IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE
CIV 2018-485-972
[2021] NZHC 3340
BETWEEN DOVEY AVIATION CONSULTING LIMITED
Plaintiff
AND
THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL OF NEW ZEALAND
First Defendant
JAMES PATRICK RANKIN
Second DefendantWARBIRDS OVER WANAKA AIRSHOWS LIMITED
Third Defendant
EDWARD RICHARD MILES TAYLOR
Fourth DefendantCHRISTOPHER CHARLES LEE
Fifth DefendantRONALD JOHN DAVID LAMONT
Sixth DefendantALLEN VICTOR HOGAN
Seventh Defendant
Hearing: 29 November 2021 Counsel:
C S Chapman for Plaintiff
J A MacGillivray for First and Second Defendants M S Anderson for Third to Seventh Defendants
Judgment:
7 December 2021
JUDGMENT OF MALLON J
(Stay application)
DOVEY AVIATION CONSULTING LIMITED v THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL OF NEW ZEALAND [2021]
NZHC 3340 [7 December 2021]
Introduction
[1] The plaintiff company brought a negligence claim against the defendants for damage sustained to its Yak-3M aircraft at the 2018 Warbirds over Wanaka airshow. It was successful and was awarded damages of $708,975 (inclusive of GST) plus interest in a judgment delivered on 9 March 2021 (the substantive judgment).1 A costs order of $250,014.81 plus interest was made in the plaintiff’s favour in a judgment dated 28 May 2021 (the costs judgment).2
[2] On 7 and 8 April 2021 respectively, the first and third defendants filed an appeal against the substantive judgment. While there is no appeal against the costs judgment, success on the appeal against the substantive judgment may led to a revisiting of the costs judgment. The first and third defendants seek an order staying the execution of both judgments pending the appeal. The plaintiff opposes the application.
[3] At the outset of the hearing, counsel for the first and third defendants advised that their respective clients would consent to there being a condition of a stay that the defendants would jointly and severally indemnify the plaintiff for any increase in repair costs post the date of the substantive judgment. The defendants submit that a stay subject to such a condition provides an outcome that is fair to everyone because it preserves each party’s position. The parties have subsequently agreed the terms of such an indemnity if a stay is to be granted in a consent memorandum dated 2 December 2021.
Principles
Substantive judgment
[4] Rule 20.10 of the High Court Rules 2016 provides the Court with the power to order a stay pending appeal:
1 Dovey Aviation Consulting Ltd v The Attorney-General [2021] NZHC 429.
2 Dovey Aviation Consulting Ltd v The Attorney-General [2021] NZHC 1224.
(a)r 20.10(1) provides that an appeal does not operate as a stay of the enforcement of any judgment or order appealed against; and
(b)r 20.10(2) provides that, despite r 20.10(1), a court “may” on application order a stay of enforcement of any judgment or order appealed against.
[5] The “may” in r 20.10(2) means that the Court has a discretion. It is well- established that, in exercising this discretion, the Court is required to balance the right of the successful party to the fruits…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Dovey Aviation Consulting Limited v Attorney-General and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NZHC 3340
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues the court was required to decide were whether the appeal may be rendered nugatory by the lack of a stay, whether the successful party may be injuriously affected by the stay, the strength of the appeal, and the overall balance of convenience. The court found that the defendants did not genuinely intend to prosecute their appeal. The court also found that there is no suggestion the defendants do not genuinely intend to prosecute their appeal. They continue to hold the view that the plaintiff was wholly or partly responsible for the accident and the outcome of the appeal will be important to the conduct of airshows going forward. The court found that there is no suggestion that there will be an effect on third parties if a stay is or is not granted. This means that the relevant factors are whether the appeal may be rendered nugatory by the lack of a stay, whether the successful party may be injuriously affected by the stay, the strength of the appeal, and the overall balance of convenience.
The court found that the matters referred to in the judgment provide an evidential basis for legitimate concern that the plaintiff may be unable to repay the judgment sums if the defendants succeed on appeal. The court also found that the plaintiff had understood that the defendants’ principal concern was that if the judgment sum was paid and spent on aircraft expenditure then the expenditure might exceed the increase in value resulting from that expenditure. The plaintiff offered not to make a start on the work if the defendants indemnified the plaintiff against an increase in the cost of repairs. The judgment sum of $708,975 reflected the cost of repairs as at May 2020. The plaintiff has provided an updated estimate from Mr Smith. As at July 2021 he estimates that the cost of repairs had increased by between $71,000 to $106,000. This well exceeds interest on the judgment sum. The court found that because of this concern that the defendants now propose that a stay be subject to the condition of an indemnity (in the form the parties have agreed). Because the defendants will provide this indemnity, the prejudice to the plaintiff from increased repair costs if a stay is granted is removed.
Balancing the various factors, the court found that the overall justice favours a stay of execution of the substantive judgment subject to the condition set out as an appendix to the consent memorandum dated 2 December 2021. The court also found that the overall justice does not favour a stay of execution of the costs judgment.
The court granted the application for an order staying execution of the Court’s substantive judgment subject to the condition set out as an appendix to the consent memorandum dated 2 December 2021. The court dismissed the application for an order staying execution of the Court’s cost judgment. The costs on this application are to lie where they fall. The defendants have succeeded in part but subject to a condition that was offered only at the hearing. Overall, both parties have had a measure of success on the application.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi