costs.

[6]    Although costs are in the discretion of the Court, nevertheless that discretion must be exercised in accordance with the principles set out in Rule 47 and 48 of the High Court Rules. First and foremost of those is the principle that, generally speaking, the unsuccessful party should be required to contribute to the cost of the successful party.

[7]    In the present case the second respondents sought to be joined to the proceeding. They did so on the basis that they wished to actively oppose the continued existence of the caveat. Having been given leave to participate in the proceeding they made submissions in opposition to the  application.  Ultimately these were not upheld by the Court. They were therefore the unsuccessful party in relation to the application.

[8]    In those circumstances I am satisfied that, notwithstanding the fact that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Emslie v Genuine Investments Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NZHC 1838
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Emslie v Genuine Investments Limited involved a dispute between Valerie and Gordon Emslie and Genuine Investments Limited, along with Judith May Cheyne and the Macky Trustee Company Limited as trustees of the RS Trust, regarding a property. The applicants sought to have the second respondents, who had been granted leave to join the proceeding, removed as parties to the action and to have their caveat on the property removed. The case was heard by Associate Judge Lang in the High Court of New Zealand, Auckland Registry.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the second respondents should remain as parties to the proceeding and whether the applicants were entitled to an award of costs. The applicants argued that, as the second respondents actively opposed their application and their efforts were ultimately unsuccessful, they should be required to meet the costs of the successful party. The second respondents, on the other hand, contended that costs should lie where they fall due to the unresolved nature of the underlying dispute.

The court held that, despite the unresolved nature of the underlying dispute, the costs of the application should be determined independently of the main dispute. The court noted that, in general, the unsuccessful party should contribute to the costs of the successful party. As the second respondents were unsuccessful in their opposition to the application, they were the unsuccessful party. However, the award of costs was reduced by 20 per cent to reflect that part of the hearing was directed to the issue of whether the second respondents should remain as parties to the proceeding. The applicants were thus entitled to an award of costs and disbursements in their favour, calculated on a category 2B basis, with disbursements to be fixed by the Registrar.