Dwyer v South Taranaki District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NEW PLYMOUTH REGISTRY

CRI-2012-443-48 [2012] NZHC 3580

BETWEEN  SHAYLE DWYER Appellant

ANDSOUTH TARANAKI DISTRICT COUNCIL

Respondent

Hearing:         17 December 2012

Appearances: R Rai for appellant

J M Marinovich for respondent

Judgment:      21 December 2012

JUDGMENT OF ALLAN J

In accordance with r 11.5 I direct that the Registrar endorse this judgment with the delivery time of 10 am on Friday 21 December 2012

Solicitors:

Till Henderson Stratford, rajan.rai@thlaw.co.nz

C & M Legal, New Plymouth

DWYER V SOUTH TARANAKI DISTRICT COUNCIL HC NWP CRI-2012-443-48 [21 December 2012]

Introduction

[1]      The appellant appeals against a sentence of 10 months imprisonment imposed in respect of two charges of owning a dog involved in an attack causing serious injury.1     The maximum penalty for that  offence  is  a  term  of imprisonment  not exceeding three years, or a fine not exceeding $20,000.

[2]      Mr Dwyer had pleaded  guilty to one charge involving an attack on Lee Ashford, but he had defended the charge involving an attack on Karl Parker.  He had also pleaded guilty to a charge of failing to comply with the effects of classification of the dog as menacing.2   On that charge he was convicted and discharged.

[3]      In addition to the sentence of imprisonment, Judge Roberts directed that the appellant pay reparation of $1042 for the cost of impounding the dog, and to cover sustenance costs.  That amount was paid in full at the time of sentencing and there is no appeal against the order.3

Background

[4]      The dog concerned in this offending was a pit bull terrier, Monster.  It was secured on the appellant’s property by a long leash which enabled it to roam the backyard, and also to obtain access to virtually all points within his house.  The two victims were visitors, who were in the house at the time of the attack.  Although there was evidence that the dog was restrained by a long leash, Judge Roberts found that, at the time of the relevant attacks, it was effectively unrestrained.

[5]      The appellant and several associates were inside the house drinking.  Initially the dog jumped on an adult female, taking hold of her by the shoulder and endeavouring to drag her to the ground.  Mr Parker intervened. The dog latched onto

his  right  arm,  causing  a  puncture  wound  and  a  large  deep  wound  to  his  inner

1 The Dog Control Act 1996, s 58.

2 The Dog Control Act s 33EC(1).

3 South Taranaki District Council v Dwyer DC Hawera CRI-2012-021-451, 10 October 2012

forearm.   Ultimately the dog let go.   Mr Parker was taken to hospital, where his wound required surgery and 10 stitches.

[6]      Then the dog focused on Ms Ashford.  She attempted to leave the house via a window.  The dog fastened onto her left leg, causing a large puncture wound in the area of her Achilles, her ankle and her foot.  She managed to kick the dog free.  She too was taken to hospital, where she underwent surgery to repair…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dwyer v South Taranaki District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 3580
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Shayle Dwyer appeals against a sentence of 10 months imprisonment for owning a dog involved in an attack causing serious injury. The dog, a pit bull terrier, attacked two visitors at the appellant's property. The appellant had pleaded guilty to one charge, but defended the charge involving the second victim. He was also convicted of failing to comply with the effects of the dog's classification as menacing, but was discharged on that charge. The court was required to determine whether the sentence of 10 months imprisonment was appropriate and whether the starting point of 12 months was too high. The court considered comparable sentencing authorities, finding that the starting point in this case was higher than in previous cases, except for one which was much more serious. The court found that the starting point should have been eight months imprisonment, but reduced it by one month to take account of mitigating factors. The appeal against sentence is allowed, and the sentence of 10 months imprisonment is quashed. The court substitutes a sentence of seven months imprisonment on each of the two charges, to be served concurrently.