Dow v Royal Commission on the Pike River Coal Mine Tragedy

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV 2012-485-1441 [2012] NZHC 2404

BETWEEN  JOHN ALAN STUART DOW First Applicant

ANDRAYMOND FRANCIS MEYER Second Applicant

ANDSTUART JOHN NATTRASS Third Applicant

ANDPETER WILLIAM WHITTALL Fourth Applicant

ANDSTEPHEN ELLIS Fifth Applicant

ANDROBB JOHN RIDL Sixth Applicant

ANDROYAL COMMISSION ON THE PIKE RIVER COAL MINE TRAGEDY

First Respondent

ANDHER MAJESTY'S ATTORNEY- GENERAL

Second Respondent

ANDDEPARTMENT OF CONSERVATION Third Respondent

ANDTHE LABOUR GROUP OF THE MINISTRY OF BUSINESS, INNOVATION AND EMPLOYMENT (FORMERLY THE DEPARTMENT OF LABOUR)

Fourth Respondent

ANDFAMILIES OF THE DECEASED Fifth Respondent

ANDMINISTRY FOR THE ENVIRONMENT Sixth Respondent

JOHN ALAN STUART DOW V ROYAL COMMISSION ON THE PIKE RIVER COAL MINE TRAGEDY HC WN CIV 2012-485-1441 [17 September 2012]

ANDTHE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT GROUP OF THE MINISTRY OF BUSINESS, INNOVATION AND EMPLOYMENT (FORMERLY THE MINISTRY OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT)

Seventh Respondent

ANDNEW ZEALAND AMALGAMATED ENGINEERING, PRINTING & MANUFACTURING UNION INC Eighth Respondent

ANDNEW ZEALAND POLICE Ninth Respondent

ANDPIKE RIVER COAL MINE LIMITED (IN RECEIVERSHIP)

Tenth Respondent

Hearing:         3 - 4 September 2012

Counsel:         S B W Grieve QC, A Horne and A Gordon for Applicants

A J F Wilding for First Respondent

C Gwyn, D Soper and A Williams for Second, Third, Fourth, Sixth, Seventh and Ninth Respondents

N R W Davidson QC and J Mills for Fifth Respondent
K N Hampton QC for Eighth Respondent
No Appearance for Tenth Respondent

Judgment:      17 September 2012

JUDGMENT OF RONALD YOUNG J

Introduction

[1]      On 19 November 2010 an explosion occurred at the Pike River Coal Mine. At the time 31 men were underground.  Two escaped, the other men did not.  There was a second explosion at the mine on 24 November 2010.  By that stage the men were considered to be dead.

[2]      On 14 October 2010 the Government released the terms of reference for a Royal Commission of Inquiry (the Commission) into the tragedy.   The terms of reference were much wider than just a direct inquiry into the causes of the tragedy. They involved an inquiry into the search and rescue operation that followed the explosions, consideration of existing relevant law, and its administration and implementation.

[3]      The  Commissioner  was  also  invited  to  make  recommendations  relating directly to the future of mining for the prevention of similar disasters and more generally for the safety of miners.  The Commission is currently required to provide its report to the Governor-General by 28 November 2012.

[4]      The applicants in these proceedings are all past employees or Board members of Pike River Coal Limited which owned and operated the mine at the time of the disaster.   That company is now in receivership.   The applicants have been jointly represented at the inquiry and were also in these proceedings.

[5]      After  the  close  of  hearings  before  the  Commission  on  4 April 2012  the Commission continued to receive further evidence.  In particular and as relevant to this case, it received briefs of evidence from three past employees of Pike River Coal,  Mr Udo  Renk,  Mr Terrence  Moynihan  and  Mr Greg…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dow v Royal Commission on the Pike River Coal Mine Tragedy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2404
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned the legal challenge by six former directors and managers of Pike River Coal Mine Limited against the Royal Commission of Inquiry into the Pike River Coal Mine Tragedy in relation to their natural justice rights and the publication of the Commission’s final report. The applicants claimed that the Commission had breached natural justice by not reconvening hearings to allow cross-examination of witnesses and not delaying the publication of its report to allow them to review adverse findings. The applicants also sought to challenge the Commission’s adverse findings process.

The High Court held that the Commission had not breached natural justice. The Commission had followed its process consistently throughout the inquiry and had allowed the applicants to file reply evidence and make further submissions. The evidence in question was not new but rather was an elaboration of issues already covered by evidence given by other witnesses. The applicants had not provided a basis for reopening the hearings and the Commission was entitled to decide that question based on the further evidence and submissions together with its knowledge of how the issues raised by those witnesses had previously been dealt with at the hearing. The Court also held that the Commission had provided an opportunity to respond to allegations and any further opportunity was speculative. The Commission was not required to provide a draft of its report to participants to comply with natural justice. Finally, the Court held that the publication of the Commission’s report did not constitute contempt of court and the publication of the report should not be delayed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established