Eaton v LDC Finance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2008-409-001140 [2013] NZHC 728

BETWEEN  STEPHEN DESMOND EATON, SEDDON JAMES MARSHALL Plaintiffs

ANDLDC FINANCE LIMITED First Defendant

ANDPRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS Second Defendant

ANDPERPETUAL TRUST LIMITED Third and Counterclaim Defendant

ANDBUDDLE FINDLAY Fourth Defendant

ANDANDREW JOHN HARDING, MURRAY SCHOLFIELD

Second Counterclaim Defendants

CIV-2013-409-000580

AND BETWEEN            RICHARD GRANT SIMPSON, DAVID IAN RUSCOE

Applicants

ANDSTEPHEN DESMOND EATON, SEDDON JAMES MARSHALL First Respondents

ANDANDREW JOHN HARDING, MURRAY SCHOLFIELD

Second Respondents

ANDPRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS Third Respondent

Hearing:         9 April 2013

On the Papers

EATON & Anor V LDC FINANCE LIMITED HC CHCH CIV-2008-409-001140 [11 April 2013]

Judgment:      11 April 2013

JUDGMENT OF FOGARTY J

Introduction

[1]      The Court has before it two originating applications.   The parties to these applications are all in agreement.  The applications relate to a settlement agreement of commercial litigation.  The applications are necessary because two of the parties to this settlement represent the interests of others.   In the 2013 proceedings the applicants are receivers of LDC Finance Limited, with responsibility to the secured and unsecured creditors of that company.   In the 2008 proceedings, the plaintiffs Messrs Eaton and Marshall, represented unsecured depositors of the partnership of Messrs Harding and Scholfield, which traded as Finance and Investments (F & I).

The receivers’ application

[2]      Messrs Simpson and Ruscoe are now the receivers of LDC Finance Limited. They were appointed receivers following the judgment against that company of the High Court, delivered by myself, of 23 May 2011.  That judgment was appealed, and was set down for hearing in April 2013.   In mediation, the parties to those proceedings,   and   other   parties  in   potentially  related   proceedings   reached   a settlement. That settlement was subject to approval by the High Court.

[3]      The receivers seek the following directions:

(1)That they are acting reasonably in entering into a settlement of the proceedings and withdrawing the appeal, on the terms set out in the conditional settlement agreement entered into between the applicants and   the   respondents,   dated   6   March   2013   (“the   settlement agreement”).

(2)That  they  be  directed  to  proceed  to  confirm  and  implement  the proposed settlement on the terms set out in the settlement agreement; and

(3)This application be treated as confidential, and that no person may search the Court file in relation to this application without the leave of a Judge, sought on not less than 20 working days notice to the parties.

[4]      Section 34(1) of the Receiverships Act 1993 provides:

34     Court supervision of receivers

(1)     The court may, on the application of a receiver,—

(a)     give directions in relation to any matter arising in connection with the performance of the functions of the receiver:

(b)     revoke or vary any such directions.

[5]      The settlement is a compromise of the judgment of the High Court, which was wholly in favour of the plaintiffs Messrs Eaton and Marshall, as representatives of the F & I depositors.

[6]      I am satisfied from the affidavit of the receiver Mr R G Simpson that from the perspective of the receivers, having obligations to pursue the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Eaton v LDC Finance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 728
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand, Christchurch Registry, presided over by Fogarty J, was presented with two originating applications related to the settlement agreement of commercial litigation involving multiple parties. The plaintiffs, Messrs Eaton and Marshall, represented the interests of unsecured depositors of the partnership of Messrs Harding and Scholfield, which traded as Finance and Investments (F&I). The receivers of LDC Finance Limited, Messrs Simpson and Ruscoe, sought approval from the Court for the settlement of the proceedings and withdrawal of the appeal. The plaintiffs, in turn, applied for orders enforcing a trust in relation to the settlement funds.

The legal issues before the Court were whether the receivers were acting reasonably in entering into the settlement, and whether the plaintiffs could be appointed as trustees to enforce the settlement. The Court considered the provisions of the Receiverships Act 1993 and the Trustee Act 1956 in reaching its decision.

Fogarty J was satisfied that the settlement was the result of a prudent assessment of the litigation risks by the receivers, and that it was in the best interests of the secured and unsecured creditors of LDC. The Court also found that there was power under the Trustee Act to appoint Messrs Eaton and Marshall as trustees of the entitlements of the F&I depositors. The Court held that the application should be first notified to the depositors to allow for any objections before deciding whether or not to grant the application. The Court directed that a letter be sent to the depositors, along with a copy of the judgment, to inform them of the settlement and the pending application for Court approval.

In conclusion, the Court granted the receivers' application for directions and made the orders sought, subject to the depositors being notified. The Court also granted the plaintiffs' application for orders enforcing a trust, subject to the depositors being notified and any objections being considered. The Court found that the decision made by the trustees to enter into the settlement appeared to be prudent and worthy of sympathetic consideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.