Det Norske Veritas As v The Ship "Clarabelle"

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND CA 66/02

BETWEEN   DET NORSKE VERTAS AS

Appellant

AND            THE SHIP CLARABELLE

Respondent  

Hearing: 28 May 2002
Coram: McGrath J
Hammond J
Panckhurst J
Appearances: P W David & S J Park for Appellant
E W Gartrell & D M McKnight for Respondent
Judgment: 10 June 2002

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY PANCKHURST J

Introduction

  1. This is a relatively unusual appeal in admiralty proceedings.  The appellant had the ship Clarabelle arrested for non-payment of a survey account rendered by it.  Security was claimed in a sum of $125,000 in accordance with the established formula viz., the “reasonably arguable best case”.  After receiving representations from the parties the Registrar released the vessel for a sum significantly less than would have been encompassed by that formula.  The appellant then applied to re-arrest the vessel to secure what it regarded as the proper figure for security, in accordance with the established authorities.  The application was declined on the footing that, in exercising its inherent jurisdiction in admiralty, the High Court has a very broad discretion.  The appellant now appeals to this court on the grounds that the Judge in so proceeding was wrong in law, and failed to follow the established (and narrower) admiralty principles.  The appellant further maintains that a failure to adhere to these principles would give rise to significant commercial inconvenience, and be out of line with accepted international admiralty practice.

Factual Background

  1. DNV is a Norwegian based classification society which provides annual surveys to keep vessels in class throughout the world.  The Clarabelle is a New Zealand owned and registered vessel.  Its owner, Straight Arrow Holdings Limited, is based in Wellington and conducts a fishing business using several vessels including the Clarabelle.

  2. In January 2001, DNV undertook an annual survey of the Clarabelle at Capetown, South Africa.  On 6 February 2001, it rendered an invoice for US$23,029.19 for its services.  The contractual terms provided for payment within 30 days, failing which interest may be charged at 24% per annum.  Payment was not forthcoming.

  3. In late August the vessel owners wrote to DNV complaining that the level of charge was excessive for the survey of a vessel of this size, 38 meters in length.  A reduction was sought, in part on the basis that Straight Arrow Holdings Limited was “struggling” and could not afford to pay the account.  DNV responded with a demand for payment in terms of s.289 of the Companies Act 1993.  The owners on 25 October moved to set aside the statutory demand.  By this stage, it had been discovered that a holding tank on the Clarabelle was leaking and the vessel had been slipped for repairs at Nelson earlier in the month.  The owners asserted that the problem was one which should have been detected in the course of survey when it could have been attended to with comparatively little disruption.

  4. On 26 November in the High Court at Wellington, DNV, in light of the affidavit…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Det Norske Veritas As v The Ship "Clarabelle" and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] NZCA 129
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Det Norske Veritas As, a Norwegian classification society, sought to arrest the vessel Clarabelle, owned by Straight Arrow Holdings Limited, a New Zealand company, for non-payment of an invoice for services rendered. The dispute arose from the assessment of the security required to release the vessel from arrest, with DNV seeking a higher amount than the Registrar had ordered. The core legal issue was whether the High Court judge had erred in law by exercising a broad discretion in setting the security amount, instead of adhering to the established principle of assessing security based on the reasonably arguable best case of the claimant.

The Court of Appeal found that the High Court judge had misapplied the law by considering factors unrelated to the established admiralty principles. The court clarified that the assessment of security in admiralty cases should be based on the claimant's reasonably arguable best case, unless there are exceptional circumstances warranting a deviation from this standard. The appeal court held that the judge's approach was too broad and not in line with the narrow and well-established principles governing security in admiralty cases. The court concluded that the appeal should be allowed, and the vessel should be re-arrested unless additional security of $51,072.26 was provided within two days. The appellant was granted leave to appeal and awarded costs in the sum of $3,500, with the reasonable expenses of the appeal to be settled by the Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established