Devoy v Goldex International Services Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-001313 [2013] NZHC 103

BETWEEN  ELI DEVOY First Plaintiff

ANDAKIKO ITO Second Plaintiff

ANDALIREZI NOROUZY Third Plaintiff

ANDDANA OMIDVAR Fourth Plaintiff

ANDHASSAN AREFI Fifth Plaintiff

ANDSACHITO SHIOZAWA Sixth Plaintiff

ANDZOHREH AZIMI Seventh Plaintiff

ANDGOLDEX INTERNATIONAL SERVICES LIMITED

First Defendant

ANDHAJI ABD RAHMAN AWG HAJI DAMIT

Second Defendant

ANDDEMIN SERGEY VLADIMIROVICH Third Defendant

Hearing:         On the papers

Counsel:         M W Ryan for Plaintiffs

Judgment:      7 February 2013

JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J

DEVOY & ORS V GOLDEX INTERNATIONAL SERVICES LTD & ORS HC AK CIV-2012-404-001313 [7

February 2013]

[1]     The plaintiffs have sued the defendants alleging financial loss through investments  made  by  them  in  reliance  on  misrepresentations  by  the  second defendant, Haji Damit.   It is alleged that Mr Damit made the representations on behalf of himself, the first defendant, Goldex International Services Limited, and the third defendant, Demin Sergey Vladimirovich.  In July 2012 the plaintiffs obtained judgment by way of formal proof against Goldex and Mr Damit.   At that stage, Mr Vladimirovich, who lives in Russia, had not been served.

[2]      In December 2012, with Mr Vladimirovich still not served, the plaintiffs applied for a freezing order against him on a without notice basis seeking to freeze funds held by an unrelated company, Velocity Trading Limited, on Mr Vladimirovich’s behalf.  Katz J refused that application on the basis that there was insufficient evidence on which to find that there existed a good arguable case against him that would justify such an order. The plaintiffs now apply afresh, with further evidence put before the Court in an affidavit by one of them, Hassan Arefi. An undertaking as to damages has also been filed.

[3]      Under r 32.2 of the High Court Rules the Court may make a freezing order restraining the disposition of assets either within or outside New Zealand.   The settled requirements for a freezing order are:[1]

(a)       There is a good arguable case against the defendant;

(b)Assets exist either inside or outside the jurisdiction to which the order can apply;

(c)       There is a risk that the assets will be dissipated;

(d)      The plaintiffs provide an undertaking of the damages.

[4]     In the Statement of Claim it is alleged that Mr Damit made various representations to the effect that he, Goldex and Mr Vladimirovich were specialist investment traders in the international gold market, that the plaintiffs would benefit from substantial returns if they invested their money with the defendants and that they would be guaranteed against any loss.  The plaintiffs claim that they invested money with Goldex  in November 2011 in reliance on those representations but subsequently suffered substantial losses.  Although Mr Vladimirovich had not been served with the proceedings there had been correspondence with him about the plaintiffs’ claims; Russian lawyers wrote on his behalf denying that he had ever been an investment adviser or involved in gold market trading and had not authorised…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Devoy v Goldex International Services Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 103
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, including Eli Devoy, Akiko Ito, Alirezi Norouzy, Dana Omidvar, Hassan Aref and Sachito Shiozawa, have sued the defendants, Goldex International Services Limited, Haji Abd Rahman AWG Haji Damit and Demin Sergey Vladimirovich, alleging financial loss through investments made by them in reliance on misrepresentations by Haji Damit. The plaintiffs claim they invested money with Goldex in November 2011 in reliance on the representations made by Haji Damit but subsequently suffered substantial losses. Although Mr Vladimirovich had not been served with the proceedings, there had been correspondence with him about the plaintiffs’ claims. The plaintiffs applied for a freezing order against Mr Vladimirovich on a without notice basis seeking to freeze funds held by an unrelated company, Velocity Trading Limited, on Mr Vladimirovich’s behalf. Katz J had previously refused that application on the basis that there was insufficient evidence on which to find that there existed a good arguable case against Mr Vladimirovich that would justify such an order. The plaintiffs applied afresh, with further evidence put before the Court in an affidavit by one of them, Hassan Arefi. An undertaking as to damages has also been filed.
The court was required to determine whether the plaintiffs had satisfied the settled requirements for a freezing order under r 32.2 of the High Court Rules. The court needed to consider whether there was a good arguable case against Mr Vladimirovich, whether assets existed either inside or outside the jurisdiction to which the order could apply, whether there was a risk that the assets would be dissipated and whether the plaintiffs had provided an undertaking of the damages. The court was also required to consider the significance of the evidence provided by Mr Arefi and whether there was reason to think that Haji Damit had authority to make representations on behalf of Mr Vladimirovich, open bank accounts and generally deal with matters on his behalf in New Zealand.
The court found that the plaintiffs had satisfied the settled requirements for a freezing order. The court was satisfied that there was a good arguable case against Mr Vladimirovich, that assets existed either inside or outside the jurisdiction to which the order could apply, that there was a risk that the assets would be dissipated and that the plaintiffs had provided an undertaking of the damages. The court was also satisfied that there was reason to think that Haji Damit had authority to make representations on behalf of Mr Vladimirovich, open bank accounts and generally deal with matters on his behalf in New Zealand. The court concluded that the evidence provided by Mr Arefi showed that Mr Vladimirovich had authorised Haji Damit to act on his behalf and that Mr Damit had acted on Mr Vladimirovich’s behalf by opening a margin trading account at Velocity Trading Limited in the name of Sergey Demin. The court was also satisfied that the risk of dissipation was significant because there was evidence that approximately NZ$430,000 was held by Velocity Trading Ltd in an account for Mr Vladimirovich and that there was an email indicating that that money was at risk of being moved. The court therefore made the freezing order in the terms sought at paragraph 1 of the application dated 31 January 2013.
The final orders were that a freezing order be made in the terms sought at paragraph 1 of the application dated 31 January 2013.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.