Duncan v Taylor HC Auckland CIV-2007-404-296

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2007-404-296

BETWEEN  BRUCE LESLIE DUNCAN ALISON LESLEY DUNCAN BRUCE CYRIL MCNIECE

AS TRUSTEES OF THE BL AND AL DUNCAN FAMILY TRUST

Plaintiffs

ANDALICIA JEAN TAYLOR First Defendant

ANDPHILIP SHAW SCOTHERN Second Defendant

ANDRAYMOND FREDERICK DEN OTTER SONIA EDWARDS

Third Defendants

ANDTHE AUCKLAND CITY COUNCIL Fourth Defendant

ANDTHE REGISTRAR GENERAL OF LANDS

Fifth Defendant

Hearing:         5 October 2011

Counsel:         KF Gould for Plaintiffs

SA Grant and K Dawson for Defendants

Judgment:      5 October 2011

ORAL JUDGMENT OF RODNEY HANSEN J

Solicitors:           Bruce C McNiece, P O Box 99, Shortland Street, Auckland for Plaintiffs

Barrie Hopkins, P O Box 106-027, Auckland for Defendants

BRUCE LESLIE DUNCAN V ALICIA JEAN TAYLOR HC AK CIV-2007-404-296 5 October 2011

[1]      In this proceeding the plaintiffs sought orders under the Property Law Act

2007 for the creation of a new plan that accurately reflects the structures of flats on land at Baddeley Avenue, Kohimaramara in which the plaintiffs and the first, second and third defendants each had an interest in the fee simple and were parties to a registered cross-lease.  The plaintiffs also sought a contribution from the defendants to the cost of repairing a failed retaining wall on common property.

[2]      The  defendants,  in  opposing  the  plaintiffs’  claim,  sought  removal  of encroaching parts of the plaintiffs’ building and compensation for their unlawful occupation.   They also sought compensation and costs from the plaintiffs and damages for trespass to common property.

[3]      In my judgment delivered on 31 May 2010, I held that the plaintiffs were entitled to orders which would permit a new flats plan to be created and correct certificates  of title issued  for all  flats.    I also  made orders for the payment  of compensation in accordance with findings made in the judgment.  I left the precise terms of orders for future determination, concluding my judgment in the following terms:

I will consider a consent memorandum if agreement is reached on the terms of  the  orders.     Otherwise,  the  Registrar  should  arrange  a  telephone conference for the purpose of making directions necessary to dispose of all remaining issues.  These include the costs of implementing the orders and of this proceeding.

[4]      A new flats plan has now been prepared and the defendants wish to proceed to have new titles issued.  However, an issue has arisen as to whether the consent of the Auckland Council is required under Part 10 of the Resource Management Act

1991 (RMA).  The defendants say that consent is not required as the Court order was made under s 325(1) of the Property Law Act and s 325(4) of that Act provides that Part 10 of the RMA does not apply to a transfer or other disposition of land giving effect to an order under s 325(1).

[5]      The Registrar General of Lands has accepted that Part 10 of the RMA does not apply to a disposition pursuant to the Court order but has advised the defendants

that it requires further orders which will…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Duncan v Taylor HC Auckland CIV-2007-404-296 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1077
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this matter, the plaintiffs sought orders for the creation of a new plan that accurately reflects the structures of flats on land at Baddeley Avenue, Kohimaramara, where they and the defendants held interests in the fee simple and were parties to a registered cross-lease. The plaintiffs also sought a contribution from the defendants to the cost of repairing a failed retaining wall on common property. The defendants opposed the plaintiffs’ claim and sought removal of encroaching parts of the plaintiffs’ building, compensation for their unlawful occupation, and damages for trespass to common property. In a previous judgment, the court held that the plaintiffs were entitled to orders which would permit a new flats plan to be created and correct certificates of title issued for all flats. The court also made orders for the payment of compensation in accordance with findings made in the judgment. The court reserved the precise terms of orders for future determination, concluding its judgment by stating that if agreement was reached on the terms of the orders, a consent memorandum would be considered. Otherwise, the Registrar should arrange a telephone conference for the purpose of making directions necessary to dispose of all remaining issues.

In the current judgment, the defendants wished to proceed to have new titles issued, but an issue arose as to whether the consent of the Auckland Council was required under Part 10 of the Resource Management Act 1991. The defendants argued that consent was not required as the Court order was made under s 325(1) of the Property Law Act and s 325(4) of that Act provides that Part 10 of the RMA does not apply to a transfer or other disposition of land giving effect to an order under s 325(1). The Registrar General of Lands accepted that Part 10 of the RMA did not apply to a disposition pursuant to the Court order but advised the defendants that it required further orders which would permit the existing titles to be cancelled and new composite computer registers issued. The plaintiffs opposed the defendants' application, arguing that supplementary orders were not necessary and were designed to enable the defendants to avoid compliance with the Auckland Council’s Code Compliance Rules. The court rejected the plaintiffs’ argument and held that it was unnecessary to resort to any supplemental jurisdiction for the purpose of making the orders sought by the defendants.

The court held that the defendants were specifically exempt by the provisions of s 325 of the Property Law Act from complying with the Auckland Council’s Code Compliance Rules in cases such as the present. Accordingly, there was no possible basis on which they could be denied the orders now sought. The court made the following orders in accordance with the draft orders annexed to the affidavit of Mr Hopkins, sworn on 26 July 2011: (a) the Order affected the following pieces of land; (b) new flats plans, No. 435634 affecting Flat 4 and No. 435753 affecting Flats 1, 2 and 3, be deposited with Land Information New Zealand; (c) all the composite computer registers be corrected to show legal ownership of the structures depicted on the above plans 435634 and 435753 by registration of dealings to: (i) withdraw the charging orders, (ii) surrender the leases of all flats and regrant new leases, and (iii) discharge all existing mortgages and register replacement mortgages over the new composite computer registers, in accordance with the requirements of mortgagees and Land Information New Zealand; and (d) leave was reserved for the parties to seek further orders from the Court if necessary. As requested by Mrs Grant, the court reserved leave to the parties to apply for further orders, if required, in relation to the costs of implementing the terms of the judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established