DGL Manufacturing Limited (formerly Chempro NZ Limited) v Simmonds

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2018-404-167

[2023] NZHC 607

BETWEEN

DGL MANUFACTURING LIMTED

(formerly CHEMPRO NZ LIMITED) Plaintiff

AND

RODNEY WAYNE SIMMONDS

Defendant

SIMON HENRY

Second Counterclaim Defendant

Hearing: 7 March 2022

Appearances:

G A Cooper for the Plaintiff and Second Counterclaim Defendant R B Hucker and M W Swan for the Defendant/Counterclaim

Plaintiff

Judgment:

27 March 2023


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE BRITTAIN


This judgment was delivered by me on 27 March 2023 at 3.00 pm, pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:

Solicitors/Counsel:

Hucker & Associates, Auckland Cavell Leitch, Auckland

DGL MANUFACTURING LTD v RODNEY WAYNE SIMMONDS [2023] NZHC 607 [27 March 2023]

Introduction

[1]        The substantive claim underlying this proceeding arises from a series of transactions between:

(a)a group of companies associated with the second counterclaim defendant, Simon Henry, including the plaintiff, DGL Manufacturing Ltd, formerly known as Chempro NZ Ltd (the plaintiff and its related companies are collectively referred to as “DGL”); and

(b)a   group   of   companies   associated   with    the    defendant, Rodney Simmonds, including Chemsafe Manufacturing Ltd, Chemsafe Group Ltd, DEF Sales Ltd, Chemsafe Logistics Ltd and Let It Grow Ltd. All are either in liquidation or removed from the Companies Register except for Chemsafe Logistics Ltd (these companies are collectively referred to as “Chemsafe”).

[2]        The transactions resulted in DGL acquiring the various businesses of Chemsafe, including the business related to the manufacturing and supply of a product known as AdBlue and the business related to the supply of warehousing services to a third party, Redox.

[3]        The transactions evolved over several years. The agreements between the parties were documented in several contracts, correspondence between the parties’ advisors, and according to Mr Simmonds, were partly oral. That gives rise to a complicated background, which I need not set out in full. For ease of reference, I refer to the transactions and agreements between the parties as “the arrangements”.

[4]        Mr Simmonds’ case is that the businesses were transferred to DGL in three parts:

(a)DGL acquired the AdBlue manufacturing side of the business in September 2016;

(b)DGL next acquired the business of supplying warehousing services to Redox. This included DGL assuming obligations for leased premises required to operate this business, and acquiring fixed assets of Chemsafe in situ on the leased premises; and

(c)DGL lastly acquired the retail side of the AdBlue business following a meeting between Mr Henry and Mr Simmonds on 14 February 2017. Mr Simmonds alleges that various oral agreements were made at that meeting.

[5]        DGL sues Mr Simmonds as guarantor of alleged warranties as to the standard and performance of various assets acquired by DGL pursuant to the arrangements. Mr Simmonds has counterclaimed, alleging that DGL failed to perform various obligations owed to Chemsafe, which I discuss further below. The extent of the obligations owed by DGL to Chemsafe is disputed.

[6]        The substantive proceeding is set down for trial on 4 September 2023.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DGL Manufacturing Limited (formerly Chempro NZ Limited) v Si... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 607
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

