Doyle v Doyle HC Auckland CP 331-Im/99

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
AUCKLAND REGISTRY CP 331-IM/99

BETWEEN ROLAND MICHAEL DOYLE
Plaintiff

AND BARBARA FLORENCE DOYLE
First Defendant

AND THE BODY CLINIC LIMITED
Second Defendant

Hearing: 21-23 May 2001

Counsel: K F Gould for Plaintiff B M Stainton for First Defendant D J Clark for Second Defendant

Judgment: 1 June 2001

(RESERVED) JUDGMENT OF MORRIS J

[1] A dispute between members of the Doyle family over the future ownership and possession of a property known as 21 The Esplanade, Whitianga lies at the heart of these proceedings. The present registered proprietors are the plaintiff Mr Doyle and the Second Defendant The Body Clinic Limited. They are registered as tenants in common in equal shares. The Body Clinic is a company controlled by Mrs Daniels. Mrs Daniels is Mr Doyle’s sister. The property was originally purchased in 1983 by Mr Doyle and the First Defendant, who is his mother. Mrs Doyle sold her interest to the Body Clinic in August 2000.

[2] Mr Doyle seeks an order under s 140 of the Property Law Act 1952 (“the Act”) for the sale of this property at public auction. This is opposed by Mrs Doyle. She claims when the property was purchased by her and her son in 1983 the purchase was made on the basis they would hold it in trust for her use and the use of family members during her lifetime. She further claims the property may be suitable for partition. The application is also opposed by The Body Clinic. Mrs Daniels agrees the property should be sold in the event of her mother’s claim being disallowed but asks me to direct it to be sold to The Body Clinic or herself pursuant to the provisions of s 140 (3) of the Act. This proposed course is not acceptable to Mr Doyle, who claims whatever be the value of the property as fixed by valuers at the present time, a public auction has the possibility of realising the true market value, particularly as it will be of interest to expatriate New Zealanders or a foreign investor.

[3] Mr Doyle also seeks rental from both Mrs Doyle and Mrs Daniels from 28 May 1996.

BACKGROUND

[4] The property originally belonged to Mrs Doyle’s parents. It was her childhood home. It has been used as a family home, a family run boarding establishment and a family run restaurant. Over the years Mrs Doyle, and to a limited extent Mrs Daniels, has spent considerable money on its maintenance and upkeep. Today it is in a somewhat rundown state. Mrs Daniels’ former husband runs a restaurant on the top floor and there are two flats on the bottom storey, one of which he occupies. The Body clinic occupies the other. The property is valued between $550,000 - $560,000. Mrs Doyle and Mrs Daniels have strong meaningful ties to the property. Mr Doyle has none. Mrs Doyle and Mrs Daniels want the property to remain in the family and they wish…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Doyle v Doyle HC Auckland CP 331-Im/99 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NZHC 432
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand, Auckland Registry, heard a case between Roland Michael Doyle, the plaintiff, and Barbara Florence Doyle, the first defendant, as well as The Body Clinic Limited, the second defendant. The dispute centred on the ownership and possession of a property known as 21 The Esplanade, Whitianga. Roland Doyle sought an order for the sale of the property at public auction, which was opposed by both Barbara Doyle and The Body Clinic Limited. Barbara Doyle claimed the property was purchased as a trust for her and her family's use during her lifetime, while The Body Clinic Limited sought to purchase the property from Barbara Doyle. Roland Doyle also sought rental payments from both Barbara Doyle and The Body Clinic Limited.

The primary legal issues the court had to address were whether the property was held in trust for Barbara Doyle and her family, and if so, whether an order for sale should be granted under section 140 of the Property Law Act 1952. The court also had to determine if there were sufficient reasons to refuse the order for sale, and whether the plaintiff was entitled to rental payments from the defendants.

The court found that there was insufficient evidence to support the claim that the property was held in trust for Barbara Doyle and her family, and rejected the claim. The court also dismissed the claim for rental payments, as there was no evidence to suggest that Barbara Doyle or The Body Clinic Limited made any profit from the property while in possession. Regarding the order for sale, the court held that there were no good reasons to refuse the order, as per section 140(1) of the Act. The court fixed a reserve price of $560,000 for the sale of the property and ordered that any party or The Body Clinic Limited could bid at the auction. The plaintiff was to bear the costs of the marketing and sale of the property, while each party was to bear their own costs in the proceedings.

In summary, the court dismissed the claims for rental payments and rejected the claim that the property was held in trust for Barbara Doyle and her family. The court granted the plaintiff's application for an order for sale of the property and fixed a reserve price for the auction. The plaintiff was ordered to bear the costs of the marketing and sale of the property, while each party was to bear their own costs in the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.