Elite Advance Tiling Limited v Bellaroc Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2016-409-001238 [2017] NZHC 878

BETWEEN

ELITE ADVANCE TILING LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

BELLAROC LIMITED Defendant

Hearing: 4 April 2017

Appearances:

R A Hearn for Plaintiff
G K Riach for Defendant

Judgment:

4 May 2017

INTERIM JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS

[1]      Elite Advance Tiling Limited (Elite) applies to set aside a demand issued against it under s 289 of the Companies Act 1993 by Bellaroc Limited (Bellaroc) dated 15 December 2016.  The application is made under s 290 of the Companies Act.    To  the  extent  relevant,  s  290(4)  provides  that  the  Court  may  grant  an application to set aside a statutory demand if it is satisfied that there is a substantial dispute over whether or not the debt is owing or is due, or if it appears that the company has a counterclaim set-off or cross-demand against the creditor.

[2]      In the demand Bellaroc claims that it is owed $22,267.13 by Elite for goods supplied to Elite in the form of materials used in the course of tiling, though not tiles.

[3]      In Industrial Group Ltd v Bakker the Court of Appeal said:1

… the statutory scheme is for applications to set aside statutory demands [is] a summary proceeding. …  The section calls for a prompt judgment as to whether there is a genuine and substantial dispute.   …   The test may be

1      Industrial Group Ltd v Bakker [2011] NZCA 142, (2011) 20 PRNZ 413 at [24]-[25].

compared   with   the   principles   developed   in   cognate   fields   such   as applications to remove caveats, leave to appeal an arbitrator’s award …

…  The tight time constraints distinguish the s 290 discretion from that to be exercised on, say, a summary judgment application, where the presence of complex legal issues is not necessarily a bar to a remedy.  As with leave to appeal an arbitrator’s award, the hearing should, in the normal course, be short and to the point, and the judgment likewise.

[4]      In AAI Ltd v 92 Lichfield Street Ltd (in rec and in liq), the Court of Appeal said:2

[22]   It is important to keep in mind the words of the statute.   What the applicant must show is that the dispute it raises has substance; the applicant must explain to the court what the dispute is; and the dispute so shown must be real and not a fanciful or insubstantial dispute. …  [However] The Court must  also  keep  in  mind  the  requirement  that  what  is  intended  to  be  a summary hearing should not be converted into a full-blown trial.

[5]      The events which gave rise to the sums claimed in the notice issued by Bellaroc are part of a factual matrix involving not only Elite and Bellaroc, but also a company called Build Team Limited (Build Team).  Both Bellaroc and Build Team Limited are controlled by Mr S W North.  Elite is controlled by Mr A C O Araujo. Elite carries out tiling.   Bellaroc supplies tiling materials.   Build Team carries out…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elite Advance Tiling Limited v Bellaroc Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 878
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Elite Advance Tiling Limited sought to set aside a statutory demand issued by Bellaroc Limited, which claimed Elite owed $22,267.13. The dispute involved complex financial interrelations between Elite, Bellaroc, and Build Team Limited. The High Court of New Zealand had to decide whether there was a substantial dispute over the debt or if Elite had a counterclaim against Bellaroc.

Elite argued there was a substantial dispute over whether it owed the full amount claimed by Bellaroc. Elite contended that there was an agreement with Bellaroc and Build Team that payment would not be required until Build Team was paid by Mark Prosser Builders, the principal contractor. However, Build Team did not pursue legal action against Mark Prosser Builders. Additionally, Elite claimed Bellaroc owed it $14,202.50 for work done at Bellaroc's showroom, which Bellaroc denied. The Court found that these arguments presented a genuine dispute over the debt, as well as an arguable counterclaim, justifying setting aside the statutory demand.

The Court acknowledged the intertwined financial affairs of the three companies and the need for caution in making orders that could isolate certain financial positions from others. Despite finding grounds to set aside the demand, the Court decided to exercise its discretion not to do so immediately, given the complex financial relationships and the potential impact on Build Team's liquidation proceedings. The Court's decision would depend on the outcome of the application to liquidate Build Team.

The application to set aside the statutory demand was adjourned for further consideration. Costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.