Department of Corrections v Taylor

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA318/2008
[2009] NZCA 129

BETWEENTHE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS


Appellant

ANDARTHUR WILLIAM TAYLOR


First Respondent

ANDTHE VISITING JUSTICE AT AUCKLAND PRISON


Second Respondent

Hearing:16 February 2009

Court:Ellen France, Harrison and Cooper JJ

Counsel:V E Casey for Appellant


First Respondent in person
No appearance for Second Respondent
H D M Lawry as amicus curiae

Judgment:8 April 2009 at 2.30 pm 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed and the decisions of the hearing adjudicator dated 25 October 2007 and that of the Visiting Justice of 30 January 2008 are reinstated.

BNo order for costs.

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Ellen France J)

Table of Contents

PARA NO

Introduction  [1]
Issues on appeal  [7]
Factual background   [8]
The decision of the High Court  [14]
The statutory scheme  [21]

First issue: must the hearing adjudicator hold a hearing before referral
     under s 134(2)(a)?
  [42]

Second issue: ability to consider previous history  [60]
Third issue: relief  [69]
Disposition  [70]
Costs  [71]

Introduction

[1]       The first respondent, Arthur Taylor, is a prisoner at Paremoremo Prison.  In October 2007 he was charged with an offence against prison discipline after a search of his cell disclosed a cell phone charger.  The matter was brought before a hearing adjudicator.  The adjudicator decided to refer the case to a Visiting Justice under s 134 of the Corrections Act 2004.

[2]       Mr Taylor was found guilty after a hearing before a Visiting Justice.  He was sentenced to ten days confinement in his cell and 35 days loss of privileges.

[3]       Mr Taylor brought judicial review proceedings which alleged, amongst other matters, breach of natural justice by the hearing adjudicator in deciding to refer the case to a Visiting Justice.

[4] In a decision now reported at [2008] NZAR 613, Wylie J concluded the adjudicator breached the principles of natural justice in determining without hearing Mr Taylor that the case should be referred to a Visiting Justice. The Judge also considered the adjudicator took into account an irrelevant consideration when he decided that Mr Taylor’s previous breaches of prison discipline were relevant to the decision under s 134. Wylie J set aside the hearing adjudicator’s decision.

[5]       The Department of Corrections appeals against Wylie J’s decision.  The second respondent abides the decision of the Court.

[6]       We note that an earlier hearing of this matter before the permanent Court was adjourned at Mr Taylor’s request.  He said that without access to computer facilities he had been unable to adequately prepare his submissions.  The hearing was rescheduled to coincide with the hearing of another appeal involving Mr Taylor and to meet the appellant’s concern that the hearing not be unduly delayed.  In adjourning the matter, the Court decided that an amicus should be appointed.  Mr Lawry was subsequently appointed as amicus.

Issues on appeal

[7]       The appeal raises three issues:

(a)Is it necessary for the hearing adjudicator to hold a hearing before…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Department of Corrections v Taylor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NZCA 129
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Department of Corrections has appealed a decision of Wylie J, who found that the hearing adjudicator had breached the principles of natural justice by deciding to refer the matter to a Visiting Justice without holding a hearing. The Court of Appeal has allowed the appeal and reinstated the decisions of the hearing adjudicator and the Visiting Justice. The key issues on appeal were whether the hearing adjudicator was required to hold a hearing before referring the case to a Visiting Justice under s 134(2)(a) of the Corrections Act 2004, whether the hearing adjudicator was entitled to consider the prisoner’s previous history, and what relief should be granted. The Court of Appeal held that there was no requirement in the Act or the Regulations that a hearing must be held before the decision to refer under s 134(2)(a) is made and the hearing adjudicator was entitled to consider the prisoner’s previous history in determining the seriousness of the matter. The Court also held that the decision to refer was not a breach of the Act, the Regulations, the principles of natural justice or of any rights arising under the Bill of Rights. The decisions of the hearing adjudicator and the Visiting Justice were reinstated and the penalties imposed on Mr Taylor stand. The Court made no order for costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

In October 2007, Arthur Taylor, a prisoner at Paremoremo Prison, was charged with an offence against prison discipline after a search of his cell revealed a cell phone charger. The matter was brought before a hearing adjudicator who decided to refer the case to a Visiting Justice under section 134 of the Corrections Act 2004. The referral was based on the seriousness of the offence. Taylor was subsequently found guilty by the Visiting Justice and was sentenced to ten days of confinement in his cell and 35 days loss of privileges. Taylor then brought judicial review proceedings, alleging, among other things, a breach of natural justice by the hearing adjudicator in deciding to refer the case without holding a hearing. The High Court found in Taylor's favour, concluding that the hearing adjudicator had breached the principles of natural justice and set aside the adjudicator's decision. The Department of Corrections appealed against the High Court's decision.

The matter was initially heard in the High Court where Wylie J concluded that the hearing adjudicator had breached the principles of natural justice by deciding to refer the case to a Visiting Justice without holding a hearing. The High Court also found that the adjudicator had taken into account an irrelevant consideration when deciding that Taylor's previous breaches of prison discipline were relevant to the decision under section 134. As a result, the adjudicator's decision was set aside. The Department of Corrections appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is it necessary for the hearing adjudicator to hold a hearing before referring cases to a Visiting Justice under section 134(2)(a)?
2. Were Taylor's earlier breaches of prison discipline irrelevant to the decision under section 134?
3. Should the decision under section 134 have been set aside?

Held
1. The appeal is allowed. The decisions of the hearing adjudicator dated 25 October 2007 and that of the Visiting Justice of 30 January 2008 are reinstated.
2. It is not necessary for the hearing adjudicator to hold a hearing before referring cases to a Visiting Justice under section 134(2)(a) of the Corrections Act 2004.
3. The hearing adjudicator was entitled to consider the prisoner's previous history in determining the seriousness of the matter under section 134(2)(a).
4. No order for costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered three issues in this case. Firstly, the Court held that it is not necessary for the hearing adjudicator to hold a hearing before referring cases to a Visiting Justice under section 134(2)(a) of the Corrections Act 2004. The Court found that neither the Act nor the Regulations required a hearing, and that the principles of natural justice and the Bill of Rights did not demand one either. The Court held that the statutory scheme provided sufficient protections, and that any disadvantage to the prisoner could be remedied when the matter came before the Visiting Justice.

Secondly, the Court held that the hearing adjudicator was entitled to consider the prisoner's previous history in determining the seriousness of the matter under section 134(2)(a). The Court found that the reference to "conduct" in the section did not restrict consideration to the actus reus of the offence. Instead, factors such as previous history which would be relevant to the assessment of the gravity of the offending and potential penalty should be considered. This approach was consistent with the legislative policy of moving away from a list of specified offences to a more general discretion.

Lastly, the Court did not address the issue of relief, as it had already decided that no hearing was required and that the hearing adjudicator did not err when considering the prisoner's past conduct. The Court reinstated the decisions of the hearing adjudicator and the Visiting Justice and made no order for costs.