DNZ Forest Products (2009) Limited v Gisborne District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND GISBORNE REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TŪRANGANUI-A-KIWA ROHE

CRI-2020-416-13

[2020] NZHC 2437

BETWEEN DNS FOREST PRODUCTS (2009) LIMITED
Appellant

AND

GISBORNE DISTRICT COUNCIL

Respondent

Hearing: 16 September 2020

Counsel:

M Atkinson for appellant V C Brewer for respondent

Judgment:

18 September 2020


JUDGMENT OF ELLIS J


[1]    In the first half of June 2018, the Gisborne region experienced a significant storm. Heavy rain over a number of days upheaved large amounts of logging debris and carried it onto roads and landings. Forestry waste flowed onto and into neighbouring properties, water bodies, and coastal areas across the region. The environmental impact was significant.

[2]    DNS Forests Products (2009) Limited (DNS) later pleaded guilty to a charge under s 338(1)(a) of the Resource Management Act 1991 (the RMA) of contravening or permitting the contravention of s 15(1)(b) of that Act. The contravention here involved the discharge of contaminants—slash, logging debris, waste logging material, and forestry waste—onto land in circumstances where it then entered water.

DNS FOREST PRODUCTS (2009) LIMITED v GISBORNE DISTRICT COUNCIL [2020] NZHC 2437 [18

September 2020]

Judge Dwyer declined DNS’ application for a discharge without conviction;1 he sentenced DNS to a fine of $124,700 and ordered reparation of $6,500.2

[3]DNS now appeals that decision.

Background

Makiri Forest and the resource consent

[4]    Makiri Forest is a 493 ha plantation forest about 38 km from Gisborne in the headwaters of the Waihora Valley. As Judge Dwyer noted in the District Court, the area is particularly vulnerable:

[17]   … about 90 percent of Makiri Forest falls within Land Overlay 3 of the Gisborne Regional Rules, being land areas most susceptible to erosion, sediment generation and soil loss in the region, an area which is well known for its vulnerability to significant weather events. The need for absolute compliance with best forestry practice in terms of resource consents when harvesting such land is overwhelmingly obvious.

[18]      Even when these requirements are followed there is a high degree of risk of slope failure and forestry waste mobilisation during (and for a period of some years after) harvesting. Forest owners or harvesters undertaking harvesting operations in these conditions are at real risk no matter how careful they are.

[5]    Since early 2017, the Makiri forest has been owned by South Pacific Forestry Holdings Ltd (South Pacific). DNS was, effectively, the company responsible for the forestry operation on the land. Both South Pacific and DNS are wholly owned and controlled by Mr Daning Sun.

[6]    On 9 November 2016, the Gisborne District Council (the Council) granted DNS a land use resource consent that allowed the formation of 11.1 km of roads, the construction of 28 landings and pads, the harvesting of 398 ha of trees, and the extraction of logs. The conditions of that resource consent included that:

(a)On slopes greater than 25 degrees, fill used in compaction of road and landing formations or sidecast to waste was to be held in place by benching, compaction,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DNZ Forest Products (2009) Limited v Gisborne District Counc... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 2437
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

DNS Forest Products (2009) Limited appeals against its conviction and sentence in the Gisborne District Court for contravening a condition of its resource consent under the Resource Management Act 1991. DNS was found to have contravened a condition of its consent that prohibited the discharge of contaminants into water. The contravention resulted from the discharge of forestry waste into water following heavy rainfall in June 2018. DNS was sentenced to a fine of $124,700 and ordered to pay $6,500 in reparation. DNS appeals against the refusal of the District Court to discharge it without conviction and against the level of the fine.

The primary issue in this appeal is whether the District Court erred in refusing DNS a discharge without conviction by failing to properly apply the parity principle. DNS argues that the District Court failed to properly consider consistency in the treatment of DNS, Logic, and A&R, and that the refusal to discharge DNS without conviction was wrong because the parity principle applies, there is nothing special about being the consent holder, and the effluxion of time after A&R leaving the site does not reduce Logic and A&R’s culpability.

The Court held that the parity principle has no application in this case. Neither A&R nor Logic have been convicted of any offence, and so are not “other offenders.” Furthermore, the Court held that it was not in any way obvious that DNS was less culpable than A&R and Logic. DNS’ status as the consent holder meant that it was ultimately responsible for compliance with the resource consent. The Court also held that DNS was not charged vicariously, but rather on the basis of its own failure to take steps to prevent a contravention of the resource consent. The Court agreed with the District Court that DNS was extremely careless in leaving the skid sites in an unsatisfactory state for five months, and that DNS had ample opportunity to rectify any shortcomings. The Court held that the sentence imposed was not manifestly excessive and fell within the appropriate range.

The appeal is dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established