Dilworth v Pirie

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE PAPAIOEA ROHE

CIV-2022-454-091

[2024] NZHC 1321

BETWEEN

SARAH ANN DILWORTH

First Plaintiff

CHRISTOPHER IAN REDPATH
Second Plaintiff

AND

CAROL ANN PIRIE, as executor of the estate of William John Redpath

First Defendant

CAROL ANN PIRIE

Second Defendant

Hearing: 8 & 9 April 2024

Counsel:

G M Richards for Plaintiffs M Freeman for Defendants

Judgment:

24 May 2024


JUDGMENT OF GRAU J


A loan by a son to his parents in 1994 and what, if anything, remains owing on it

[1]In 1994 a son, Ian Redpath, loaned his parents, William and Caroline Redpath,

$127,000 to enable them to purchase a new home where they could spend their retirement in greater comfort (the Loan). William and Caroline signed a Deed of Acknowledgement of Debt in respect of the Loan (the Loan Deed).

DILWORTH v PIRIE [2024] NZHC 1321 [24 May 2024]

[2]                 The parties to the Loan, Ian, William, and Caroline, are now all deceased. Caroline passed away in 2001, Ian passed away in 2017, and William passed away in 2021.1

[3]                 Ian’s final will did not forgive the 1994 Loan to his parents.2 Ian gifted it in equal shares to his children, Sarah and Christopher, with a direction that his children would not seek payment from their grandfather until six months after his passing. Sarah and Christopher honoured their father’s wishes. Ian’s estate received $100,000 from William’s estate on 20 January 2022 following correspondence between the parties’ lawyers.

[4]                 At issue in this case is what, if anything, William’s estate still owes in respect of the Loan:

(a)The plaintiffs, Sarah and Christopher, say William’s estate still owes the remaining $27,000 of the Loan principal, along with interest on the unpaid Loan balance, going back to 1994.

(b)The defendant, Ian’s sister Carol, is the executor of William’s estate. She says that the $27,000 portion of the Loan was payable and was repaid to Ian in 1994, some 28 years before this claim was commenced. The claim for repayment of the $27,000 is time-barred.

(c)Christopher and Sarah also say that interest at 10 per cent per annum has accrued on the unpaid Loan balance and this accrued interest became payable when it was demanded on 8 December 2021.

(d)Carol says no interest is owing because cl 4 of the Loan Deed is what is known as a “Marshall clause”, meaning that interest did not accrue unless and until it was demanded within 14 days of the anniversary of the Loan each year. Ian never demanded interest therefore no interest was payable or is owed now. But, even if interest was payable absent


1      This decision refers to the family members by their first names. No discourtesy is intended. It is solely for ease of reference.

2      Ian’s final will is dated 16 February 2010.

a demand (so that it accrued on the Loan), all but $50,000 of interest would be time-barred.

The Loan and Deed of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dilworth v Pirie and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 1321
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Dilworth v Pirie before Grau J in the High Court of New Zealand, Palmerston North Registry, concerned the repayment and interest on a loan of $127,000 made by Ian Redpath to his parents, William and Caroline Redpath, in 1994. The primary dispute was whether the $27,000 portion of the loan was repaid and if any interest was owing on the remaining balance of $100,000. The plaintiffs, Sarah and Christopher, Ian's children, argued that the $27,000 was never repaid and that interest accrued from 1994 until it was demanded in 2021. Conversely, the defendant, Carol Pirie, as the executor of William's estate, maintained that the $27,000 was repaid in 1994 and no interest was payable because it had never been demanded.

The court examined the Loan Deed, which stipulated the repayment of the $27,000 on the sale of the Birmingham Street unit and interest payable annually if demanded. The court found that documentary evidence, including correspondence from Mr. Hubbard, Ian's parents' lawyer, and settlement statements, strongly indicated that the $27,000 was repaid to Ian in 1994. The court also concluded that the interest clause in the Loan Deed functioned as a "Marshall clause," meaning interest only accrued if demanded annually. Since Ian never demanded interest, no interest was payable.

The court ruled that the plaintiffs' claims were time-barred for the $27,000 portion of the loan, and no interest accrued on the remaining balance of $100,000 as it was never demanded. Consequently, Carol Pirie was entitled to costs, with the parties required to agree on the quantum or submit memoranda for a final costs award.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established