Easton v Wellington City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA813/2010
[2011] NZCA 296

BETWEEN  BENJAMIN MORLAND EASTON
Appellant

AND  WELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL
Respondent

Counsel:         Appellant in Person

Judgment:      27 June 2011 at 10 am

JUDGMENT OF CHAMBERS J

A        The application to review the sum fixed by way of security for costs is dismissed. 

BThe appellant must pay security for costs of $5,560 on or before 5 July 2011.

REASONS

  1. Benjamin Easton, the appellant, has appealed against a decision of Clifford J delivered on 29 October last year.[1]  Clifford J’s decision dealt with two different civil proceedings.  The first was a purported appeal from a decision of the Environment Court.[2]  His Honour held he had no jurisdiction to hear that appeal, a conclusion which has subsequently been confirmed in this Court.[3]  That aspect is, therefore, off the table. 

    [1]Easton v Wellington City Council HC Wellington CIV-2010-485-678 and CIV-2010-485-748, 29 October 2010.

    [2]      CIV-2010- 485-678.

  2. The other proceeding was an application for judicial review of the Wellington City Council’s decision to revoke the pedestrian status of Manners Mall.[4]  The Judge struck out that proceeding.  Mr Easton appeals against that aspect of the decision. 

    [4]      CIV-2010-485-748.

  3. The Registrar fixed security for costs at $5,560.  Mr Easton sought an order dispensing with security.  The Registrar, by decision dated 10 May 2011, refused to dispense with security.  She did not accept Mr Easton’s submission that the appeal was “high profile and significant”.  Although she accepted Mr Easton was “impecunious”, she referred to the following passage from a decision of Arnold J, in which His Honour dealt with an application for review of a security for costs decision.  This application involved the same Mr Easton who is appealing in the present case.  Arnold J said:[5]

    [5]       The appellant receives an unemployment benefit and appears to have little else in the way of income or assets.  I accept that he is impecunious.  However, impecuniosity does not automatically mean that security for costs should be waived, although it may well lead to a reduction in the amount awarded: see MacLeod v Housing New Zealand Corporation Limited HC AK M256/02 9 October 2002 at [9].  The touchstone is whether the interests of justice require that a waiver or dispensation be given: see Blanshard v The National Life of Australasia Limited HC AK CIV-2001-404-001961 10 December 2003 at [8].  It is relevant to consider whether the appellant’s appeal rights will be rendered nugatory if no appeal is granted, but it is also relevant to consider the merits of the appeal to see whether the appellant has an arguable case.  A respondent should not be put to the expense of arguing a meritless appeal without some protection for its costs. 

  4. I accept the correctness of that approach.  I also consider the Registrar’s decision in the present case was clearly correct. 

  5. First, the grounds of appeal are very weak.  The first ground…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Easton v Wellington City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZCA 296
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Benjamin Morland Easton appealed against a decision of Clifford J, who dismissed an application for judicial review of a Wellington City Council decision to revoke the pedestrian status of Manners Mall. The court held that Easton's grounds of appeal were weak, with no apparent arguable case. The court noted that Easton had no grounds to challenge the former Mayor of Wellington’s vote on the matter, as the Environment Court had already heard the matter afresh. The court found that Easton’s appeal was unlikely to be successful, and the Wellington City Council would likely be entitled to costs if the appeal was unsuccessful. The court also noted that unless the Council had security for costs, it was unlikely to be able to recover any costs awarded in its favour. The public interest in the appeal was not considered to be high. Therefore, the appeal against the security for costs was dismissed, and Easton was required to pay the security for costs by a specified date.

The legal issue before the court was whether the Registrar's decision to deny Easton's application to be dispensed from paying security for costs was correct. The court held that the decision was correct for several reasons. Firstly, the grounds of appeal were weak, and the appeal was unlikely to be successful. Secondly, the Wellington City Council would likely be entitled to costs if the appeal was unsuccessful, which was a strong factor to be taken into account. Thirdly, the public interest in the appeal was not considered to be high. The court also noted that unless the Council had security for costs, it was unlikely to be able to recover any costs awarded in its favour. The court found that the Registrar's decision was correct, and Easton was required to pay the security for costs by a specified date.

The court found that the Registrar's decision was clearly correct, and the appeal against the security for costs was dismissed. The court found that the grounds of appeal were weak, and the appeal was unlikely to be successful. The court also noted that the Wellington City Council would likely be entitled to costs if the appeal was unsuccessful, and the public interest in the appeal was not considered to be high. The court held that the Registrar's decision was correct, and Easton was required to pay the security for costs by a specified date. The court further noted that unless the Council had security for costs, it was unlikely to be able to recover any costs awarded in its favour.

The final order of the court was that the application to review the sum fixed by way of security for costs was dismissed. The appellant was required to pay security for costs of $5,560 on or before 5 July 2011.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established