Dorn Investments Limited v Hoover

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

CIV-2016-419-000015 [2016] NZHC 1325

BETWEEN

DORN INVESTMENTS LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

PAUL HOOVER Defendant

Hearing: 9 June 2016

Counsel:

DJ Chisholm QC for Plaintiff
DM O'Neill and S Kennedy for Defendant

Judgment:

17 June 2016

JUDGMENT OF ASHER J

This judgment was delivered by me on Friday, 17 June 2016 at 4.30 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:

Claymore Partners Ltd, Auckland.

DJ Chisholm QC, Auckland. Cooney Law, Cambridge.

DM O’Neill, Hamilton.

DORN INVESTMENTS LTD v HOOVER [2016] NZHC 1325 [17 June 2016]

Introduction

[1]      The  plaintiff,  Dorn  Investments  Ltd,  applies  for  an  interim  injunction restraining the defendant, Paul Hoover, from breaching a restraint of trade clause.

[2]      Dorn Investments Ltd (Dorn Investments) is a franchisee of Green Acres Franchise Group Ltd (Green Acres) and has an exclusive licence to operate the Green Acres Lawnmowing and Garden Care Services in a mapped territory which approximately corresponds to the Waikato region.   Dorn Investments has sub- franchised approximately 14 independent sub-franchises in that Waikato territory, providing lawn and gardening services to approximately 1,500 customers.  The sub- franchisees are called contractors.

[3]      The  defendant  Paul  Hoover  is  approximately  60  years  old  and  has  a background as a rigger and truck driver.  He has some medical issues, and lives in Te Awamutu, in a home owned by a trust he settled, in which there is approximately an equity of $60,000.  His other assets are chattels and vehicles used for his business worth about $35,000.

[4]      On or about 23 January 2013, he entered into a sub-franchise agreement with Dorn Investments.  The agreement provided at cl 9.6 that Mr Hoover would not do anything that would prejudicially affect the goodwill of the business.  At cl 16.1 it contained the following restraint of trade clause:

Non Competition  In consideration for the grant of the franchise (and any prior franchises relating to the Contractor’s Business) to the Contractor by the   Franchisee   at   the   Contractor’s   and   Guarantor’s   request,   and   in recognition of the resultant significant financial opportunities for the Contractor and Guarantor, the Contractor and the Guarantor will not at any time during the Term or for a period of two years following the expiration or termination of this agreement be interested in any business the same as, or similar to or in competition with the Business within New Zealand.  Without limitation, the Contractor or a Guarantor will be in breach of this clause if they either  individually or in conjunction  with any person, as  principle, agent, shareholder or otherwise, advise, lend money to, guarantee the debts or obligations of, or permit the names of the Contractor or the Guarantor (or any part of those names) to be used or employed by or associated with, any person that is engaged in or concerned with or interested in any business the same  as,  or similar  to  or in  competition  with the Business  within  New Zealand.  …

[5]      Mr  Hoover  paid  $36,000  plus  GST as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dorn Investments Limited v Hoover and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 1325
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dorn Investments Limited, the plaintiff, sought an interim injunction against Paul Hoover, the defendant, to prevent him from breaching a restraint of trade clause in their sub-franchise agreement. The agreement, which granted Hoover a sub-franchise to operate lawn and gardening services under the Green Acres brand in the Waikato region, included a clause prohibiting Hoover from engaging in similar businesses within New Zealand for two years after the agreement's termination. The plaintiff argued that Hoover had breached this clause by starting a competing business under the name 'The Lawn Ranger'. The court had to determine whether there was a serious question to be tried regarding the breach and whether, if such a question existed, the balance of convenience favoured granting an interim injunction.

The court found that there was indeed a serious question to be tried regarding the breach of the restraint of trade clause. The clause, while potentially unreasonable in its geographic scope, was likely enforceable within the Waikato territory. However, the court also considered whether Hoover had a credible defence to the restraint of trade claim. Hoover argued that he had not received promised training and that the plaintiff had unfairly removed a significant portion of his business by terminating the contract for maintaining courthouse lawns and gardens. The court found these arguments to have some merit, particularly the claim that the removal of the courthouse work could constitute a repudiation of the contract by the plaintiff, potentially making the restraint of trade clause unenforceable. Given this arguable defence, the court assessed the balance of convenience and concluded that the overall justice favoured not granting the interim injunction. Hoover's potential loss of livelihood and reputation outweighed the plaintiff's need for immediate protection. Consequently, the application for an interim injunction was dismissed, and the plaintiff was ordered to pay the defendant's costs and reasonable disbursements.