Director-General of Health v Lowe

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA169/2015
[2016] NZCA 369

BETWEEN

DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF HEALTH, MINISTRY OF HEALTH
First Appellant

CHIEF EXECUTIVE, CAPITAL AND COAST DISTRICT HEALTH BOARD
Second Appellant

AND

JANET ELSIE LOWE
Respondent

Hearing:

23 June 2016

Court:

Harrison, Wild and French JJ

Counsel:

J C Holden and M J R Conway for Appellants
P Cranney and A McInally for Respondent

Judgment:

1 August 2016 at 3.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AWe answer the question of law submitted for determination by this Court:

“Was the respondent a ‘homeworker’, as that term is defined by s 5 of the Employment Relations Act 2000, and therefore an employee of the first and second appellants, when she undertook support care pursuant to the Carer Support Scheme?”

No.

BThe appeal is allowed and the decision of the Employment Court quashed.

CCosts are to lie where they fall.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by French J)

Introduction

  1. Under the Employment Relations Act 2000 (the Act), the term “employee” includes a “homeworker”,[1]  as defined by s 5.  Section 5 states:

    homeworker­—

    (a)means a person who is engaged, employed, or contracted by any other person (in the course of that other person’s trade or business) to do work for that other person in a dwellinghouse (not being work on that dwellinghouse or fixtures, fittings, or furniture in it); and

    (b)includes a person who is in substance so engaged, employed, or contracted even though the form of the contract between the parties is technically that of vendor and purchaser.

    [1]Employment Relations Act 2000, s 6(1)(b)(i).

  2. The question for determination in this appeal is whether the respondent, Ms Lowe, comes within this definition when undertaking relief care pursuant to a government programme known as the Carer Support Scheme.  A Full Court of the Employment Court held Ms Lowe was a homeworker within the meaning of s 5 and so deemed to be an employee to whom obligations were owed under the Act and under other employee protection legislation, such as the Minimum Wage Act 1983 and the Holidays Act 2003.[2]

    [2]Lowe v Director-General of Health, Ministry of Health [2015] NZEmpC 24.

  3. The Ministry of Health (the Ministry) and the Capital and Coast District Health Board (the DHB), both of which fund the Carer Support Scheme, now appeal the decision.

Factual background

  1. The purpose of the Carer Support Scheme is to provide respite to persons who provide unpaid full time care to a person with a disability.  Typically, the full time carer is a member of the disabled person’s family who is willing to provide a level of care that enables the disabled person to continue living in their own home.  The Carer Support Scheme aims to give the full time carer a break from full time care by assisting with the cost of a relief carer for a specified number of days per year based on a needs assessment.

  2. Eligibility for carer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director-General of Health v Lowe and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZCA 369
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Director-General of Health v Lowe involved the question of whether Ms Lowe, who provided relief care under the Carer Support Scheme, was a "homeworker" as defined by the Employment Relations Act 2000. The appeal was brought by the Ministry of Health and the Capital and Coast District Health Board, who fund the Carer Support Scheme, against the decision of the Employment Court that Ms Lowe was a homeworker and therefore an employee of the appellants. The appeal was heard by the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, with French J delivering the judgment.

The legal issue before the court was whether Ms Lowe, when undertaking support care under the Carer Support Scheme, was engaged, employed, or contracted by the appellants within the meaning of the definition of "homeworker" in s 5 of the Employment Relations Act 2000. The court considered whether the mere fact that Ms Lowe was engaged in relief care, rather than piecework, could exclude her from the definition of homeworker. The court also considered the purpose of including homeworkers as employees, which was to prevent the exploitation of vulnerable workers working at home.

The court held that Ms Lowe was not a homeworker within the meaning of the Employment Relations Act 2000. The court found that neither the Ministry nor the DHB had any role in selecting the relief carer or arranging the timing, nature, or extent of the support to be provided. The court also found that the full time carer would be free to select an organisation such as a rest home provider rather than an individual like Ms Lowe, and that the relief carer had no relationship with the appellants prior to or while carrying out the work.

The court held that the Carer Support Scheme can fairly be described in substance as a subsidy, and that if Ms Lowe was engaged by anyone, it must be the full time carer. The court found that the degree of autonomy enjoyed by the full time carer was inconsistent with the existence of any agency. The court also found that the appellants did not engage Ms Lowe within the meaning of s 5 of the Act, as the word "engage" requires that the person doing the engaging take an active role in both the selection and oversight or control of the work of the particular individual whose status is at issue.

The appeal was allowed and the decision of the Employment Court quashed. Costs were to lie where they fell, as the parties had agreed that, this being in the nature of a test case, there should be no award of costs regardless of outcome.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established