DGL Manufacturing Limited (formerly Chempro NZ Limited) brought proceedings against Rodney Simmonds, who was a director of a group of companies that sold their businesses to DGL. Simmonds counterclaimed, alleging that DGL failed to perform obligations owed to the selling companies. Simmonds now seeks further discovery from DGL. DGL opposes the application and argues that the discovery sought is too broad and too late. The substantive proceeding is set down for trial on 4 September 2023. The close of pleadings date was 31 August 2021. The application for further discovery was filed on 21 October 2022. In DGL Manufacturing Limited (formerly Chempro NZ Limited) v Simmonds, Associate Judge Brittain considered the application for further discovery. The judge found that while the application was late, leave to bring it could be granted because it would not prejudice the trial. The judge noted that the application was made in the context of an elaborate commercial transaction that was documented in numerous contracts and correspondence between the parties' advisors and which was partly oral. The counterclaim raised by Simmonds was based on the alleged failure by DGL to pay various debts owed by the selling companies, and the failure to take over certain assets. The counterclaim also included a claim for personal loss by Simmonds as a result of DGL's alleged breaches. The proposed evidence of the parties' experts focused on the value of the Chemsafe companies at the time of the transaction, if DGL had met its alleged obligations. The proposed evidence of the expert for Simmonds relied on a spreadsheet prepared by DGL that recorded the debits and credits on settlement. The proposed evidence of the expert for DGL suggested that the amounts claimed in the counterclaim were not substantiated by the supporting documents provided during the discovery process. The judge noted that the need to substantiate the value of the transactions that ground the counterclaim ought to have been apparent to Simmonds when his counterclaim was first conceived. The judge noted that the queries raised by the expert for DGL regarding a lack of source documents to substantiate claims, and the various requests by Simmonds for further discovery that followed, could be traced back to two key documents created by the parties during, or shortly after, the settlement of the arrangements in 2017. The judge noted that in broad terms, the issues that must be resolved were whether the interests of justice require further discovery of source documents relevant to some of those line items, and if so, whether the scope of that discovery could be confined to ensure proportionality and to ensure that the trial date in September 2023 was not put in jeopardy. The judge noted that categories (i), (vii) and (viii) in essence sought all source accounting documents that underlie all of the debits and credits in the spreadsheet and the expert's analysis of it. This included all accounting records, systems and ledgers of Chemsafe. The request for discovery in categories (i), (vii) and (viii) was so broad as to amount to a request for standard discovery. Given the extent of the discovery that had already been provided, and the failure to particularise readily ascertainable classes of documents and how they might be relevant, the request came too late. If such an order was made it would be oppressive. It would also prejudice the trial. The judge noted that categories (ii), (iii), (iv), (v) and (vi) also required consideration. The judge noted that category (ii) sought discovery of documents that would evidence the state of the Chemsafe creditors ledger at the relevant time. Given the state of Simmonds' pleading, it was not clear whether Simmonds intended to take a different approach and seek compensation for the value of the unpaid creditors. Given that uncertainty, limited discovery of documents that would evidence the state of the Chemsafe creditors ledger at the relevant time was reasonable. The relevant invoices may fall within a broad date range. An arbitrary limit must be set, and 1 January 2017 was a suitable start date. In addition to the allegedly unpaid invoices from creditors, there was potentially a range of accounting source documents that might be relevant to a full audit of the amount due to each of the creditors, such as statements issued by the creditors and records of payments made by Chemsafe. The judge noted that categories (iv), (v) and (vi) involved a series of transactions that were described as line items in the wash-up. The judge noted that one of the Chemsafe companies, DEF Sales Ltd, supplied goods to DGL. The counterclaim alleged that the unpaid value of the invoices was $426,312.95. In his proposed evidence, the expert for DGL stated that he was unable to conclude whether the goods were received by DGL. The judge noted that the proposed evidence of the expert for DGL put in issue whether the invoiced supplies were received by DGL. DGL may still hold records relevant to the issue of whether the supplies were ordered and received, or that otherwise evidenced the state of the running account in respect of the supplies. All of those documents should be made available. The judge noted that category (iii) sought documents relating to ANZ bank, one of the Chemsafe creditors, but it was not included in the counterclaim. The documents that related to ANZ were not relevant. There was no evidence of Chemsafe obligations to ANZ that DGL failed to pay. The reference to 'any other lender' was too vague. Discovery in respect of Chemsafe creditors should be confined to those creditors listed in the counterclaim. The judge noted that category (vi) sought discovery of an ill-defined category of documents that somehow related to the expert's suggestion, and therefore to the analysis of whether the debits and credits involved in the settlement of the arrangements constituted payment for the Wiri assets. Once again, this request for further discovery was ill-defined and too broad. The discovery requested was unnecessary to resolve the issue of whether the Wiri assets were in effect paid for by the net result of the various debits and credits between the parties on settlement. The judge noted that category (vii) sought discovery of the 'additional summary of the funds' sent as an attachment to an email from Simmonds' solicitors to DGL's solicitors. This attachment ought to be on DGL's solicitors' file, and should be provided. The judge noted that category (viii) sought discovery of documents that recorded the running account between supplier and customer in respect of the alleged supply of products from DGL to Chemsafe which totalled $35,611.46. There appeared to be no further information regarding that transaction before the court at present. The amount of this transaction was modest, which suggested that the range of documents available should not be significant, and all within DGL's possession as the supplier. These documents should be made available. The judge noted that the interests of justice required further discovery of source documents relevant to some of those line items. The scope of that discovery could be confined to ensure proportionality and to ensure that the trial date in September 2023 was not put in jeopardy. The judge made orders for further discovery in respect of certain classes of documents. Costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established