Di-Giandomenico v Accident Compensation Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2015-485-000275 [2015] NZHC 2193

BETWEEN

ALESSIO DI-GIANDOMENICO

Appellant

AND

ACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION

Respondent

Hearing: 12 August 2015

Counsel:

H G de Groot and J M Miller for Appellant
C J Hlavac for Respondent

Judgment:

11 September 2015

JUDGMENT OF COLLINS J

Introduction

[1]      I am allowing the appeal and remitting the case back to the District Court for reconsideration as to whether Alessio Di-Giandomenico (Alessio) was entitled to cover under the Accident Insurance Act 1998 for medical misadventure based upon medical mishap.

[2]      I have reached this conclusion because in my assessment the District Court did not address questions of causation in accordance with the principles articulated by the Court of Appeal in Accident Compensation Corporation v Ambros.1

[3]      The rehearing in the District Court is confined to the issue of whether Alessio suffered a medical mishap.  Further evidence will be required to determine whether

Alessio’s circumstances meet the statistical requirements of being a rare adverse

1      Accident Compensation Corporation v Ambros [2007] NZCA 304, [2008] 1 NZLR 340.

DI-GIANDOMENICO v ACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION [2015] NZHC 2193 [11 September

2015]

consequence of treatment within the meaning of s 37(3) of the Accident Insurance

Act 1998.

Background

[4]      Alessio was born at Tauranga Hospital on 3 August 1999.  When he was born Alessio was assessed as being in a “flat and floppy” state and not breathing.  The midwife, Ms Easton, attempted to stimulate Alessio into breathing with a warm towel and by placing an oxygen catheter under his nose.   Ms Williams, a second midwife arrived. At that point it was realised Alessio would need to be transferred to a resuscitation room.  Ms Easton cut and clamped the umbilical cord.  Ms Williams took Alessio to the resuscitation room and a paediatrician was summoned.

[5]      In the resuscitation room Ms Williams attempted to resuscitate Alessio using an oxygen bag and valve mask.   There is an issue about how much time passed before this was done.  In the District Court, Judge Ongley found there was a delay of “about two minutes until [Alessio was] bagg[ed] with oxygen”.2

[6]      Dr Lawrence, the on-call paediatrician arrived and intubated Alessio.  There is also an issue about how long that process took.  Judge Ongley found that there was a delay of approximately “5 minutes until intubation by Dr Lawrence”.3

[7]      Alessio did not start breathing independently until approximately 25 minutes after resuscitation was commenced.  He was admitted to the Special Care Baby Unit at Starship Children’s Hospital.

[8]      On 6 October 2000, an MRI Report concluded Alessio had:4

cerebral  white  matter,  basal  ganglion  and  thalmalic  abnormalities  which

[were] in keeping with a previous hypoxic event.

[9]      Alessio  has  cerebral  palsy  and  spastic  quadriplegia.    He  is  significantly disabled and requires assistance with most aspects of his day-to-day life.

2      Giandomenico by his parents v Accident Compensation Corporation [2007] NZACC 71 at [62].

3 At [62].

4      MRI Report, Starship Children’s Hospital, 6 October 2000.

[10]     In October…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Di-Giandomenico v Accident Compensation Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 2193
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Di-Giandomenico v Accident Compensation Corporation, the appellant, Alessio Di-Giandomenico, appealed the District Court's decision that he was not entitled to cover under the Accident Insurance Act 1998 for medical misadventure based on medical mishap. The central issue in the appeal was whether Alessio's physical injuries were caused by medical error or medical mishap. The High Court found that the District Court had applied an overly stringent test for causation in relation to the resuscitation delays. The court held that the District Court did not address the causation issues in line with the principles articulated by the Court of Appeal in Accident Compensation Corporation v Ambros. The appeal was allowed, and the case was remitted back to the District Court for reconsideration of whether Alessio's physical injuries were the consequence of medical misadventure through medical mishap. The High Court also noted that further evidence would be required to determine whether Alessio's circumstances met the statistical requirements of being a rare adverse consequence of treatment within the meaning of s 37(3) of the Accident Insurance Act 1998.

The legal issues the court was required to decide were whether Alessio's physical injuries were caused by medical error or medical mishap under the Accident Insurance Act 1998. The court found that there was insufficient evidence to establish any medical error in the way Alessio's labour was managed or in the way he was treated following his birth. In terms of medical mishap, the court found that the District Court had not considered Alessio's claim on the basis of it being medical misadventure through medical mishap. The court held that the District Court would need to reconsider the issue of causation in light of the principles set out in Accident Compensation Corporation v Ambros.