Elder

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV2011-404-002766 [2012] NZHC 289

UNDER  Part 5 of the Insolvency Act 2006

IN THE MATTER OF     a Proposal made by Collin James Elder

BETWEEN  COLLIN JAMES ELDER Insolvent

CIV 2011-404-002767

AND UNDER                 Part 5 of the Insolvency Act 2006

IN THE MATTER OF     a Proposal made by Adeline Wei Wei Elder

BETWEEN  ADELINE WEI WEI ELDER Insolvent

Hearing:         20 February 2012

Appearances: M J Whale for the Applicants

H Schoonraad for the Commissioner of Inland Revenue in Opposition

Judgment:      22 February 2012

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE CHRISTIANSEN

This judgment was delivered by me on

22.02.12 at 4:30pm, pursuant to

Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Solicitors/Counsel:

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

J Whale, Lowndes Associates, Auckland – whale@lowndeslaw.com

COLLIN JAMES ELDER and ADELINE WEI WEI ELDER HC AK CIV 2011-404-002766 / 002767 [22

February 2012]

H Schoonraad, Inland Revenue, Auckland – hanno.schoonraad@ird.govt.nz

The application

[1]      The  applicants  (Mr  and  Mrs  Elder)  have  applied  under  Part  5  of  the Insolvency Act 2006 (the Act) for approval of their Proposals for their combined payment of a total sum of $224,000 payable to their creditors over three years.  The Proposals offered creditors 12 cents in the dollar owed to them.

[2]      The Court has no ability to hear a joint Proposal application, hence the filing of separate Proposals.  Because Mr and Mrs Elder have a number of joint debts, their two applications were heard together before me.

The Proposals

[3]      On 18 May 2011 a creditors meeting was held in relation to the Proposals. Five creditors voted in favour of the proposals and three against.  The total amount of proven claims was $3,171,397.67 of which $2,509,346.98 was owed to creditors who voted for the Proposals, and $662,050.69 was owed to creditors who voted against the Proposals.

[4]      Those against were the Inland Revenue Department (the Commissioner) to whom  $79,100.00  was  owed,  Origin  Mortgage  Management  Services  (2008) Limited (Origin Mortgage) to whom $390,800.00 was owed, and Westpac.

[5]      Before Mr and Mrs Elders’ Proposals were filed, Origin Mortgage had filed and  served  applications  to  adjudicate  Mr  and  Mrs  Elder  bankrupt.     Those applications  have  been  held  over  pending the  Court’s  decision  on  Mr  and  Mrs Elders’ Proposal applications.

[6]      The Commissioner has filed an opposition to the Proposals.  That opposition is supported by Origin Mortgage.   It is not supported by Westpac even though Westpac voted against the Proposal at the creditors meeting.

[7]      The Proposal Trustees have applied for the Court’s order approving those Proposals, they being satisfied the voting outcome of the creditors meeting has provided them with authority to do so.

[8]      Section 333(3) of the Act provides:

...

(3)      The Court may refuse to approve the proposal if it considers that:

(a)      the provisions of this sub part have not been complied with;

or

(b)      the  terms  of  the  proposal  are  not  reasonable  or  are  not calculated to benefit the general body of creditors; or

(c)      for  any  reason  it  is  not  expedient  that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elder and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 289
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Collin James Elder and Adeline Wei Wei Elder applied for approval of their debt repayment proposals under the Insolvency Act 2006. The Proposals offered creditors 12 cents in the dollar owed to them over a three-year period. The Commissioner of Inland Revenue opposed the Proposals on the grounds that the terms were unreasonable, speculative, and not in the public interest. The Commissioner argued that the largest creditor, Anna Ng, who was related to Mrs Elder, should not have been allowed to vote on the Proposals. The Commissioner also argued that the proposals were speculative given the uncertain and unreliable nature of the Elders' earnings. The Commissioner claimed that the Elders posed a risk to the commercial community and to the integrity of New Zealand's tax system. The Court rejected the Commissioner's arguments, finding that there was no evidence that the related parties had voted in any other way than independently and that the terms of the Proposals were in fact calculated to benefit the general body of creditors. The Court found that there was sufficient certainty of payment of the distribution to creditors and that the Proposals were not speculative. The Court also found that there was no continuing threat or harm to the commercial community and bankruptcy was not required to protect the public from the Elders. The Court granted approval of both Proposals in the form submitted for approval.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established