| IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND |
| SC 30/2015 [2015] NZSC 85 |
| BETWEEN | DEREK NICHOLAS BLACKWELL AND CHARLES BASIL BLACKWELL as Executors and Trustees of the Estate of ROSS WINSTON BLACKWELL |
| AND | LEITH ROGER CHICK AND ROSEMARY CHICK |
| AND | EDMONDS JUDD |
| Court: | William Young, Glazebrook and Arnold JJ |
Counsel: | C T Gudsell QC for the Applicants |
Judgment: | 19 June 2015 |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
AThe application for leave to appeal in CA 481/2013 is dismissed.
BCosts of $2,500 are payable by the applicants to the first respondents.
CThe application for leave to appeal in CA 476/2013 is granted.
DThe approved question is whether the Court of Appeal was correct in its conclusion that, on the findings in the High Court, the negligence of the second respondent caused no loss.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS
The applicants, Derek and Charles Blackwell, apply for leave to appeal against a judgment of the Court of Appeal.[1] The Court of Appeal judgment dealt with two appeals arising from a single High Court judgment:[2] the first appeal (CA 481/2013) dealt with affirmative defences (lack of mental capacity and unconscionability); the second appeal (CA 476/2013) dealt with the issue of whether Edmonds Judd, the second respondent and a firm of solicitors, was negligent and caused the loss to the applicants.[3]
[1]Blackwell v Chick [2015] NZCA 34 (Ellen France P, Randerson and Harrison JJ) [Blackwell (CA)].
[2]Chick v Blackwell [2013] NZHC 1525 (Rodney Hansen J) [Blackwell (HC)].
[3]There was also a cross appeal in CA 481/2013 by the first respondents claiming against Edmonds Judd in the event the applicants succeeded.
In relation to the appeal in CA 481/2013, the Court of Appeal upheld the High Court decision that the applicants’ brother, the late Ross Blackwell (Ross), had sufficient mental capacity at the time he entered into a number of impugned transactions with the first respondents, the Chicks.[4] In addition, and in agreement with the High Court, the Court of Appeal held that there was no basis for the applicants’ claims that the impugned transactions constituted unconscionable bargains.[5] In relation to the appeal in CA 476/2013, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and held that while Edmonds Judd, the second respondent, was negligent, the applicants had failed to show that this negligence had caused any loss.[6] The cross appeal in CA 481/2013 was dismissed.[7]
Background
[4]See Blackwell (CA), above n 1, at [22]–[66].
[5]See [67]–[83].
[6]See [84]–[120].
[7]At [83].
The applicants’ brother, Ross, was diagnosed with a brain tumour in 2000 and received radiotherapy. Over the following years, the tumour and treatment had a detrimental impact on his cognitive ability. There was evidence that MRI scans from 2001 to 2007 showed that, as a result of the radiotherapy treatment, Ross was suffering rational encephalopathy (or softening of the brain). One of the experts opined that this would have produced “irreversible cognitive decline and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Derek Nicholas Blackwell v Leith Roger Chick and Rosemary Ch... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] NZSC 85
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The applicants submitted that the Courts were presented with two competing bodies of evidence and failed to assess the Chicks’ evidence properly and therefore placed too much reliance on it. They argued that both the High Court and the Court of Appeal failed to assess the Chicks’ evidence properly and therefore placed too much reliance on it. The applicants also submitted that, while the general legal principles as to causation are not in dispute, the Court of Appeal made a number of errors in applying those principles in the present case.
The Court considered that leave should be granted on the issue of causation. The Court found that there was no legal question of general or public importance arising. The challenges sought to be made related to the particular factual circumstances, where there are concurrent findings in the courts below. The Court found that the applicants had failed to show that this may be one of those rare cases where there have been such apparent and substantial errors that it would be repugnant to justice to leave them uncorrected.
The Court dismissed the application for leave to appeal in CA 481/2013, with costs of $2,500 payable by the applicants to the first respondents. The Court granted the application for leave to appeal in CA 476/2013 and the approved question is whether the Court of Appeal was correct in its conclusion that, on the findings in the High Court, the negligence of the second respondent caused no loss.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi