E v Police HC Napier CRI 2009-441-20

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CRI 2009-441-000020

E

Appellant

v

NEW ZEALAND POLICE

Respondent

Hearing:         24 August 2009

Appearances: R Fairbrother for the Appellant

D Kerr for the Respondent

Judgment:      24 August 2009

[ORAL] JUDGMENT OF WYLIE J [Appeal against conviction and sentence]

Solicitors:

R Fairbrother, P O Box 339, Napier 4140

Crown Solicitor, P O Box 609, Napier 4140

E V NEW ZEALAND POLICE HC NAP CRI 2009-441-000020  24 August 2009

[1]      On 4 May 2009, the appellant, Mr E  , was found guilty of trespass under s 3(1) of the Trespass Act 1980 following a defended hearing before His Honour Judge A J Adeane.  Mr E   was sentenced to 150 hours of community work and ordered to pay witness expenses of $50.

[2]      Mr E   has appealed against both his conviction and sentence.  The notice of appeal and the written submissions filed in support by Mr Fairbrother raise four issues.

a)       First,  Mr  E    complained  that  there  was  a  seven  month  delay between the date of the offence and the date when he was first made aware of the charge.  It was asserted that the prosecution should have been stayed as a result.

b)Secondly, it was argued that there was insufficient evidence to support the finding that the person who told Mr E   to leave the premises was the occupier of the property.

c)       Thirdly, it was submitted that the Judge’s decision, and in particular his sentencing notes, indicated a prejudicial bias which led him to make adverse findings as to Mr E  ’s credibility.

d)       Fourthly, it was argued that the sentence was manifestly excessive.

District Court decision

[3]      In his oral judgment, Judge Adeane noted that the case turned on what he made of the witnesses.

[4]      After  hearing  the  prosecution  evidence,  the  Judge  recorded  that  he  was satisfied from what he had heard, that a Mr Baird – a security guard – was present when the trespass occurred, that Mr Baird was an agent of the occupier of the premises for the purposes of the Trespass Act, and that any person who was not

entitled to be there was obliged to comply with any directions given by Mr Baird under the Act.

[5]      The Judge went on to say that he accepted Mr Baird’s evidence, namely that when the group of protesters achieved entry to the property, he told them on several occasions that they must leave.   The Judge rejected Mr E  ’s evidence to the contrary, saying that he found it difficult to reconcile Mr E  ’s evidence with statements that he knew that he was unwelcome at the property and that he would immediately be “trespassed” by the security guard.  It was Mr E  ’s assertion that he forewarned the group of protestors that they must comply with any direction by the security guard to leave the premises.

[6]      The Judge accepted that Mr E   was sincere in seeking to advance his cause but…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read E v Police HC Napier CRI 2009-441-20 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NZHC 1111
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal was against both the conviction and the sentence of Mr E for the offence of trespass under section 3(1) of the Trespass Act 1980. The appeal was heard before Wylie J in the High Court of New Zealand at Napier. The primary issues were whether there was sufficient evidence to support the finding that the person who directed Mr E to leave the premises was the occupier or the occupier's agent and whether the Judge exhibited any bias in his assessment of Mr E's credibility. The appeal was dismissed, and the conviction and sentence were upheld.

The Judge had found Mr E guilty based on the evidence that Mr Baird, a security guard working for Triko Security, had directed Mr E to leave the property. Mr E contested the sufficiency of the evidence that Mr Baird had the authority of the occupiers to require persons trespassing to leave and claimed that there was a delay of seven months between the offence and the charge, which should have resulted in the prosecution being stayed. Additionally, Mr E argued that the Judge's comments revealed a degree of bias against him and his cause. The appeal against sentence was later withdrawn.

Wylie J found that there was sufficient evidence to establish that Mr Baird was the agent of the occupiers and had the authority to require Mr E to leave the premises. The court considered Dr Goldenthal's evidence that he had instructed Triko Security to oversee the property and prevent trespassing. Mr Baird's evidence that he worked for Triko Security and had been alerted to the pending trespass supported the conclusion that he had the authority to direct Mr E to leave. The court further found that there was no evidence of judicial bias in the Judge's comments, as they were expressions of the Judge's view on the credibility of the witnesses and the nature of the offence, rather than a repulsion to Mr E's cause. The appeal was dismissed, and the conviction and sentence were upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established