Donovan v Lynskey HC Auckland CIV 2006-406-293

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND BLENHEIM REGISTRY

CIV-2006-406-293

BETWEEN  PATRICK DONOVAN First Plaintiff

ANDPATRICK DONOVAN (AS TRUSTEE OF THE DONOVAN TRUST)

Second Plaintiff

ANDKATHERINE FAY LYNSKEY First Defendant

ANDKATHY LYNSKEY WINES LIMITED Second Defendant

Judgment:      9 August 2010 at 12.30 pm

DECISION OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE D.I. GENDALL

This judgment was delivered by me

on 9 August 2010 at

12.30 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Solicitors:           Gascoigne Wicks, Solicitors, PO Box 2, Blenheim

Radich Law, Solicitors, PO Box 842, Blenheim

PATRICK DONOVAN AND ANOR V KATHERINE FAY LYNSKEY AND ANOR HC BLE CIV-2006-406-

293  9 August 2010

[1]      On 26 March 2010 the second defendant in this proceeding filed a Notice of

Discontinuance of the counter-claim it had brought earlier against the first plaintiff.

[2]      The first plaintiff now seeks costs against the second defendant as a result of that discontinuance.   In a Minute I issued on 10 May 2010 regarding this costs question I noted the various memoranda and submissions on costs which had been received from counsel and acknowledged that the second defendant wished to have a further opportunity to file and serve what it described as “comprehensive” submissions on the issue of costs.

[3]      That Minute then directed that those submissions from the second defendant were to be filed and served by 24 May 2010 with the plaintiff having an opportunity by 7 June 2010 to file and serve any final reply submissions.

[4]      Counsel for the second defendant did avail himself of that opportunity to file those further “comprehensive” submissions on costs.   They were filed on 24 May

2010.

[5]      Counsel for the first plaintiff then filed his submissions in reply on 4 June

2010.

[6]      All submissions have now been referred to me for a decision to be made on the  costs  question.    I  apologise  to  the  parties  and  to  counsel  for  the  delay  in providing this decision – I was away on leave for the period 31 May 2010 to 23 July

2010 and have only just been provided with counsels’ various submissions. [7]       I now address the costs question based upon all the material filed.

[8]      In doing so, I note that the first plaintiff seeks costs on a Category 2B scale basis on the discontinued counter-claim from the second defendant which he calculates at $15,250.00.   In addition, disbursements as fixed by the Registrar are sought.  Any award of costs at this point is opposed by the second defendant.  Its counsel, Mr Radich, contends that these costs should be reserved to be dealt with at the conclusion of the hearing of the plaintiff’s substantive claim.  But in any event, if

costs are to be imposed now, Mr Radich in his submissions takes issue strongly with the quantum sought by the first plaintiff.

[9]      It is also significant and regrettable, in my view, at this stage to note the substantial number and length of submissions I have received from counsel on what is  a  relatively straight  forward  costs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Donovan v Lynskey HC Auckland CIV 2006-406-293 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 1403
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Donovan v Lynskey before the High Court of New Zealand in Blenheim Registry concerns a dispute where the first plaintiff, Patrick Donovan, and the second plaintiff, Patrick Donovan as trustee of the Donovan Trust, are suing the first defendant, Katherine Fay Lynskey, and the second defendant, Kathy Lynskey Wines Limited. The second defendant has discontinued a counter-claim against the first plaintiff, and the first plaintiff is seeking costs associated with this discontinuance. The legal issues revolve around whether the presumption that the discontinuing party must pay costs up to the point of discontinuance, as outlined in rule 15.23 of the High Court Rules, should apply and, if so, the appropriate quantum of those costs.

The court addressed these issues by first considering the presumption in rule 15.23, which states that unless otherwise agreed or ordered by the court, a plaintiff who discontinues a proceeding must pay the defendant's costs up to and including the discontinuance. The court noted that this presumption may be displaced if the circumstances of the case make a different costs outcome just and equitable. The court found that this case did not present circumstances warranting a departure from the presumption. The second defendant had instituted a counter-claim and then, upon challenge, decided to discontinue that action. The court concluded that there was no reason to deviate from the normal principle that costs on a discontinuance should be awarded against the discontinuing party.

Regarding the quantum of costs, the court considered the submissions from both parties. The first plaintiff had sought costs of $15,250.00, which included expenses for document discovery, inspection, and case management conferences. The court found that only a fraction of the claimed discovery and inspection costs were justifiable, awarding $1,000.00 for these items. Additionally, the court awarded $500.00 for filing memoranda and $500.00 for appearing at case management conferences related to the counter-claim. The total costs awarded to the first plaintiff were $7,120.00, along with disbursements as fixed by the Registrar.

In summary, the court ruled that the presumption in rule 15.23 applies and awarded the first plaintiff $7,120.00 in costs, along with disbursements, as a result of the second defendant's discontinuance of the counter-claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established